{"base": "0005_relight_neon_cyberpunk_illuminat_180fa0b098bb", "edited_type": "relight", "prompt": "Change the lighting to neon cyberpunk illumination from the right. Preserve the original scene content, motion, camera movement, object identity, and materials. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_relight_videocof_base", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The lighting is not neon cyberpunk. The video is severely blown-out, with extreme flickering and loss of identity.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0004_relight_neon_cyberpunk_illuminat_0f852d21fd8a", "edited_type": "relight", "prompt": "Change the lighting to neon cyberpunk illumination from the upper left. Preserve the original scene content, motion, camera movement, object identity, and materials. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_relight_videocof_base", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit is extremely blurry and overexposed, and does not resemble the requested neon cyberpunk lighting style.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0037_relight_a_soft_crimson_red_glow_1aaf26e75e42", "edited_type": "relight", "prompt": "Light the scene with a soft crimson red glow shining in from the lower left. Preserve the original scene content, motion, camera movement, object identity, and materials. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_relight_videocof_base", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The lighting is blue, not the requested crimson red. People's identities and scene details are drastically altered.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0000_relight_soft_studio_lighting_0731564136e7", "edited_type": "relight", "prompt": "Change the lighting to soft studio lighting from the upper right. Preserve the original scene content, motion, camera movement, object identity, and materials. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [2, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_relight_videocof_base", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The lighting direction is correct, but it's harsh, not soft. The background is completely blown out.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0030_relight_warm_fireplace_light_19f917c422c5", "edited_type": "relight", "prompt": "Change the lighting to warm fireplace light from the upper left. Preserve the original scene content, motion, camera movement, object identity, and materials. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_relight_videocof_base", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit failed to produce warm fireplace light, instead creating a heavily artifacted and posterized video.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0035_relight_a_noticeable_magenta_ill_07100a9ebaaf", "edited_type": "relight", "prompt": "Give the video a noticeable magenta illumination, falling from the left side. Preserve the original scene content, motion, camera movement, object identity, and materials. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [2, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_relight_videocof_base", "raw": "Brief reasoning: Scene content is heavily changed, turning it into a cartoon. Lighting is incorrect.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0018_relight_underwater_blue_green_il_0a7e06d8836f", "edited_type": "relight", "prompt": "Change the lighting to underwater blue-green illumination from the upper left. Preserve the original scene content, motion, camera movement, object identity, and materials. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_relight_videocof_base", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The lighting style is incorrect. The edit is extremely blurry, washing out all detail and changing materials.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0003_relight_cool_blue_moonlight_11c3341944f0", "edited_type": "relight", "prompt": "Change the lighting to cool blue moonlight from the lower left. Preserve the original scene content, motion, camera movement, object identity, and materials. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_relight_videocof_base", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The lighting is pink, not blue, and comes from the wrong direction. The video is severely overexposed.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0001_relight_soft_studio_lighting_15f3a72606b5", "edited_type": "relight", "prompt": "Change the lighting to soft studio lighting from the lower left. Preserve the original scene content, motion, camera movement, object identity, and materials. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [2, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_relight_videocof_base", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The lighting direction is somewhat correct but not soft. The video has severe artifacts and the background is removed.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0040_relight_film_noir_venetian_blind_0abf01de82ca", "edited_type": "relight", "prompt": "Make the lighting film noir venetian-blind shadows, with the light arriving from the lower left. Preserve the original scene content, motion, camera movement, object identity, and materials. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_relight_videocof_base", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit is a single static frame and does not follow the lighting instruction or preserve content.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0019_relight_underwater_blue_green_il_04a52af9c265", "edited_type": "relight", "prompt": "Change the lighting to underwater blue-green illumination from the right. Preserve the original scene content, motion, camera movement, object identity, and materials. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_relight_videocof_base", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit is severely overexposed and blown out, with incorrect color and no clear lighting direction.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0043_relight_an_intimate_romantic_moo_0effb4857b41", "edited_type": "relight", "prompt": "Light the scene with an intimate romantic moonbeam glow shining in from the front, lighting the subject head-on. Preserve the original scene content, motion, camera movement, object identity, and materials. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_relight_videocof_base", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit is an overpowering pink glow that blows out all detail, not a romantic moonbeam.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0009_relight_soft_candlelight_0a030bae3ffd", "edited_type": "relight", "prompt": "Change the lighting to soft candlelight from the upper right. Preserve the original scene content, motion, camera movement, object identity, and materials. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [4, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_relight_videocof_base", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The requested lighting is well-applied, but the video is blurry and the man's face is noticeably smoothed.\nInstruction Compliance: 4\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3"}
