{"base": "0138_background_change_Create_a_dynamic_pir", "edited_type": "background_change", "prompt": "Create a dynamic pirate ship deck background with sails billowing in the wind, ropes swaying gently, and waves lapping against the hull. Include subtle movement of seagulls flying overhead and shifting clouds. The man remains perfectly still in the foreground.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The background was not changed at all; it does not match the pirate ship prompt.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1"}
{"base": "0144_background_change_Place_the_subject_in", "edited_type": "background_change", "prompt": "Place the subject in a lively Mediterranean street market with warm sunlight casting soft shadows, gentle breeze moving awnings and leaves, and distant chatter and footsteps creating a vibrant atmosphere.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: No changes were made to the video; the background is identical to the original video.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1"}
{"base": "0134_background_change_Place_the_subject_in", "edited_type": "background_change", "prompt": "Place the subject in a lively outdoor garden. The background should have gentle motion with leaves rustling in a light breeze, butterflies fluttering, and dappled sunlight shifting through tree branches. The subject remains perfectly still.", "scores": [2, 2, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The background was not replaced, only an overlay of leaves was added to the top.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2"}
{"base": "0127_background_change_Transform_the_backgr", "edited_type": "background_change", "prompt": "Transform the background into a lively French bistro with soft chatter and clinking glasses implied, flickering candlelight on tables, and gentle movement of patrons in the blurred background, while the woman remains perfectly still.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The background was not changed to a bistro; static, poorly integrated elements were added to the original kitchen.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1"}
{"base": "0152_background_change_Transform_the_backgr", "edited_type": "background_change", "prompt": "Transform the background into a dynamic art gallery with soft ambient lighting, occasional flickers from spotlights, and subtle reflections on polished floors. The subject remains static and unchanged.", "scores": [4, 4, 4], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The gallery background matches, but lacks the requested dynamic elements. The edit is clean and visually consistent.\nInstruction Compliance: 4\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 4\nVisual Quality & Stability: 4"}
{"base": "0148_background_change_Replace_the_backgrou", "edited_type": "background_change", "prompt": "Replace the background with a dynamic ship's command bridge scene. Include subtle movements of ocean waves visible through the windows, blinking navigation lights, and soft ambient sounds of the sea and ship machinery. The subject should remain perfectly still.", "scores": [4, 2, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: Background matches prompt, but a very obvious cutout halo and inconsistent lighting degrade the quality significantly.\nInstruction Compliance: 4\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2"}
{"base": "0129_background_change_Replace_the_backgrou", "edited_type": "background_change", "prompt": "Replace the background with a dynamic sky scene filled with slowly drifting pastel cotton candy clouds in pink, lavender, and baby blue hues. Include subtle light rays filtering through the clouds and a gentle breeze causing the clouds to softly shift and morph over time, while the subject remains perfectly still.", "scores": [3, 2, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The background is a static image, not dynamic as requested, and has a noticeable halo around the subject.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2"}
{"base": "0125_background_change_Replace_the_backgrou", "edited_type": "background_change", "prompt": "Replace the background with a dynamic 1970s living room scene. Include subtle flickering of the vintage lamp light, a slow-moving curtain in a gentle breeze, and soft ambient shadows shifting with the light. The child and knitted snake remain perfectly still in the foreground.", "scores": [3, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The background is static; it does not include any of the requested dynamic elements like flickering or movement.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3"}
{"base": "0131_background_change_Transform_the_backgr", "edited_type": "background_change", "prompt": "Transform the background into a modern art gallery. The lighting should subtly shift to highlight different paintings, with occasional soft footsteps and distant murmurs implied. The man in the foreground should remain perfectly still.", "scores": [3, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: Background is an art gallery, but not modern, and the requested dynamic lighting effect is missing.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3"}
{"base": "0136_background_change_Replace_the_backgrou", "edited_type": "background_change", "prompt": "Replace the background with a dynamic classic car showroom scene where soft reflections move subtly on the polished car surfaces, overhead lights gently flicker, and distant footsteps and murmurs create a lively but unobtrusive atmosphere, while the subject and car interior remain perfectly still.", "scores": [4, 4, 4], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit followed the prompt well, creating a dynamic showroom. Minor edge softness is visible on close inspection.\nInstruction Compliance: 4\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 4\nVisual Quality & Stability: 4"}
{"base": "0153_background_change_Replace_the_backgrou", "edited_type": "background_change", "prompt": "Replace the background with a dynamic snowy mountain summit where snowflakes gently fall, clouds drift slowly across the sky, and sunlight glints off the snow. The subject remains perfectly still.", "scores": [2, 2, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The background is static, missing requested dynamic elements. The subject has a clear halo and looks pasted on.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2"}
{"base": "0149_background_change_Replace_the_backgrou", "edited_type": "background_change", "prompt": "Replace the background with a dynamic cozy lounge scene where the fireplace flickers with dancing flames, shadows gently move on the walls, and a soft glow illuminates the room. The subject remains perfectly still.", "scores": [4, 4, 4], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The lounge scene matches the prompt's cozy and dynamic feel. Masking is excellent, especially on the hair and tree.\nInstruction Compliance: 4\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 4\nVisual Quality & Stability: 4"}
{"base": "0147_background_change_Transform_the_backgr", "edited_type": "background_change", "prompt": "Transform the background into a modern art gallery with subtle ambient lighting changes, soft reflections on polished floors, and occasional visitors walking slowly in the distance, creating a calm, cultured atmosphere. The subject remains perfectly still.", "scores": [2, 2, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: Subject is unnaturally frozen. Obvious edge halos are present, and the lighting and scale are inconsistent.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2"}
{"base": "0143_background_change_Replace_the_backgrou", "edited_type": "background_change", "prompt": "Replace the background with a dynamic modern conference room where sunlight streams through glass walls casting moving shadows, distant city traffic noise is implied, and subtle reflections shimmer on the glass surfaces, while the subject remains perfectly still.", "scores": [4, 3, 4], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The conference room background matches the prompt, but the lighting on the subject is inconsistent with the new environment.\nInstruction Compliance: 4\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 4\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3"}
{"base": "0142_background_change_Replace_the_backgrou", "edited_type": "background_change", "prompt": "Replace the background with a dynamic ancient Roman forum. Include subtle movement of fluttering banners, distant crowds milling about, birds flying overhead, and sunlight casting moving shadows across the stone surfaces. The subject should remain perfectly still.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit is incomplete and inconsistent, ignoring subject stillness and dynamic elements. Original background remains visible during motion.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1"}
{"base": "0126_background_change_Replace_the_backgrou", "edited_type": "background_change", "prompt": "Replace the background with a vibrant secret garden balcony scene where gentle breezes cause flowers and vines to sway softly, warm sunlight dapples through leaves creating moving light patterns, and distant birds chirp faintly, while the couple remains perfectly still.", "scores": [3, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit captures the garden theme and warm light, but fails to include the requested background motion.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3"}
{"base": "0123_background_change_Replace_the_backgrou", "edited_type": "background_change", "prompt": "Replace the background with a dynamic garden patio scene where leaves gently sway in a light breeze, bees and butterflies flutter around flowers, and sunlight shifts softly as clouds pass overhead. The subject should remain perfectly still.", "scores": [2, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The original background is still visible through a transparent overlay, creating a messy, unrealistic composite with mismatched lighting.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1"}
{"base": "0124_background_change_Replace_the_backgrou", "edited_type": "background_change", "prompt": "Replace the background with a dynamic ancient Roman forum. Include subtle movements of people walking, fluttering banners, dust motes in the sunlight, and birds flying overhead. The man in the foreground should remain perfectly still.", "scores": [2, 1, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The SEARS logo was incorrectly retained from the original background. The lighting doesn't match, and the subject's cutout is rough.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1"}
{"base": "0151_background_change_Replace_the_backgrou", "edited_type": "background_change", "prompt": "Replace the background with a bustling vintage toy workshop. Include subtle motions such as a spinning wooden toy, flickering overhead lights, and dust motes floating in warm sunlight streaming through a window. The child remains perfectly still.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit produced a static image, failing to preserve foreground motion or add the requested background motion.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1"}
{"base": "0154_background_change_Replace_the_backgrou", "edited_type": "background_change", "prompt": "Replace the background with a dynamic snowy mountain pass. Include gently falling snowflakes, wind blowing through the pine trees, and shifting clouds casting moving shadows. The green Kia Soul remains perfectly still in the foreground.", "scores": [3, 2, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: Background is static, missing all requested dynamic effects like snow and wind. Lighting on car mismatches the background.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2"}
{"base": "0146_background_change_Replace_the_backgrou", "edited_type": "background_change", "prompt": "Replace the background with a dynamic forest classroom where leaves gently rustle in a soft breeze, sunlight filters through the canopy creating moving light patterns, and distant birds chirp, while the foreground person remains perfectly still.", "scores": [2, 1, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The background is a static image, not dynamic, and only partially replaces the original. The composite quality is poor.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1"}
{"base": "0139_background_change_Replace_the_backgrou", "edited_type": "background_change", "prompt": "Replace the background with a dynamic desert highway scene. Heat waves should shimmer above the asphalt, dust occasionally drifts across the road, and distant birds fly across the sky. The lighting should be bright and natural, with subtle shadows moving as if from a passing cloud. The man and SUV remain perfectly still.", "scores": [2, 1, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: Background is only partially replaced, ignoring most instructions. The new lighting is completely inconsistent with the foreground.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1"}
{"base": "0135_background_change_Replace_the_backgrou", "edited_type": "background_change", "prompt": "Replace the background with a dynamic snowy mountain retreat. The scene should include gently falling snowflakes, soft wind moving pine branches, smoke rising slowly from the cabin chimney, and bright sunlight reflecting off the snow. The atmosphere should feel crisp and peaceful.", "scores": [2, 2, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: Partial edit missing key elements. The subjects look pasted on due to obvious halos and inconsistent lighting.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2"}
{"base": "0128_background_change_Replace_the_backgrou", "edited_type": "background_change", "prompt": "Replace the background with a dynamic enchanted forest clearing scene. Include gentle swaying of tree branches, soft rays of sunlight shifting through the canopy, occasional fluttering of small forest birds, and a light mist drifting near the ground. The subject should remain perfectly still.", "scores": [3, 2, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit failed to create a dynamic scene as requested; the background is a static image.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2"}
{"base": "0140_background_change_Replace_the_backgrou", "edited_type": "background_change", "prompt": "Replace the background with a dynamic snowy alpine scene where gentle snowflakes fall, pine branches sway lightly in the cold breeze, and sunlight glints off the snow. The subject remains perfectly still.", "scores": [3, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit replaced the background with a static snowy scene, but missed the requested dynamic elements like falling snow.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3"}
{"base": "0141_background_change_Replace_the_backgrou", "edited_type": "background_change", "prompt": "Replace the background with a dynamic urban graffiti wall scene. The wall should have subtle flickering neon light effects reflecting off the paint, occasional passing shadows of pedestrians, and faint distant city sounds to create an alive street atmosphere. The subject should remain perfectly still.", "scores": [2, 2, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The background is a static image, missing all requested dynamic effects. A very obvious halo is visible around the subject's hair.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2"}
{"base": "0150_background_change_Transform_the_backgr", "edited_type": "background_change", "prompt": "Transform the background into a lively Mediterranean village street. Include subtle motion such as fluttering flower petals, gentle swaying of tree leaves, distant birds flying, and warm sunlight casting dynamic shadows. The person and dog remain perfectly still in the foreground.", "scores": [3, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit achieved the Mediterranean theme but failed to add any of the requested subtle motion elements.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3"}
{"base": "0133_background_change_Replace_the_backgrou", "edited_type": "background_change", "prompt": "Replace the background with a dynamic urban rooftop at dusk. The scene should have slowly moving clouds, twinkling city lights, and a gentle breeze causing slight movement in rooftop objects. The subject should remain perfectly still.", "scores": [2, 2, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: Background is static, not dynamic as requested. A ghost artifact from the original background is visible.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2"}
{"base": "0145_background_change_Replace_the_backgrou", "edited_type": "background_change", "prompt": "Replace the background with a lively urban rooftop garden scene. Include subtle movement of leaves in a gentle breeze, distant city traffic sounds implied by soft light flickers, and shifting sunlight casting dynamic shadows. The deer remains perfectly still.", "scores": [3, 2, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit missed all requested dynamic elements (movement, light shifts) and looks unnatural due to inconsistent lighting.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2"}
{"base": "0130_background_change_Replace_the_backgrou", "edited_type": "background_change", "prompt": "Replace the background with a dynamic racetrack pit lane scene. Include subtle motion such as pit crew members moving around, flags waving, engines revving in the distance, and sunlight casting moving shadows. The Porsche remains perfectly still in the foreground.", "scores": [4, 2, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit followed instructions, but the car's reflections still show the original background, which is a major inconsistency.\nInstruction Compliance: 4\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2"}
{"base": "0137_background_change_Replace_the_backgrou", "edited_type": "background_change", "prompt": "Replace the background with a dynamic winter scene where snowflakes fall gently, tree branches sway slightly under the weight of snow, and the frozen lake reflects soft winter sunlight. The atmosphere is crisp and clear. The person and vehicle remain perfectly still.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: Static scene, not dynamic as requested. A severe static overlay covers the entire video, ruining the foreground.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1"}
{"base": "0132_background_change_Replace_the_backgrou", "edited_type": "background_change", "prompt": "Replace the background with a dynamic cozy library nook where flickering candlelight casts gentle shadows, pages of books occasionally flutter from a soft breeze, and a fireplace glows warmly in the background. The subject should remain perfectly still.", "scores": [2, 2, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: Instruction to make the subject perfectly still was not met; the subject's juggling action was removed.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2"}
{"base": "0157_background_change_Replace_the_backgrou", "edited_type": "background_change", "prompt": "Replace the background with a dynamic 1960s car show. Include people walking around, chatting, and admiring cars, flags fluttering in the breeze, and occasional camera flashes. The lighting should be warm and natural, with soft shadows moving as the sun shifts.", "scores": [4, 2, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The prompt is mostly followed, but the composite has a clear halo and mismatched lighting/reflections.\nInstruction Compliance: 4\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2"}
{"base": "0158_background_change_Replace_the_backgrou", "edited_type": "background_change", "prompt": "Replace the background with a dynamic tropical beachside garage where palm leaves sway in the breeze, ocean waves gently lap the shore, and sunlight flickers through moving clouds. The green 2016 Chevy Spark remains perfectly still in the foreground.", "scores": [2, 2, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: Only part of the background was replaced. The new scene has inconsistent lighting and looks poorly composited.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2"}
{"base": "0162_background_change_Transform_the_backgr", "edited_type": "background_change", "prompt": "Transform the background into a dynamic mountain sunrise scene. Include slowly moving morning mist, birds flying in the distance, and the warm sunlight gradually brightening the peaks. The atmosphere should feel fresh and calm with soft ambient sounds.", "scores": [2, 2, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The background is a static image, failing the 'dynamic' instruction. Lighting on the subject does not match the background.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2"}
{"base": "0155_background_change_Replace_the_backgrou", "edited_type": "background_change", "prompt": "Replace the background with a dynamic lavender field where a gentle breeze causes the flowers to sway rhythmically, bees and butterflies flit about, and sunlight casts warm, shifting shadows. The subject should remain perfectly still.", "scores": [2, 1, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: Background partially replaced with animated flowers. Missing key prompt elements like bees, butterflies, and shadows. The edit is obvious.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1"}
{"base": "0160_background_change_Transform_the_backgr", "edited_type": "background_change", "prompt": "Transform the background into a dynamic desert scene at sunset with shifting sand dunes, a warm glowing sky, and occasional gusts of wind blowing sand gently across the landscape. The Volvo V90 remains static in the foreground.", "scores": [3, 2, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: Background is a static image, not dynamic. It incorrectly retains the snowy mountains and winter trees.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2"}
{"base": "0163_background_change_Transform_the_backgr", "edited_type": "background_change", "prompt": "Transform the background into a lively European street café. Include subtle movements like people walking by, leaves rustling in a gentle breeze, and soft chatter sounds implied by animated figures. The lighting should be warm and natural, with occasional sunbeams filtering through the umbrellas.", "scores": [2, 2, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit incorrectly retained the car and distorted the subject with an unstable, painterly effect and unnatural lighting.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2"}
{"base": "0156_background_change_Replace_the_backgrou", "edited_type": "background_change", "prompt": "Replace the background with a dynamic tropical beach scene. Include gentle ocean waves lapping the shore, palm fronds swaying in a light breeze, and occasional seabirds flying overhead. The sunlight should create sparkling reflections on the car’s surface.", "scores": [3, 1, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: Background is partly replaced; ground is incorrect and palm trees are static. No perspective shift during pan.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1"}
{"base": "0173_background_change_Place_the_subject_in", "edited_type": "background_change", "prompt": "Place the subject in a dynamic forest retreat. The background should have subtle motion: leaves gently swaying, light rays flickering through the branches, and occasional small animals moving quietly in the distance.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edited video is identical to the original; no changes were made to the background.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1"}
{"base": "0169_background_change_Replace_the_backgrou", "edited_type": "background_change", "prompt": "Replace the background with a dynamic classic library scene where soft light filters through windows, dust motes float gently in the air, and the flicker of a fireplace adds warmth, while the subject remains perfectly still.", "scores": [4, 4, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit followed all instructions, creating a dynamic library scene. Lighting is well-matched, but minor edge artefacts are visible.\nInstruction Compliance: 4\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 4"}
{"base": "0167_background_change_Replace_the_backgrou", "edited_type": "background_change", "prompt": "Replace the background with a dynamic luxury yacht deck scene where ocean waves gently rock the yacht, seagulls fly in the distance, and the warm sunset light slowly shifts hues, casting soft reflections on the car and man. The foreground remains perfectly still.", "scores": [3, 2, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit misses the 'yacht deck' detail and has noticeable perspective issues, making the car look unnaturally placed.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2"}
{"base": "0161_background_change_Create_a_dynamic_cel", "edited_type": "background_change", "prompt": "Create a dynamic celestial night sky background with twinkling stars, slowly drifting nebula clouds, occasional shooting stars streaking across the sky, and a softly glowing moon casting gentle light. The blue sunflowers in the foreground remain perfectly still.", "scores": [2, 1, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit is a static image, failing the \"dynamic\" instruction. Key celestial elements are missing, and edges are rough.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1"}
{"base": "0176_background_change_Transform_the_backgr", "edited_type": "background_change", "prompt": "Transform the background into a modern art gallery with soft ambient lighting. Include subtle reflections on polished floors, gentle movement of visitors in the distance, and dynamic light shifts from overhead spotlights highlighting the artworks.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The background was not changed to an art gallery; only lighting was added to the original background.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1"}
{"base": "0159_background_change_Replace_the_backgrou", "edited_type": "background_change", "prompt": "Replace the background with a dynamic space scene. Include slowly twinkling stars, drifting colorful nebula clouds, and a rotating distant planet casting subtle light on the statue. The statue remains perfectly still.", "scores": [3, 2, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: Only the sky was replaced, not the whole background. The lighting on the trees conflicts with the new sky.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2"}
{"base": "0164_background_change_Replace_the_backgrou", "edited_type": "background_change", "prompt": "Replace the background with a dynamic vintage garage workshop. Include subtle flickering of overhead incandescent lights, occasional dust motes floating in the warm light beams, and slight movement of hanging tools due to a gentle draft. The subject remains perfectly still.", "scores": [3, 2, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The background theme is correct, but most requested dynamic elements are missing. The cutout is rough, and lighting doesn't match.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2"}
{"base": "0165_background_change_Transform_the_backgr", "edited_type": "background_change", "prompt": "Transform the background into a dynamic ancient Japanese garden. Include gentle ripples in the koi pond, cherry blossom petals slowly drifting in the breeze, soft rustling of leaves, and dappled sunlight filtering through the trees. The subject should remain perfectly still.", "scores": [2, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit fails completely during the camera pan, creating a blurry mess and deleting the second subject.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1"}
{"base": "0170_background_change_Replace_the_backgrou", "edited_type": "background_change", "prompt": "Replace the background with a dynamic autumn forest scene. Include gently falling leaves, soft sunlight filtering through the trees, and a light breeze causing branches to sway. The subject should remain perfectly still.", "scores": [2, 1, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The background is a static image, not a dynamic scene. Poor masking and a static background with a moving foreground create a fake look.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1"}