{"base": "0036_relight_a_strong_navy_blue_glow_0f7c57ef4e36", "edited_type": "relight", "prompt": "Make the lighting a strong navy blue glow, with the light arriving from below. Preserve the original scene content, motion, camera movement, object identity, and materials. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [2, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_relight_videocof_base", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit adds incorrect yellow light from above and has severe flicker, artifacts, and detail changes.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0017_relight_green_fluorescent_indoor_072085a78d3a", "edited_type": "relight", "prompt": "Change the lighting to green fluorescent indoor lighting from the lower left. Preserve the original scene content, motion, camera movement, object identity, and materials. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_relight_videocof_base", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The lighting is pink/purple, not green. The edit severely degrades image quality, distorting colors and details.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0049_relight_a_soft_mint_green_illumi_0030f0174823", "edited_type": "relight", "prompt": "Make the lighting a soft mint green illumination, with the light arriving from the front, lighting the subject head-on. Preserve the original scene content, motion, camera movement, object identity, and materials. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_relight_videocof_base", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit applied a harsh red light, not the requested soft mint green. The quality is extremely poor.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0002_relight_cool_blue_moonlight_1a4b2f87c863", "edited_type": "relight", "prompt": "Change the lighting to cool blue moonlight from the right. Preserve the original scene content, motion, camera movement, object identity, and materials. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_relight_videocof_base", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit applied warm light from the left, not cool blue light from the right. The video is blurry.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0028_relight_nightclub_magenta_and_cy_05bf565eec34", "edited_type": "relight", "prompt": "Change the lighting to nightclub magenta and cyan lighting from the upper right. Preserve the original scene content, motion, camera movement, object identity, and materials. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [2, 2, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_relight_videocof_base", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit applies a cartoonish filter, not nightclub lighting, and heavily distorts the background and materials.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2"}
{"base": "0032_relight_warm_bedroom_lamp_light_17c1847962e0", "edited_type": "relight", "prompt": "Change the lighting to warm bedroom lamp light from the right. Preserve the original scene content, motion, camera movement, object identity, and materials. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_relight_videocof_base", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit is extremely blown out and has unrealistic colors, not warm lamp light. Many details are changed.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0042_relight_futuristic_holographic_s_126277f52b8c", "edited_type": "relight", "prompt": "Give the video futuristic holographic sci-fi glow, falling from above. Preserve the original scene content, motion, camera movement, object identity, and materials. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_relight_videocof_base", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit is an unrelated high-contrast filter, not the requested holographic glow. Visual quality and details are severely degraded.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0044_relight_a_soft_diffused_foggy_gl_1b451b5b211d", "edited_type": "relight", "prompt": "Give the video a soft, diffused foggy glow, falling from the right side. Preserve the original scene content, motion, camera movement, object identity, and materials. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_relight_videocof_base", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit is extremely overexposed with a strong color cast, not a soft foggy glow.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0029_relight_nightclub_magenta_and_cy_094da103a61d", "edited_type": "relight", "prompt": "Change the lighting to nightclub magenta and cyan lighting from the lower right. Preserve the original scene content, motion, camera movement, object identity, and materials. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_relight_videocof_base", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The lighting style and direction are completely wrong. The video is too dark, losing significant scene detail.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0048_relight_a_vibrant_honey_gold_glo_1a78ab3028a9", "edited_type": "relight", "prompt": "Give the video a vibrant honey gold glow, falling from behind the subject, as a backlight. Preserve the original scene content, motion, camera movement, object identity, and materials. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_relight_videocof_base", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit is a severe, unusable filter, not a backlight. It destroys all scene details and identity.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0033_relight_bright_blue_neon_street__0993e01706ba", "edited_type": "relight", "prompt": "Light the scene with bright blue neon street lighting shining in from the left side. Preserve the original scene content, motion, camera movement, object identity, and materials. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_relight_videocof_base", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit applied an artistic filter, not the requested blue neon lighting. It severely degraded quality and changed scene details.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0022_relight_cinematic_noir_lighting_1746b4c87ca1", "edited_type": "relight", "prompt": "Change the lighting to cinematic noir lighting from the upper right. Preserve the original scene content, motion, camera movement, object identity, and materials. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_relight_videocof_base", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit is just extremely overexposed and color distorted, completely unrelated to the requested noir lighting.\nInstruction Compliance: 1.\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1.\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1."}