{"base": "0171_background_change_Replace_the_backgrou", "edited_type": "background_change", "prompt": "Replace the background with a lively spring meadow scene where butterflies gently flutter around, wildflowers sway softly in a light breeze, and the sky is bright blue with occasional drifting clouds. The subject remains perfectly still.", "scores": [3, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: Background matches the general theme, but misses key animated elements like butterflies, clouds, and swaying flowers.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3"}
{"base": "0174_background_change_Transform_the_backgr", "edited_type": "background_change", "prompt": "Transform the background into a dynamic countryside road scene with gentle breeze moving the wildflowers, birds flying in the sky, and soft sunlight shifting through passing clouds. The foreground vehicles and pedestrians remain perfectly still.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The background is not a countryside scene. The pedestrian was removed, not frozen still as instructed.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1"}
{"base": "0172_background_change_Replace_the_backgrou", "edited_type": "background_change", "prompt": "Replace the background with a lively park scene. Trees gently sway in the breeze, birds occasionally fly by, and sunlight filters through leaves creating dappled light patterns. The two people and puppies remain perfectly still in the foreground.", "scores": [2, 1, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: Background is static, not lively. A background picture frame was not removed and floats in the new scene.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1"}
{"base": "0177_background_change_Replace_the_backgrou", "edited_type": "background_change", "prompt": "Replace the background with a dynamic rustic kitchen scene where sunlight streams softly through the window, a gentle breeze moves a curtain, and a kettle on the stove emits occasional steam puffs. The subject should remain perfectly still.", "scores": [4, 4, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The dynamic kitchen background matches the prompt, but there is noticeable green spill in the subject's hair.\nInstruction Compliance: 4\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 4"}
{"base": "0310_creative_edit_Given_the_video_of_a", "edited_type": "creative_edit", "prompt": "Given the video of a wide expanse of fluffy white clouds under a clear blue sky, transform the entire cloud layer instantly into a sprawling futuristic cityscape composed of gleaming glass and steel towers with visible streets and lights.", "scores": [3, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit fails to transform the entire cloud layer and does not show the requested instant transformation.\nInstruction Compliance: 3.\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3.\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3."}
{"base": "0168_background_change_Replace_the_backgrou", "edited_type": "background_change", "prompt": "Replace the background with a dynamic mountain sunrise scene where morning mist slowly drifts across the peaks, golden sunlight gradually brightens the valley, and gentle breezes sway the distant trees. The subject remains perfectly still in the foreground.", "scores": [3, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit failed to add mountains, replacing the background with a forest instead. The technical execution is high quality.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3"}
{"base": "0175_background_change_Replace_the_backgrou", "edited_type": "background_change", "prompt": "Replace the background with a lively outdoor market on a sunny day. Include gentle movement of leaves in the breeze, people walking and chatting in the distance, and dynamic sunlight casting soft shadows. The subject should remain perfectly still.", "scores": [4, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The background is well replaced, but a bright halo is visible around the subject's hair, breaking the illusion.\nInstruction Compliance: 4\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3"}
{"base": "0308_creative_edit_Given_the_video_of_t", "edited_type": "creative_edit", "prompt": "Given the video of the glass filled with glowing green liquid and a flickering ethereal flame on its surface, transform the scene so the glass is now empty and dry. The green liquid and flame disappear, replaced by glowing green alchemical symbols etched on the glass surface, emitting a faint mystical aura.", "scores": [2, 2, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit added symbols but failed to remove the liquid and the flame as instructed.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2"}
{"base": "0181_background_change_Replace_the_backgrou", "edited_type": "background_change", "prompt": "Replace the background with a dynamic ancient Colosseum scene featuring moving crowds cheering, fluttering banners, and dust particles in the sunlight. The lighting should shift subtly as if from a late afternoon sun, while the football player remains perfectly still.", "scores": [3, 2, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The background is static, missing all requested dynamic elements like moving crowds, banners, and shifting light.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2"}
{"base": "0166_background_change_Replace_the_backgrou", "edited_type": "background_change", "prompt": "Replace the background with a dynamic futuristic cyber command center where holographic displays flicker and shift, data streams flow continuously, and subtle light reflections move across the surfaces, creating an immersive high-tech atmosphere.", "scores": [4, 3, 4], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: Background matches the theme well. The subject's edges are clean but her lighting doesn't match the background.\nInstruction Compliance: 4\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 4\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3"}
{"base": "0178_background_change_Transform_the_backgr", "edited_type": "background_change", "prompt": "Transform the background into a peaceful Japanese Zen garden with dynamic elements: soft ripples on the koi pond, leaves gently falling, and dappled sunlight shifting through the trees. The subject should remain perfectly still.", "scores": [3, 1, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: Static background lacks requested dynamic elements and motion tracking, causing a floating effect.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1"}
{"base": "0309_creative_edit_Given_the_video_of_t", "edited_type": "creative_edit", "prompt": "Given the video of the freshly baked seeded bread loaf on the cutting board with a hand holding a knife, transform the entire bread surface into a miniature lush forest with green trees, moss, and tiny flowers shaped exactly like the loaf. The knife is now poised to slice through the forest canopy instead of bread.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The bread is perfectly transformed into a miniature forest, maintaining the original shape and slicing motion.\nInstruction Compliance: 5.\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5.\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5."}
{"base": "0180_background_change_Transform_the_backgr", "edited_type": "background_change", "prompt": "Transform the background into a lively urban graffiti alley. Include subtle movement such as fluttering trash, distant city sounds, occasional flickering neon signs, and shifting shadows from passing pedestrians, while the lighting changes with passing clouds.", "scores": [3, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The graffiti alley background was added, but none of the requested dynamic elements like movement or lighting changes were included.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3"}
{"base": "0312_creative_edit_Given_the_video_of_t", "edited_type": "creative_edit", "prompt": "Given the video of the man holding a traditional wooden shotgun in the dry field, transform the shotgun instantly into a polished wooden acoustic guitar, with strings and tuning pegs, while keeping the man's pose and environment unchanged.", "scores": [3, 2, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: Failed to fully transform the shotgun, resulting in a physically inconsistent guitar-shotgun hybrid object.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0311_creative_edit_Given_the_video_of_t", "edited_type": "creative_edit", "prompt": "Given the video of the modern office meeting with the woman gesturing while holding a laptop and the colleague holding a clipboard, transform the scene so that the woman is now interacting with a futuristic holographic telepathic interface above her laptop, the clipboard is replaced by a transparent tablet displaying dynamic graphs, and the man in the background is engaged with floating holographic screens, with the lighting shifting to a subtle blue glow.", "scores": [3, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit replaces devices with screens but misses key specifics like placement, floating screens, and dynamic content.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3"}
{"base": "0179_background_change_Replace_the_backgrou", "edited_type": "background_change", "prompt": "Replace the background with a dynamic tropical beach at sunset. The scene should include softly rolling ocean waves, palm fronds swaying in a gentle breeze, and warm, shifting colors in the sky as the sun sets. The black Hyundai SUV and the person inside should remain perfectly still.", "scores": [2, 1, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: First background is wrong. Second is static, not dynamic. Lighting and reflections are mismatched.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1"}
{"base": "0317_creative_edit_Given_the_video_of_t", "edited_type": "creative_edit", "prompt": "Given the video of the natural moon with cratered surface and bright illumination, transform the moon into a giant bioluminescent jellyfish by making its surface translucent with glowing blue and purple hues and adding long, flowing tentacles trailing beneath it, while preserving its position in space.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: All instructions were followed perfectly, creating a high-quality, stable, and detailed jellyfish in place of the moon.\nInstruction Compliance: 5.\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5.\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5."}
{"base": "0316_creative_edit_Given_the_video_of_t", "edited_type": "creative_edit", "prompt": "Given the video of the shiny red classic 1930s coupe parked on the street, transform the car so it is now a sleek futuristic hovercraft floating above the pavement. Remove the chrome wheels and replace them with glowing blue anti-gravity thrusters and smooth hover pads. Add subtle neon accents to the streamlined body while keeping the original red color and background intact.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The instruction was completely ignored. No edits were made to the video; it is identical to the original.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0314_creative_edit_Given_the_video_of_a", "edited_type": "creative_edit", "prompt": "Given the video of a man's natural hands typing on a black laptop keyboard, transform the hands instantly into sleek, metallic robotic hands with articulated joints and glowing blue lights, maintaining the same typing position and motion.", "scores": [3, 2, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The robotic hands look good but are completely static, failing to replicate the original typing motion.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0315_creative_edit_Given_the_video_of_t", "edited_type": "creative_edit", "prompt": "Given the video of the blue dragon wearing a plain Santa hat against a solid red background, transform the dragon so its scales shimmer with red and green sparkles, its Santa hat is decorated with glowing fairy lights, and it holds a candy cane. Add subtle falling snowflakes and twinkling stars to the red background.", "scores": [2, 2, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: Only the hat was edited, and not as requested. All other instructions were ignored.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2"}
{"base": "0325_creative_edit_Given_the_video_of_t", "edited_type": "creative_edit", "prompt": "Given the video of the young woman with a static thumb-down gesture, instantly add a glowing red flame-shaped aura flickering around her thumb, with subtle red light reflections on her hand and sweater, while keeping her pose and background unchanged.", "scores": [5, 4, 4], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit perfectly adds a flickering flame aura and subtle light reflections as instructed, maintaining excellent quality.\nInstruction Compliance: 5.\nVisual Quality & Stability: 4.\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 4."}
{"base": "0321_creative_edit_Given_the_video_of_t", "edited_type": "creative_edit", "prompt": "Given the video of the white Peugeot 2008 SUV parked on the city street, transform the entire vehicle into a giant mechanical lion composed of car parts and metal panels. The lion has glowing eyes and articulated limbs, replacing the original car form while keeping the urban background unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The instruction to transform the car into a mechanical lion was completely ignored; the car remains a car.\nInstruction Compliance: 1.\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1.\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1."}
{"base": "0313_creative_edit_Given_the_video_of_t", "edited_type": "creative_edit", "prompt": "Given the video of the wild tabby cat calmly sitting in the forest, transform the cat instantly into a mythical chimera with the same feline body, large golden eagle wings extending from its shoulders, and glowing emerald eyes, while keeping the forest background unchanged.", "scores": [2, 2, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The model produced a static image instead of a video, completely ignoring the motion in the original clip.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0318_creative_edit_Given_the_video_of_t", "edited_type": "creative_edit", "prompt": "Given the video of the brightly lit Ferris wheel at the waterfront carnival, transform the Ferris wheel into a massive celestial portal glowing with ethereal blue and violet energy, swirling with stars and cosmic dust. The colorful carnival lights are replaced by cosmic patterns, and the water reflection changes accordingly.", "scores": [2, 2, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: Failed to create a celestial portal; only changed some light colors to blue.\nInstruction Compliance: 2.\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2.\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2."}
{"base": "0323_creative_edit_Given_the_video_of_t", "edited_type": "creative_edit", "prompt": "Given the video of the underground corridor with white corrugated walls and framed pictures, transform the walls into towering bookshelves filled with colorful books extending infinitely. Replace the framed pictures with ornate reading lamps emitting warm light, and change the floor reflections to mirror the golden glow of the lamps.", "scores": [4, 4, 4], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit successfully adds bookshelves, lamps, and reflections, but fails to make them extend infinitely, leaving the back wall unchanged.\nInstruction Compliance: 4\nVisual Quality & Stability: 4\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 4"}
{"base": "0326_creative_edit_Given_the_video_of_t", "edited_type": "creative_edit", "prompt": "Given the video of two glass bottles behind clear, glossy bubble wrap, remove the bubble wrap instantly and fill the bottles with swirling, glowing liquid cores—amber in the brown bottle and emerald green in the green bottle—while making the glass surfaces crystal clear and reflective.", "scores": [3, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit only applies the effects to one of the two specified bottles, ignoring the other completely.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3"}
{"base": "0331_creative_edit_Given_the_video_of_t", "edited_type": "creative_edit", "prompt": "Given the video of the woman holding a shiny red heart-shaped balloon in a grassy field under a blue sky with white clouds, transform the balloon into a glowing, pulsating celestial heart composed of radiant stardust and cosmic light. The heart emits sparkles and shooting stars drifting upward, the woman’s clothing gains a faint cosmic shimmer, and the clouds swirl gently in response to the heart’s energy.", "scores": [3, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit transformed the balloon but missed the sparkles, clothing shimmer, and swirling clouds.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3"}
{"base": "0330_creative_edit_Given_the_video_of_t", "edited_type": "creative_edit", "prompt": "Given the video of the lone paraglider soaring in a bright blue sky with white clouds, transform the entire scene into a cosmic night sky filled with stars and nebulae. The paraglider's canopy becomes a glowing constellation map, and the pilot is now a radiant celestial navigator surrounded by cosmic light.", "scores": [3, 3, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: Changed the sky and canopy, but kept daytime clouds and an unchanged pilot, creating major lighting inconsistencies.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2"}
{"base": "0329_creative_edit_Given_the_video_of_t", "edited_type": "creative_edit", "prompt": "Given the video of the person indoors holding a green leaf, transform the person’s entire body and clothing into a living botanical figure made of green leaves, flowers, and vines. The leaf they hold glows softly, and the window view changes to a surreal garden with ethereal light.", "scores": [2, 2, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: Only the hair and collar were altered. The rest of the person, leaf, and background remain unchanged.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2"}
{"base": "0328_creative_edit_Given_the_video_of_s", "edited_type": "creative_edit", "prompt": "Given the video of softly falling snowflakes against a black background, transform each snowflake into a softly glowing bioluminescent jellyfish-like creature emitting blue and green light, drifting gently upward and sideways.", "scores": [2, 2, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: No more than 20 words.\nInstruction Compliance: 2.\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2.\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2."}
{"base": "0334_creative_edit_Given_the_video_of_t", "edited_type": "creative_edit", "prompt": "Given the video of the young man standing against the guitar-adorned wall, transform his entire body into a living acoustic guitar hybrid, integrating wood textures, strings, frets, and tuning pegs into his skin and limbs, while keeping the background unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: Instruction ignored. The background was edited instead of the person, which is the opposite of the prompt.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0320_creative_edit_Given_the_video_of_t", "edited_type": "creative_edit", "prompt": "Given the video of the man holding chopsticks above a static bowl of noodle soup in a cluttered Thai market stall, transform the bowl so that all ingredients instantly levitate and swirl above it in a vibrant, glowing animated explosion. The background remains unchanged but pulses with colorful light to highlight the magical effect.", "scores": [2, 2, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The ingredients do not levitate, swirl, or explode, and the background does not pulse with light.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2"}
{"base": "0335_creative_edit_Given_the_video_of_t", "edited_type": "creative_edit", "prompt": "Given the video of the young woman meditating calmly on the yoga mat in the minimalist room, transform the scene so that elemental forces instantly manifest around her: flames swirl around her arms, water ripples appear near her hands, a breeze moves her hair and clothes, and stones levitate around her, while the background remains unchanged.", "scores": [2, 2, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: Only one of four requested elemental effects was added, and the others were completely ignored.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2"}
{"base": "0332_creative_edit_Given_the_video_of_c", "edited_type": "creative_edit", "prompt": "Given the video of compressed Pu-erh tea cakes and loose tea leaves on rustic paper with ceramic cups of tea, transform the tea cakes and leaves into miniature forest ecosystems with tiny trees, moss, and small animals inhabiting them. Transform the ceramic cups into natural ponds reflecting the sky.", "scores": [3, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: Only one tea cake was changed, and the requested small animals are missing from the ecosystem.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3"}
{"base": "0324_creative_edit_Given_the_video_of_t", "edited_type": "creative_edit", "prompt": "Given the video of three mummified human figures standing lifeless in a glass display case with warm lighting, instantly transform each figure into an ethereal forest spirit composed of roots, moss, and glowing bioluminescent fungi. They maintain their original poses and now emit soft green and blue light with magical energy flickering around them.", "scores": [3, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The instruction was generally followed, but the third figure's texture is inconsistent with the other two and the prompt.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3"}
{"base": "0333_creative_edit_Given_the_video_of_f", "edited_type": "creative_edit", "prompt": "Given the video of fresh white milk filling the glass, transform the milk instantly into a miniature ocean scene with clear blue water, tiny waves, miniature sailboats floating on the surface, and small seagulls flying above inside the glass.", "scores": [3, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit adds sailboats and blue water but misses the requested waves and seagulls, failing to fully create the scene.\nInstruction Compliance: 3.\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3.\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3."}
{"base": "0322_creative_edit_Given_the_video_of_t", "edited_type": "creative_edit", "prompt": "Given the video of the real person wearing a VR headset against a beige background, transform the entire figure into a stylized 3D digital avatar with a translucent visor replacing the VR headset. Change the background to a digital grid environment with floating data streams and neon accents.", "scores": [2, 2, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: Failed to turn the person into an avatar and create the specified digital background.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2"}
{"base": "0000_global_style_Apply_the_Impression", "edited_type": "global_style", "prompt": "Apply the Impressionist aesthetic to this video, ensuring seamless temporal consistency across all frames. The result should emulate the fluid brushstroke techniques and atmospheric focus of 19th-century Impressionist art, with each frame retaining the original motion, character actions, and camera movements. Preserve the dynamic interplay of light and shadow while keeping the video's narrative flow and structural coherence intact.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit failed to apply the requested Impressionist aesthetic. The output video is virtually indistinguishable from the original, showing no evidence of painterly textures, brushstrokes, or atmospheric changes.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1"}
{"base": "0006_global_style_Apply_the_Studio_Ghi", "edited_type": "global_style", "prompt": "Apply the Studio Ghibli animation style to this video, ensuring seamless temporal consistency across all frames. The result should emulate a Ghibli feature film, complete with its distinctive artistic flair. All original motion, character actions, and camera movements must be meticulously retained to maintain narrative flow.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The requested Studio Ghibli animation style is completely absent. The edited video appears nearly identical to the original, showing no evidence of any style transfer.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1"}
{"base": "0005_global_style_Apply_the_Aesthetic", "edited_type": "global_style", "prompt": "Apply the Aesthetic Ancient-style to this video, ensuring seamless temporal consistency across all frames. The final output should emulate the aesthetic of ancient hand-painted scrolls or temple murals, with fluid transitions between frames and soft, diffused lighting. All original motion—including character movements, camera panning, and environmental dynamics—must be precisely maintained without disruption.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit failed to apply the requested ancient scroll/mural style, only performing a simple color grading. The core instruction was completely missed, resulting in a low score across all categories.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1"}
{"base": "0327_creative_edit_Given_the_video_of_t", "edited_type": "creative_edit", "prompt": "Given the video of the paddleboarder on a calm sea at sunset with warm orange and pink sky reflections, transform the paddleboarder into a glowing ethereal water guardian figure. Change the water to sparkle with bioluminescent waves and add glowing mythical water creatures swimming nearby. Replace the sun with a large luminous moon casting a mystical glow over the shoreline.", "scores": [3, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The paddleboarder became a glowing figure, but the sun was not changed to a moon, a major deviation.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3"}
{"base": "0319_creative_edit_Given_the_video_of_t", "edited_type": "creative_edit", "prompt": "Given the video of the person in a vintage white lace blouse with a natural hand near their face and metallic blue streamers behind, transform the person into a semi-transparent blue hologram with visible digital grid lines. Change the blouse into glowing blue light patterns replicating the lace embroidery. Replace the metallic streamers with dynamic vertical light beams pulsing softly, and make the hand flicker with digital particles.", "scores": [2, 2, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: Most instructions were ignored. Only a digital grid was added to the face, failing the hologram transformation.\nInstruction Compliance: 2.\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2.\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2."}
{"base": "0001_global_style_Apply_the_Ukiyoe_ani", "edited_type": "global_style", "prompt": "Apply the Ukiyoe animation style to this video, ensuring strict temporal consistency across all frames. The final output should mirror the elegance of classic Ukiyoe prints, with fluid transitions between frames that uphold the style's aesthetic. Preserve original motion, character actions, camera movements, and narrative flow, while integrating the signature Ukiyoe elements—delicate linework, atmospheric color washes, and compositional balance—without disrupting the video's continuity.", "scores": [2, 2, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit fails to capture the requested Ukiyoe style, lacking the characteristic delicate linework and texture. It more closely resembles a simple color grade and sharpening filter.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2"}
{"base": "0003_global_style_Apply_the_Steampunk", "edited_type": "global_style", "prompt": "Apply the Steampunk aesthetic to this video, ensuring seamless temporal consistency across all frames. The output should emulate the detailed, retro-futuristic style of Steampunk, with elements like mechanical contraptions, brass accents, and industrial backdrops. Maintain all original motion, character actions, and camera movements to preserve narrative flow.", "scores": [4, 4, 4], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The steampunk style is excellently applied to the main subjects with perfect stability. However, the background remains unedited, which prevents a perfect instruction compliance score.\nInstruction Compliance: 4\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 4\nVisual Quality & Stability: 4"}