{"base": "0041_relight_harsh_industrial_fluores_17a446893954", "edited_type": "relight", "prompt": "Light the scene with harsh industrial fluorescent lighting with sparks from welding shining in from behind the subject, as a backlight. Preserve the original scene content, motion, camera movement, object identity, and materials. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_relight_videocof_base", "raw": "Brief reasoning: Edit fails to add requested lighting, has severe flicker, and heavily alters the cars and background.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0015_relight_golden_hour_sunlight_0507a79f6878", "edited_type": "relight", "prompt": "Change the lighting to golden-hour sunlight from the lower left. Preserve the original scene content, motion, camera movement, object identity, and materials. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_relight_videocof_base", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The video is extremely blurry, destroying all detail and making the text unreadable. The lighting direction is also incorrect.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0008_relight_sci_fi_rgb_glowing_light_19e1af60ee46", "edited_type": "relight", "prompt": "Change the lighting to sci-fi RGB glowing light from the left. Preserve the original scene content, motion, camera movement, object identity, and materials. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_relight_videocof_base", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The lighting is not sci-fi RGB. The entire scene is heavily stylized, losing all original detail and texture.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0024_relight_soft_overcast_daylight_04eaf6f63a96", "edited_type": "relight", "prompt": "Change the lighting to soft overcast daylight from the left. Preserve the original scene content, motion, camera movement, object identity, and materials. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_relight_videocof_base", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The lighting is harsh and stylized, not soft and overcast. The video quality is poor with blown-out colors.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0046_relight_a_warm_sunset_glow_191fd013c751", "edited_type": "relight", "prompt": "Light the scene with a warm sunset glow shining in from the lower right. Preserve the original scene content, motion, camera movement, object identity, and materials. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_relight_videocof_base", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The lighting is an incorrect pink color, not a warm sunset glow. The video has severe artifacts.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0013_relight_dramatic_spotlight_12e7fb0e01f3", "edited_type": "relight", "prompt": "Change the lighting to dramatic spotlight from the upper right. Preserve the original scene content, motion, camera movement, object identity, and materials. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_relight_videocof_base", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The video is completely blown-out, and the text and microphone have been changed, failing all instructions.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0031_relight_warm_fireplace_light_0806de05d8df", "edited_type": "relight", "prompt": "Change the lighting to warm fireplace light from the right. Preserve the original scene content, motion, camera movement, object identity, and materials. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_relight_videocof_base", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit is a uniform red color wash, not fireplace light from the right.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0007_relight_sci_fi_rgb_glowing_light_0c6d518b3bbd", "edited_type": "relight", "prompt": "Change the lighting to sci-fi RGB glowing light from the lower right. Preserve the original scene content, motion, camera movement, object identity, and materials. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [3, 2, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_relight_videocof_base", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The lighting direction is correct, but the video has severe artifacts, especially the unnaturally colored pink lips.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2"}
{"base": "0012_relight_dramatic_spotlight_12b5d54e1c36", "edited_type": "relight", "prompt": "Change the lighting to dramatic spotlight from the left. Preserve the original scene content, motion, camera movement, object identity, and materials. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [2, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_relight_videocof_base", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The entire video is extremely blurry, losing all detail. The requested lighting is not a spotlight.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0038_relight_an_intense_electric_blue_0ca7278bb853", "edited_type": "relight", "prompt": "Give the video an intense electric blue glow, falling from behind the subject, as a backlight. Preserve the original scene content, motion, camera movement, object identity, and materials. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_relight_videocof_base", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit failed to add the requested blue light, instead adding a harsh orange/red light and crushing the blacks.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0016_relight_green_fluorescent_indoor_0ec5168abb65", "edited_type": "relight", "prompt": "Change the lighting to green fluorescent indoor lighting from the right. Preserve the original scene content, motion, camera movement, object identity, and materials. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_relight_videocof_base", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit applied an oversaturated, multi-color glow instead of green lighting, resulting in severe artifacts and color changes.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0011_relight_bright_snowy_reflected_l_005169827ffe", "edited_type": "relight", "prompt": "Change the lighting to bright snowy reflected light from the upper right. Preserve the original scene content, motion, camera movement, object identity, and materials. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_relight_videocof_base", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The lighting is just overexposed, not the requested snowy style. The video has severe artifacts and detail loss.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0020_relight_bright_stage_lighting_144668edac96", "edited_type": "relight", "prompt": "Change the lighting to bright stage lighting from the upper left. Preserve the original scene content, motion, camera movement, object identity, and materials. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_relight_videocof_base", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The lighting is not from the upper left and the edit heavily stylizes the video, destroying details.