{"base": "0002_global_style_Apply_the_Cyberpunk", "edited_type": "global_style", "prompt": "Apply the Cyberpunk animation style to this video, ensuring seamless temporal consistency across all frames. The result should emulate the dynamic, futuristic ambiance of Cyberpunk media, complete with flickering neon signs, rain-slicked streets reflecting holographic light, and a gritty urban backdrop. Maintain original motion, character actions, camera movements, and narrative flow, ensuring that every frame transitions smoothly while embodying the Cyberpunk aesthetic.", "scores": [3, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The cyberpunk theme is only applied to the background, not the foreground subjects, making the style application inconsistent across the scene. Fidelity and stability are high but capped by compliance.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3"}
{"base": "0336_creative_edit_Given_the_video_of_t", "edited_type": "creative_edit", "prompt": "Given the video of the person wearing a tall, pointed green witch's hat with black tulle in front of a cobwebbed window, transform the hat instantly into a lush, miniature enchanted forest canopy made of vibrant leaves, moss, glowing fairy lights, and delicate flowers, with the black tulle becoming wisps of magical mist drifting around it.", "scores": [2, 2, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit failed to add leaves, moss, flowers, or transform the tulle into mist as requested.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2"}
{"base": "0008_global_style_Apply_the_Watercolor", "edited_type": "global_style", "prompt": "Apply the Watercolor animation style to this video, ensuring seamless temporal consistency across all frames. The output should mirror the aesthetic of traditional Watercolor art, with fluid color transitions, soft outlines, and a dreamlike atmosphere. Maintain the original motion, character actions, camera movements, and narrative flow, ensuring no frame exhibits jarring style inconsistencies.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit failed to apply the requested watercolor style. It only performed a simple color correction, completely missing the stylistic instruction for soft outlines and fluid transitions.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1"}
{"base": "0337_creative_edit_Given_the_video_of_t", "edited_type": "creative_edit", "prompt": "Given the video of the young woman painting an abstract watercolor on paper, transform the watercolor painting into a flock of vivid, lifelike parrots that flutter and fly gently around her, matching the colors on her shirt and filling the space with dynamic movement.", "scores": [3, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit changes the painting to a single parrot, but fails to create the requested flying flock.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3"}
{"base": "0004_global_style_Apply_the_Sketch_Sty", "edited_type": "global_style", "prompt": "Apply the Sketch Style to this video, ensuring seamless temporal consistency across every frame. The final output should mimic the look of a hand-drawn animation, with consistent sketch outlines, shading, and textural flair. All original motion, character actions, and camera movements must remain unaltered, preserving the video’s narrative flow and dynamic pacing.", "scores": [3, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The comic-book style is applied consistently but lacks the requested hand-drawn sketch texture. The video is perfectly stable, with all original details and motion fully preserved.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3"}
{"base": "0012_global_style_Apply_the_sunny_styl", "edited_type": "global_style", "prompt": "Apply the sunny style to this video, ensuring seamless, frame-by-frame consistency throughout. The final output should feature warm, golden-hour lighting, soft shadows, and vivid colors typical of a bright, sunny day. Maintain all original motion, character actions, and camera movements, preserving the video’s temporal flow, narrative integrity, and visual coherence.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit perfectly applies a warm, sunny style with golden-hour lighting. The effect is completely stable, with no flickering, and all original motion and detail are preserved.\nInstruction Compliance: 5\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5"}
{"base": "0010_global_style_Apply_the_soft_warm", "edited_type": "global_style", "prompt": "Apply the soft, warm aesthetic of dawn to this video, ensuring temporal consistency across all frames. The result should emulate the gradual light transition of early morning, with smooth color blending and gentle golden hour illumination. Preserve all original motion, character actions, and camera movements, ensuring the video’s narrative flow and visual dynamics remain intact while adopting the dawn-inspired style.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The requested warm, dawn-like aesthetic was perfectly applied through color grading. Original details, motion, and stability were flawlessly preserved, fully meeting the instruction.\nInstruction Compliance: 5\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5"}
{"base": "0007_global_style_Apply_the_dynamic_ae", "edited_type": "global_style", "prompt": "Apply the dynamic aesthetic of abstract art to this video, maintaining strict temporal consistency across all frames. The result should exude the spontaneity and emotional depth of abstract expressionism, with synchronized brushstroke patterns and color transitions that align with the original narrative flow. Preserve all original motion, character movements, and camera dynamics, ensuring no frame deviates from the video’s intended rhythm.", "scores": [3, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The style is a generic painterly effect, not abstract expressionism as instructed. The original scene is clear, but the video suffers from noticeable, distracting texture boiling and flickering.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3"}
{"base": "0013_global_style_Apply_the_Watercolor", "edited_type": "global_style", "prompt": "Apply the Watercolor animation style to this video, ensuring frame-by-frame temporal consistency. The final output should exude the fluidity and softness of hand-painted watercolors, with colors bleeding and blending naturally across each frame. Preserve all original motion—such as character movements, camera panning, and object interactions—while infusing the signature watercolor aesthetic. Avoid any jarring transitions or inconsistencies that could disrupt the narrative flow.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The requested watercolor animation style is completely absent from the video. The edit appears to be a simple color saturation boost, failing the primary instruction to apply a style.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1"}
{"base": "0014_global_style_Apply_the_Cartoon_an", "edited_type": "global_style", "prompt": "Apply the Cartoon animation style to this video, maintaining strict frame-by-frame consistency. The final result should emulate classic 2D animated films, complete with its signature exaggerated expressions and dynamic color schemes. All original motion, character movements, and camera angles must be flawlessly retained.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The requested cartoon animation style is completely absent. The edited video is nearly identical to the original, showing no stylistic changes, altered colors, or animation effects.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1"}
{"base": "0011_global_style_Apply_the_pixel_art", "edited_type": "global_style", "prompt": "Apply the pixel art style to this video, ensuring seamless frame-by-frame consistency to avoid flickering or jarring transitions. The final output should emulate the look of classic pixel animations, with sharp, retro-style pixels and a cohesive color palette. All original motion—including character movements, camera panning, and dynamic actions—must be preserved in full, without any temporal disruption.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit fails to apply the requested pixel art style. Instead, it only performs a simple color correction, completely missing the main instruction of the prompt.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1"}
{"base": "0020_global_style_Apply_the_Aesthetic", "edited_type": "global_style", "prompt": "Apply the Aesthetic Ancient-style to this video with strict frame-by-frame consistency. The final output should emulate the elegance of ancient art, complete with its signature soft color palettes and hand-drawn textures. All original motion, character movements, and camera angles must be preserved without alteration.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edited video is identical to the original. The requested \"Aesthetic Ancient-style\" was not applied, and no changes were made to the video's color, texture, or overall look.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1"}
{"base": "0009_global_style_Apply_the_sketch_sty", "edited_type": "global_style", "prompt": "Apply the sketch style to this video, ensuring seamless temporal consistency across all frames. Each frame should exhibit the sketch aesthetic—clean lines, intentional shading, and a hand-drawn feel—while preserving the original motion, character actions, and camera movements. The final video should look like a professionally rendered animated sketch, with no flickering or abrupt style changes.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The sketch style is flawlessly applied, preserving all original details and motion. The final video is exceptionally stable, with no flickering, resulting in a professional-looking animated effect.\nInstruction Compliance: 5\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5"}
{"base": "0019_global_style_Apply_the_sunny_aest", "edited_type": "global_style", "prompt": "Apply the sunny aesthetic to this video, ensuring seamless temporal consistency across all frames. The style should mimic bright, outdoor daylight with warm, golden lighting, vivid colors, and a clear blue sky. All original motion, character actions, and camera movements must remain perfectly intact, with the sunny effects integrated smoothly into every frame to avoid flickering or inconsistencies.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit perfectly applies the requested warm, sunny aesthetic with golden lighting. Original details and motion are fully preserved, and the effect is completely stable with no flickering.\nInstruction Compliance: 5\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5"}
{"base": "0015_global_style_Apply_the_snowy_aest", "edited_type": "global_style", "prompt": "Apply the snowy aesthetic to this video, ensuring seamless temporal consistency across all frames. The result should capture the dynamic yet tranquil atmosphere of a snowfall, with realistic snowflakes drifting, frost accumulating on surfaces, and soft, diffused lighting. Preserve all original motion, character actions, camera movements, and narrative elements to maintain the video’s integrity and flow.", "scores": [2, 2, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit only turns the sand white, failing to add key elements like falling snow, frost, or soft lighting. The snowy atmosphere requested was not achieved.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2"}
{"base": "0016_global_style_Apply_the_immersive", "edited_type": "global_style", "prompt": "Apply the immersive snowy style to this video, ensuring seamless temporal consistency across every frame. Craft a winter wonderland effect with consistent snow accumulation, dynamic snowfall patterns, and a cohesive cool-toned palette. Maintain the original motion, character actions, and camera movements, while enhancing the video with the soft, ethereal ambiance of a snowy environment, all without altering the narrative flow or visual integrity of the source footage.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit failed to add the requested dynamic snowfall or apply a cool-toned palette. The result is almost indistinguishable from the original, making the instructed style completely absent.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1"}
{"base": "0018_global_style_Apply_a_seamless_rai", "edited_type": "global_style", "prompt": "Apply a seamless rainy effect to this video, ensuring temporal consistency across all frames. The rain should appear to fall continuously, with liquid dynamics that look natural—drizzle, puddle reflections, and wet surface textures. Maintain the original motion of characters, camera movements, and narrative flow, while enhancing the video with the immersive, atmospheric qualities of a rainy day.", "scores": [2, 2, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit adds a misty atmosphere but fails to include the requested rain, wet surfaces, or puddles. The effect is stable, and original details are preserved.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2"}
{"base": "0021_global_style_Apply_the_iconic_Ghi", "edited_type": "global_style", "prompt": "Apply the iconic Ghibli animation style to this video, ensuring seamless temporal consistency across every frame. The final output should emulate the aesthetic of a Studio Ghibli feature film, complete with its signature watercolor-like backgrounds, gentle color transitions, and charming character movements. All original motion, camera angles, and narrative pacing—including subtle gestures and environmental dynamics—must be preserved without alteration.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit completely failed, applying no style whatsoever. The output video is identical to the original, showing none of the requested Ghibli animation aesthetic.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1"}
{"base": "0017_global_style_Apply_the_Sunny_st", "edited_type": "global_style", "prompt": "Apply the 'Sunny' style to this video, ensuring seamless temporal consistency across all frames. The final output should evoke the bright, warm, and dynamic atmosphere of a sunlit day, with natural shadows and lifelike lighting. All original motion, camera movements, and narrative elements must be preserved without flickering or disruption.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The warm, sunny style is perfectly and consistently applied. All original details and motion are preserved with perfect temporal stability and no flickering or artifacts.\nInstruction Compliance: 5\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5"}
{"base": "0024_global_style_Apply_the_Rainy_visu", "edited_type": "global_style", "prompt": "Apply the Rainy visual style to this video, ensuring seamless temporal consistency across all frames. The result should depict a rainy environment with realistic rain dynamics—including falling droplets, wet surfaces, and soft, diffused lighting—while preserving the original motion, character actions, camera movements, and narrative flow in every frame.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edited video appears identical to the original. The requested rainy style is completely absent, with none of the specified visual elements like rain or wetness.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1"}
{"base": "0025_global_style_Apply_the_dawn_aesth", "edited_type": "global_style", "prompt": "Apply the dawn aesthetic to this video, ensuring seamless temporal consistency. The final output should exude the soft, warm ambiance of early morning, with gradual light transitions and pastel sky tones, all while maintaining the original motion, character actions, and camera movements without distortion.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The dawn aesthetic is perfectly applied with warm lighting and pastel skies. All original motion and details are flawlessly preserved, and the result is completely stable with no temporal artifacts.\nInstruction Compliance: 5\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5"}
{"base": "0022_global_style_Apply_the_dawn_aesth", "edited_type": "global_style", "prompt": "Apply the dawn aesthetic to this video, ensuring smooth, frame-by-frame temporal consistency. The output should exhibit gradual color transitions from deep night to soft dawn, with warm orange and pink skies, cool blue shadows, and subtle atmospheric effects like soft mist or dew. All original motion, character actions, camera movements, and narrative details must be preserved, resulting in a fluid, coherent video that feels like a natural dawn unfolding.", "scores": [4, 4, 4], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The warm dawn palette is applied well and is perfectly stable. However, it misses key instructions like a gradual transition and cool shadows. Fidelity and stability are otherwise excellent.\nInstruction Compliance: 4\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 4\nVisual Quality & Stability: 4"}
{"base": "0023_global_style_Apply_the_Gongbi_ani", "edited_type": "global_style", "prompt": "Apply the Gongbi animation style to this video, ensuring seamless temporal consistency across all frames. The final output should emulate the elegance of classical Chinese ink painting, with deliberate brush movements, harmonious color blending, and refined linework that aligns with traditional Gongbi principles. All original motion—including character movements, camera pans, and narrative actions—must be flawlessly maintained to preserve the video’s intended flow.", "scores": [2, 2, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The Gongbi style is only minimally applied as static background elements. The main subject is unstyled, resulting in low instruction compliance despite perfect motion preservation and stability.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2"}
{"base": "0032_global_style_Apply_the_Ghibli_ani", "edited_type": "global_style", "prompt": "Apply the Ghibli animation style to this video, ensuring absolute temporal consistency across all frames. The final output should emulate the cinematic quality of Studio Ghibli films, complete with soft focus effects, atmospheric lighting, and character movements that feel both fluid and true to the original motion. All original camera angles, character actions, and narrative pacing must be preserved, with the Ghibli aesthetic layered over them without disrupting the temporal flow or coherence of the video.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit completely fails to apply the requested Ghibli animation style. It only performs a basic color correction, making the target style entirely absent from the final video.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1"}
{"base": "0026_global_style_Apply_the_Surrealist", "edited_type": "global_style", "prompt": "Apply the Surrealist aesthetic to this video, ensuring seamless temporal consistency across all frames. The result should emulate the dreamlike, unconventional style of Surrealist cinema, while preserving all original motion, character actions, and camera movements.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit completely failed. The output video is identical to the original, with absolutely no application of the requested Surrealist aesthetic. The instruction was entirely ignored.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1"}
{"base": "0029_global_style_Apply_the_Cubist_aes", "edited_type": "global_style", "prompt": "Apply the Cubist aesthetic to each frame of this video, ensuring seamless temporal consistency. The final output should exhibit the signature fragmented forms, angular planes, and dynamic color contrasts of Cubism, while preserving all original motion, character actions, and camera movements to maintain narrative coherence.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The applied style is a generic painterly or cartoon filter, completely failing to represent the requested Cubist aesthetic of fragmented forms, angular planes, and dynamic contrasts.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1"}
{"base": "0028_global_style_Apply_the_soft_warm", "edited_type": "global_style", "prompt": "Apply the soft, warm ambiance of dawn to this video, ensuring seamless temporal consistency across all frames. The final output should exude the gentle glow of early morning light, with pink and golden hues permeating each frame. All original motion, character actions, and camera movements must be flawlessly preserved to maintain narrative flow.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit flawlessly applies the requested warm dawn ambiance. Original details and motion are perfectly preserved, and the new lighting effect is completely stable with no flickering or inconsistencies.\nInstruction Compliance: 5\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5"}
{"base": "0031_global_style_Apply_the_traditiona", "edited_type": "global_style", "prompt": "Apply the traditional Gongbi painting style to this video, ensuring seamless temporal consistency across all frames. The final output should exhibit the signature characteristics of Gongbi—fine linework, harmonious color transitions, and layered ink effects—while preserving original motion sequences, character animations, and camera movements. Motion blur, lighting shifts, and narrative pacing must remain unchanged to maintain the video's natural flow.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit is merely a color and contrast enhancement. It completely fails to apply the requested Gongbi painting style, lacking any fine linework, layered effects, or painterly texture.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1"}
{"base": "0033_global_style_Apply_the_Cartoon_St", "edited_type": "global_style", "prompt": "Apply the Cartoon Style to this video, ensuring seamless temporal consistency across all frames. The final output should mimic the aesthetic of classic animated cartoons, complete with dynamic character animations, exaggerated movements, and a vivid color scheme. Maintain the original motion, camera angles, and narrative flow, ensuring no frame disrupts the cohesive storytelling of the video.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit failed completely. The \"edited\" video is identical to the original; no cartoon style whatsoever has been applied, representing a total failure to follow the instructions.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1"}
{"base": "0027_global_style_Apply_the_Gongbi_ani", "edited_type": "global_style", "prompt": "Apply the Gongbi animation style to this video, ensuring seamless temporal consistency across every frame. The result should mirror the elegance of traditional Chinese ink painting, with fluid brushstroke transitions, consistent color palettes, and meticulous line work. All original motion, character movements, and camera dynamics must be preserved without alteration, maintaining the video’s narrative flow and visual coherence.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The applied style is a generic cartoon effect, not the specified Gongbi style. It lacks the required fine brushwork and traditional ink painting aesthetics, failing the core instruction.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1"}
{"base": "0036_global_style_Apply_the_Cubist_ani", "edited_type": "global_style", "prompt": "Apply the Cubist animation style to this video, ensuring seamless frame-by-frame consistency. The final output should reflect the fragmented geometric forms and dynamic color palettes characteristic of Cubism, while preserving all original motion, character actions, and camera movements without disruption.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The video appears completely unedited. The requested Cubist animation style is entirely absent, with no discernible changes made to the original footage.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1"}
{"base": "0038_global_style_Apply_the_Pointillis", "edited_type": "global_style", "prompt": "Apply the Pointillist animation style to this video, maintaining strict frame-by-frame consistency to ensure smooth, coherent transformation. The final output should emulate the visual language of Pointillist art, with each frame rendered in precise, colorful dots. All original motion, character actions, and camera movements must be perfectly preserved.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The output video completely fails to apply the requested \"Pointillist animation style\". It remains a standard black and white animation, virtually identical to the original input.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1"}
{"base": "0034_global_style_Apply_the_enchanting", "edited_type": "global_style", "prompt": "Apply the enchanting, wintry 'Snowy' style to this video, ensuring seamless frame-by-frame consistency. The final output should evoke the tranquility of a snow-covered landscape, with soft, diffused lighting and delicate snowfall effects. All original motion—including character movements, camera panning, and background dynamics—must be flawlessly maintained to preserve the video’s narrative flow.", "scores": [3, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit partially applies a \"snowy\" style by making the lake look frozen, but fails to change the lush green trees, creating an inconsistent scene. No snowfall was added.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3"}
{"base": "0035_global_style_Apply_the_Watercolor", "edited_type": "global_style", "prompt": "Apply the Watercolor animation style to this video, ensuring seamless temporal consistency across all frames. The final result should exude the dreamy, ethereal quality of watercolor art, with soft gradients, blurred edges, and painterly textures applied uniformly to every frame. It is imperative that the original motion, character movements, camera panning, and narrative flow are fully preserved, with no flickering or abrupt style shifts between successive frames.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit completely failed to apply the requested watercolor style. The output video is almost identical to the original, lacking any painterly textures, soft gradients, or ethereal qualities.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1"}
{"base": "0030_global_style_Apply_the_Steampunk", "edited_type": "global_style", "prompt": "Apply the Steampunk animation style to this video, ensuring seamless temporal consistency across all frames. The final output should exhibit the hallmark elements of Steampunk—brass and copper textures, Victorian-era machinery, and retro-futuristic details—while preserving the original motion, character actions, and camera movements with absolute precision. Avoid any flickering or jarring style shifts between frames.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit failed completely; the video is unedited. The requested Steampunk animation style is entirely absent, with no changes made to the original footage.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1"}
{"base": "0037_global_style_Apply_the_Watercolor", "edited_type": "global_style", "prompt": "Apply the Watercolor animation style to this video, ensuring seamless frame-by-frame consistency. The final output should exhibit the characteristic softness of watercolor, with gentle color gradients and subtle, ethereal blending across all frames, while perfectly maintaining the original motion, character actions, camera movements, and narrative flow—no flickering or jarring style changes allowed.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit failed to apply the requested watercolor style. The output is nearly identical to the original video, showing no characteristic softness, color blending, or animation-like qualities.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1"}
{"base": "0044_global_style_Apply_the_Ukiyoe_ani", "edited_type": "global_style", "prompt": "Apply the Ukiyoe animation style to this video, maintaining strict temporal consistency across all frames. The final output should exhibit the hand-drawn essence of Ukiyoe, with smooth transitions between frames and the signature aesthetic of traditional Japanese woodblock prints, including flowing lines, vibrant but balanced colors, and stylized movement. Preserve all original motion, character actions, and camera movements without alteration, ensuring the video’s narrative flow and emotional tone remain intact.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit completely fails to apply the Ukiyoe style. It only changes the background to an off-white color, ignoring all instructions about color, lines, and stylized movement.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1"}