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0023_relight_cinematic_noir_lighting_138513f3d8cc", "edited_type": "relight", "prompt": "Change the lighting to cinematic noir lighting from the right. Preserve the original scene content, motion, camera movement, object identity, and materials. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [3, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_relight_videocof_base", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The lighting direction is correct, but the video has severe artifacts, blown-out colors, and alters the person's identity.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0021_relight_bright_stage_lighting_193f475c24c3", "edited_type": "relight", "prompt": "Change the lighting to bright stage lighting from the right. Preserve the original scene content, motion, camera movement, object identity, and materials. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [4, 2, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_relight_videocof_base", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The lighting direction and style match the instruction, but the visual quality is poor and important scene details are lost.\nInstruction Compliance: 4\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2"}
{"base": "0045_relight_blazing_yellow_stage_lik_0a2ffc16daca", "edited_type": "relight", "prompt": "Make the lighting blazing yellow stage-like lighting, with the light arriving from the upper left corner. Preserve the original scene content, motion, camera movement, object identity, and materials. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_relight_videocof_base", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The lighting is pink, not yellow. The direction is wrong, and the scene is oversaturated and blown out.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0010_relight_soft_candlelight_05c7a478a954", "edited_type": "relight", "prompt": "Change the lighting to soft candlelight from the lower left. Preserve the original scene content, motion, camera movement, object identity, and materials. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_relight_videocof_base", "raw": "Brief reasoning: Lighting is wrong color and direction. Edit adds severe artifacts and heavily alters materials and subject identity.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0027_relight_natural_outdoor_sunlight_096b2e54be7a", "edited_type": "relight", "prompt": "Change the lighting to natural outdoor sunlight from the lower left. Preserve the original scene content, motion, camera movement, object identity, and materials. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_relight_videocof_base", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit is a complete style change, not natural sunlight. It heavily distorts the scene and introduces severe artifacts.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0039_relight_a_gentle_cream_light_04e902ab47e3", "edited_type": "relight", "prompt": "Make the lighting a gentle cream light, with the light arriving from above. Preserve the original scene content, motion, camera movement, object identity, and materials. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_relight_videocof_base", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The video is severely overexposed, not a gentle cream light. All detail and original colors are lost.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0006_relight_wong_kar_wai_style_warm__00603be92b52", "edited_type": "relight", "prompt": "Change the lighting to Wong Kar-wai style warm neon lighting from the left. Preserve the original scene content, motion, camera movement, object identity, and materials. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [4, 2, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_relight_videocof_base", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The requested lighting style is recognizable but the visual quality is low with unnatural skin texture and color.\nInstruction Compliance: 4\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3"}
{"base": "0014_relight_golden_hour_sunlight_06540b80d80c", "edited_type": "relight", "prompt": "Change the lighting to golden-hour sunlight from the left. Preserve the original scene content, motion, camera movement, object identity, and materials. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [5, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_relight_videocof_base", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit looks like a cartoon. Details and materials are lost, with blown-out highlights.\nInstruction Compliance: 5\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0026_relight_natural_outdoor_sunlight_0a0d9588a7a4", "edited_type": "relight", "prompt": "Change the lighting to natural outdoor sunlight from the lower right. Preserve the original scene content, motion, camera movement, object identity, and materials. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [2, 2, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_relight_videocof_base", "raw": "Brief reasoning: Lighting is from the right, but not low or like sunlight. The entire scene and identities are drastically altered.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0047_relight_a_moderate_teal_light_0da01b08a468", "edited_type": "relight", "prompt": "Light the scene with a moderate teal light shining in from the upper left corner. Preserve the original scene content, motion, camera movement, object identity, and materials. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_relight_videocof_base", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit applied a strong magenta light instead of the requested teal light. Scene details are heavily distorted.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0025_relight_soft_overcast_daylight_061dfcc7e0e0", "edited_type": "relight", "prompt": "Change the lighting to soft overcast daylight from the left. Preserve the original scene content, motion, camera movement, object identity, and materials. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_relight_videocof_base", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit is completely unrelated, creating harsh, hyper-saturated lighting with severe blown-out areas and artifacts.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0034_relight_wet_rain_soaked_city_lig_08d03a3af5c6", "edited_type": "relight", "prompt": "Give the video wet, rain-soaked city light reflections, falling from below. Preserve the original scene content, motion, camera movement, object identity, and materials. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [2, 2, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_relight_videocof_base", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit adds a strong purple glow instead of wet reflections. Background details and text are lost.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2"}