{"base": "0041_global_style_Apply_the_Pop_Art_st", "edited_type": "global_style", "prompt": "Apply the Pop Art style to this video, ensuring seamless temporal consistency across all frames. The final output should mirror the dynamic energy of Pop Art, featuring bold colors, graphic shapes, and iconic motifs (e.g., Ben-Day dots, comic book aesthetics). All original motion, character movements, and camera actions must be perfectly retained.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The Pop Art style is perfectly applied with bold colors and Ben-Day dots. The original motion and details are flawlessly preserved, and the result is completely stable.\nInstruction Compliance: 5\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5"}
{"base": "0046_global_style_Apply_the_retro_pixe", "edited_type": "global_style", "prompt": "Apply the retro pixel art style to this video, maintaining strict temporal consistency across all frames. The result should emulate classic 8-bit or 16-bit video game aesthetics, with smooth, artifact-free pixelation that aligns with the original motion, character animations, and camera movements. Preserve the narrative flow and all dynamic details, ensuring the video feels like a timeless pixelated masterpiece.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The requested retro pixel art style is completely absent. The output video is identical to the original, showing a total failure to apply the instructed style.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1"}
{"base": "0040_global_style_Apply_the_Cubist_ani", "edited_type": "global_style", "prompt": "Apply the Cubist animation style to this video, ensuring seamless frame-by-frame consistency. The result should mirror the fragmented geometric forms, overlapping planes, and dynamic perspectives of Cubist art, all while retaining the original motion, character actions, and camera movements. Maintain bold color palettes and angular line work to uphold the Cubist aesthetic without disrupting the narrative flow.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit applied a generic cartoon style, completely failing to capture the requested Cubist aesthetic of fragmented forms and overlapping planes. It's stable but the style is wrong.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1"}
{"base": "0042_global_style_Apply_the_principles", "edited_type": "global_style", "prompt": "Apply the principles of abstract art to this video, ensuring seamless temporal consistency across all frames. Infuse each frame with dynamic color gradients, fragmented motion blurs, or non-representational patterns, while preserving the original motion trajectories, character movements, and camera angles. The final output should feel like a cohesive abstract artwork brought to life, with every movement and frame maintaining the integrity of the source video’s narrative flow.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit completely failed to apply the requested abstract art style. No color gradients, motion blurs, or non-representational patterns were added. The video remains virtually unchanged from the original.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1"}
{"base": "0039_global_style_Apply_the_Ukiyoe_ani", "edited_type": "global_style", "prompt": "Apply the Ukiyoe animation style to this video, ensuring seamless temporal consistency across all frames. The final output should emulate the fluidity of traditional Ukiyoe art, with smooth transitions between frames, flat color palettes, and bold outlines. Preserve all original motion, character actions, and camera movements, maintaining the video’s narrative flow and visual coherence.", "scores": [3, 2, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The style is applied with bold outlines, but it fails on temporal consistency. There is significant flickering on the ground textures, making the video unstable and distracting to watch.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2"}
{"base": "0043_global_style_Apply_the_oil_painti", "edited_type": "global_style", "prompt": "Apply the oil painting style to this video, ensuring absolute temporal consistency across all frames. The result should emulate the look of a live-action film rendered in the classic oil painting medium, complete with dynamic brushstroke textures that appear to move with the scene’s motion—whether characters walk, objects shift, or the camera pans. Preserve all original camera movements, character actions, and narrative pacing, ensuring the final video feels both authentic and visually cohesive, with no flickering or jarring style changes.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit completely fails to apply the requested oil painting style. Instead, a subtle beautifying filter was used, missing the core instruction for brushstrokes and painterly texture entirely.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1"}
{"base": "0052_global_style_Apply_the_Chinese_In", "edited_type": "global_style", "prompt": "Apply the Chinese Ink Wash Painting style to this video, ensuring seamless temporal consistency across all frames. The final output should emulate classic ink wash art, with animated ink smudging, blended textures, and a soft, ethereal glow. Preserve all original motion, character actions, camera movements, and narrative flow—only the visual style should transform into the traditional ink wash aesthetic.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edited video is identical to the original. No style transfer was applied, failing to meet any part of the instruction.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1"}
{"base": "0045_global_style_Apply_the_immersive", "edited_type": "global_style", "prompt": "Apply the immersive Snowy style to this video, ensuring seamless temporal consistency across all frames. The final output should evoke a winter wonderland, complete with dynamic snowfall, frosty textures, and soft, diffused lighting. All original motion, character actions, and camera movements must be precisely preserved.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit failed entirely. The requested snowy style, including snowfall and frosty textures, is completely absent. The output video is identical to the original, showing no attempt at editing.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1"}
{"base": "0050_global_style_Apply_the_Thick_Pain", "edited_type": "global_style", "prompt": "Apply the Thick-Paint Hand-Drawn Style to this video, ensuring seamless temporal consistency across all frames. The final output should emulate the look of a hand-painted film, with deliberate brushstrokes and thick impasto textures that flow naturally with the video's motion. All original motion, character actions, and camera movements must be perfectly preserved to maintain the video's narrative flow and visual coherence.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The requested thick-paint, hand-drawn style is completely absent. The edited video appears nearly identical to the original, indicating a failure to apply the instructed artistic effect.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1"}
{"base": "0047_global_style_Apply_the_Watercolor", "edited_type": "global_style", "prompt": "Apply the Watercolor animation style to this video, ensuring seamless temporal consistency across all frames. The final result should mirror the soft, painterly aesthetic of watercolor art, with blended colors, fluid transitions, and gentle motion blur that aligns with the medium's organic flow. Preserve the original motion, character actions, camera movements, and narrative flow, ensuring no frame exhibits jarring changes or inconsistencies in color or texture.", "scores": [4, 4, 4], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit successfully applies a soft, painterly style that is visually stable and preserves details well. However, it lacks the distinct fluid transitions and texture of watercolor animation.\nInstruction Compliance: 4\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 4\nVisual Quality & Stability: 4"}
{"base": "0051_global_style_Apply_the_Thick_pain", "edited_type": "global_style", "prompt": "Apply the Thick-paint Hand-drawn animation style to this video, ensuring seamless temporal consistency across all frames. The result should exhibit the characteristic bold brushwork, textured surfaces, and dynamic color transitions typical of this style. Preserve all original motion, character actions, and camera movements to maintain the narrative flow and visual coherence.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit completely fails to apply the requested hand-drawn, thick-paint style. It only increases color saturation, missing the stylistic instruction entirely.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1"}
{"base": "0243_local_add_Overlay_an_animated", "edited_type": "local_add", "prompt": "Overlay an animated pair of reading glasses on the bedspread near the person's left hand. The glasses must be tracked to the blanket surface as the camera moves. They should remain stationary relative to the blanket, with reflections dynamically adapting to the changing light. All other parts of the video must remain unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The video is unchanged. No glasses were added to the bedspread as instructed.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0054_global_style_Apply_the_Chinese_In", "edited_type": "global_style", "prompt": "Apply the Chinese Ink Wash Painting style to this video, ensuring seamless temporal consistency across all frames. The final output should emulate the aesthetic of traditional Chinese ink art, with fluid brushstroke dynamics, muted color palettes, and soft, diffused edges. Preserve all original motion, character actions, camera movements, and narrative flow, maintaining a cohesive and visually harmonious sequence.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit completely fails to apply the requested Chinese ink wash style. The video appears to have only undergone a minor color/contrast adjustment, with none of the specified artistic elements.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1"}
{"base": "0056_global_style_Apply_the_dawn_aesth", "edited_type": "global_style", "prompt": "Apply the dawn aesthetic to this video, ensuring seamless temporal consistency across all frames. The final output should emulate the gradual transition of light at sunrise, with soft pink and orange sky gradients, and consistent golden-hour glow. All original motion, character actions, and camera movements must be perfectly maintained.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The dawn aesthetic is flawlessly rendered with accurate colors and a golden glow. All original details are perfectly preserved, and the video is completely stable with zero flickering.\nInstruction Compliance: 5\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5"}
{"base": "0241_local_add_Overlay_an_animated", "edited_type": "local_add", "prompt": "Overlay an animated small wooden stool near the base of the blue curtain to the right of the person. The stool must be tracked to the floor as the camera moves, maintaining consistent shadows and lighting. All other parts of the video must remain unchanged.", "scores": [4, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The stool is added correctly, but it is static, not animated. The shadow is a bit too dark.\nInstruction Compliance: 4\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3"}
{"base": "0245_local_add_Overlay_an_animated", "edited_type": "local_add", "prompt": "Overlay an animated clear glass of water on the right side of the wooden cutting board. The glass must be perfectly tracked to the table surface as the camera moves. The water inside should have subtle light reflections and refractions that dynamically change with the lighting. All other parts of the video must remain unchanged.", "scores": [2, 2, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The added glass is a static image with no animation and incorrectly occludes the person's hand.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0055_global_style_Apply_the_Rainy_Styl", "edited_type": "global_style", "prompt": "Apply the Rainy Style to this video, ensuring seamless temporal consistency across all frames. The final output should depict dynamic rain effects—including wet surfaces that glisten and reflections that adjust with movement—while perfectly maintaining the original motion, character actions, camera movements, and narrative flow.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit failed to apply the requested rainy style. The output video is virtually unchanged from the original sunny day scene, with no rain or wet effects added.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1"}
{"base": "0247_local_add_Overlay_an_animated", "edited_type": "local_add", "prompt": "Overlay an animated pair of sunglasses on the man's shirt collar near the top button. The sunglasses must be perfectly tracked to the shirt as the camera moves. Their reflections and shadows should dynamically adapt to the changing light. All other parts of the video must remain unchanged.", "scores": [3, 2, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The sunglasses are static and not tracked to the shirt's movement. Reflections and shadows are also static.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2"}
{"base": "0248_local_add_Overlay_an_animated", "edited_type": "local_add", "prompt": "Overlay an animated small potted green plant on the white shelf behind the man near the 'Barkley' sign. The plant's leaves should have a subtle swaying motion. The object must be perfectly tracked to the shelf as the camera moves. All other parts of the video must remain unchanged.", "scores": [3, 3, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The plant was added to the wrong shelf, lacks the requested animation, and casts no shadow.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2"}
{"base": "0048_global_style_Apply_the_Chinese_In", "edited_type": "global_style", "prompt": "Apply the Chinese Ink Wash Painting style to this video, ensuring seamless temporal consistency across all frames. The output should mimic traditional ink wash animation, with fluid ink flow and consistent brushstroke patterns. Preserve all original motion, character actions, and camera movements to maintain narrative coherence.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit is a generic cartoon filter, completely missing the requested Chinese Ink Wash Painting style. The fundamental aesthetic instruction was not followed, resulting in a wrong style application.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1"}
{"base": "0246_local_add_Overlay_an_animated", "edited_type": "local_add", "prompt": "Overlay an animated seagull flying in the sky near the top left quadrant. The bird should be tracked relative to the background sky, smoothly flapping its wings and gliding across the frame. All other parts of the video must remain unchanged.", "scores": [2, 2, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The added seagull has a severe occlusion error, appearing behind the sailboat's mast despite being in the foreground.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0049_global_style_Apply_the_Pop_Art_an", "edited_type": "global_style", "prompt": "Apply the Pop Art animation style to this video, ensuring seamless temporal consistency across all frames. The result should mirror the aesthetic of classic Pop Art, with vivid colors, repetitive patterns, and Ben-Day dots integrated smoothly into each frame. Preserve the original motion, character movements, camera angles, and narrative flow without any abrupt or jarring style changes.", "scores": [3, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The Pop Art style is only applied to the background. The main subject remains photorealistic, making the style application patchy and incomplete, despite good stability and detail preservation.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3"}
{"base": "0249_local_add_Overlay_an_animated", "edited_type": "local_add", "prompt": "Overlay an animated blue water bowl on the floor in front of the dog, slightly to the left. The bowl should be tracked to the floor surface as the camera moves. The water inside should have gentle ripples and reflections that respond to the lighting changes. All other parts of the video must remain unchanged.", "scores": [3, 3, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The bowl is added, but it is static, lacks the requested animation, and has no shadow.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2"}
{"base": "0242_local_add_Overlay_an_animated", "edited_type": "local_add", "prompt": "Overlay an animated pigeon onto the cobblestone street near the man's feet, slightly to the left. The pigeon should have subtle natural movements such as pecking and slight head turns. It must be perfectly tracked to the street surface as the camera moves. All other parts of the video must remain unchanged.", "scores": [3, 2, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The added pigeon slides unnaturally on the ground, lacks a shadow, and has mismatched lighting, making it look pasted on.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0057_global_style_Apply_the_Rainy_aest", "edited_type": "global_style", "prompt": "Apply the Rainy aesthetic to this video, ensuring seamless temporal consistency across all frames. Each frame should maintain the original motion, character actions, and camera movements while incorporating dynamic rain effects—such as falling droplets, wet reflections, and atmospheric moisture—that blend smoothly without flickering. The final output should feel like a live, authentic rainy moment captured on camera.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The requested rainy aesthetic is completely absent. The video remains a sunny day scene with no changes, failing to follow the core instruction of adding rain.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1"}
{"base": "0252_local_add_Overlay_an_animated", "edited_type": "local_add", "prompt": "Overlay an animated round wall clock onto the empty wall space above the black cabinet. The clock must be tracked to the wall and its hands should move correctly over time, with the second hand ticking visibly. All other parts of the video must remain unchanged.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The animated clock is perfectly added, lit, and animated, with realistic hand movement and a subtle shadow.\nInstruction Compliance: 5\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5"}
{"base": "0251_local_add_Overlay_an_animated", "edited_type": "local_add", "prompt": "Overlay an animated white ceramic coffee mug onto the desk near the keyboard. The mug must be perfectly tracked to the desk surface as the camera moves slightly. Its glossy reflections and shadow should dynamically adapt to the changing light. All other parts of the video must remain unchanged.", "scores": [4, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The mug is added correctly, but its lighting feels slightly flat and it lacks the specified glossy reflections.\nInstruction Compliance: 4\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3"}
{"base": "0244_local_add_Overlay_an_animated", "edited_type": "local_add", "prompt": "Overlay an animated colorful kite flying in the upper left sky area. The kite should sway and flutter naturally with the wind, tracked relative to the sky as the camera moves. Its shadow on the ground should shift dynamically with the sun's position. All other parts of the video must remain unchanged.", "scores": [2, 2, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The added kite is a static image, not animated. It also lacks the requested shadow on the ground.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0250_local_add_Overlay_an_animated", "edited_type": "local_add", "prompt": "Overlay an animated flying seagull in the sky near the top right quadrant. The bird should be tracked relative to the sky as the camera moves, with smooth wing flapping motion and subtle shadow movement on the water below. All other parts of the video must remain unchanged.", "scores": [3, 2, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The seagull's animation is very jerky and unnatural. The requested shadow on the water is also missing.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2"}
{"base": "0257_local_add_Overlay_an_animated", "edited_type": "local_add", "prompt": "Overlay an animated pair of black-framed sunglasses on the dashboard near the windshield on the passenger side. The sunglasses must be tracked to the dashboard as the camera moves, with reflections dynamically adapting to the changing light. All other parts of the video must remain unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The sunglasses were added to the person's face instead of the instructed dashboard location.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0253_local_add_Overlay_an_animated", "edited_type": "local_add", "prompt": "Overlay an animated colorful kite in the upper left sky area of the video. The kite should flutter and sway gently as it flies, with its tail moving naturally in the wind. The kite must be tracked to the sky background as the camera moves, with lighting and shadows adjusting dynamically. All other parts of the video must remain unchanged.", "scores": [5, 4, 4], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The kite is correctly added and animated. The visual quality is high, but the motion is slightly too linear.\nInstruction Compliance: 5\nVisual Quality & Stability: 4\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 4"}
{"base": "0254_local_add_Overlay_an_animated", "edited_type": "local_add", "prompt": "Overlay an animated small ceramic cat figurine on the top right corner of the yellow chair's backrest. The figurine must be perfectly tracked to the chair as the camera moves. Its glossy surface should reflect the changing light dynamically. All other parts of the video must remain unchanged.", "scores": [3, 3, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The added cat figurine is static, not animated as requested, and its lighting does not match the scene.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2"}
{"base": "0053_global_style_Apply_the_Sketch_ani", "edited_type": "global_style", "prompt": "Apply the Sketch animation style to this video, ensuring frame-by-frame consistency to maintain visual harmony. The final output should mirror the fluidity of traditional sketch art, with smooth linework and intentional shading that aligns with the Sketch aesthetic. All original motion—including character movements, camera pans, and environmental dynamics—must be precisely preserved, ensuring the video flows as coherently as the original footage.", "scores": [4, 4, 4], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The comic-like style is well-applied and perfectly stable. Although it deviates slightly from a \"sketch\" aesthetic, all original details and the scene's static nature are flawlessly preserved.\nInstruction Compliance: 4\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 4\nVisual Quality & Stability: 4"}
{"base": "0258_local_add_Overlay_an_animated", "edited_type": "local_add", "prompt": "Overlay an animated red rubber ball on the grass in front of the character. The ball should bounce up and down smoothly, with reflections and shadows dynamically changing with the light. It must remain fixed relative to the grass as the camera moves. All other parts of the video must remain unchanged.", "scores": [2, 2, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The ball is in the wrong location and does not bounce as instructed. Occlusion and shadows are unrealistic.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0255_local_add_Overlay_an_animated", "edited_type": "local_add", "prompt": "Overlay an animated dragonfly hovering just above the water surface near the top-right quadrant. The dragonfly's wings should flutter rapidly with subtle iridescence. It should be tracked relative to the water surface and background foliage, with its shadow and reflection dynamically adapting to the light and ripples. All other parts of the video must remain unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The editor replaced the snake with a dragonfly, which fundamentally violates the instruction to add an object.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0261_local_add_Overlay_an_animated", "edited_type": "local_add", "prompt": "Overlay an animated pair of wooden chopsticks diagonally across the bottom right edge of the plate, tracked perfectly to the plate and surface as the camera moves. The chopsticks should have subtle light reflections that change dynamically with the lighting. All other parts of the video must remain unchanged.", "scores": [3, 3, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The chopsticks were added, but they are static and lack the requested dynamic light reflections and realistic shadows.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2"}
{"base": "0263_local_add_Overlay_an_animated", "edited_type": "local_add", "prompt": "Overlay an animated bicycle leaning against the yellow concrete pillar on the left side of the rooftop parking area. The bicycle must be perfectly tracked to the pillar and ground as the camera moves. It should remain stationary relative to the pillar, with reflections and shadows dynamically adapting to the changing light. All other parts of the video must remain unchanged.", "scores": [2, 2, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The bicycle is not leaning against the pillar. The lighting and shadow are inconsistent with the environment.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2"}
{"base": "0266_local_add_Overlay_an_animated", "edited_type": "local_add", "prompt": "Overlay an animated black metal music stand to the right side of the seated man holding the guitar. The stand should remain fixed relative to the man as the camera moves, with subtle reflections and shadows adapting to the lighting changes. All other parts of the video must remain unchanged.", "scores": [2, 2, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The wrong object was added (a light stand, not a music stand) and it's static. It looks pasted on, with no shadows or lighting integration.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0259_local_add_Overlay_an_animated", "edited_type": "local_add", "prompt": "Overlay an animated snowman standing on the snow field near the footprints. The snowman should remain fixed relative to the snow surface as the camera moves, with subtle scarf fluttering and dynamic shadows adapting to the changing light. All other parts of the video must remain unchanged.", "scores": [3, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: Snowman added, but it is static. It lacks the requested scarf animation and dynamic shadows, making it feel unnatural.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3"}
{"base": "0260_local_add_Overlay_an_animated", "edited_type": "local_add", "prompt": "Overlay an animated small white sailboat on the horizon slightly to the right of center. The boat should be tracked to the water surface as the camera moves, with gentle sailing motion and sails fluttering subtly. Reflections and shadows on the water should dynamically adapt to the changing light and waves. All other parts of the video must remain unchanged.", "scores": [2, 2, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The boat is a static image, not animated. Its position and size are incorrect, and the reflection is unrealistic.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0268_local_add_Overlay_an_animated", "edited_type": "local_add", "prompt": "Overlay an animated red and white checkered kitchen towel draped over the edge of the kitchen island in front of the woman. The towel should have subtle, natural movements as if affected by a gentle breeze. The towel must be tracked to the countertop edge as the camera moves, with shadows and lighting adapting dynamically. All other parts of the video must remain unchanged.", "scores": [2, 2, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The added towel is a static image. It lacks the requested animation, shadows, and realistic lighting, making it look fake.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0269_local_add_Overlay_an_animated", "edited_type": "local_add", "prompt": "Overlay an animated floor lamp near the corner of the room to the left of the desk. The lamp's light should softly flicker and cast dynamic shadows on the wall and floor as the camera moves. The lamp must be perfectly tracked to the floor and wall corner. All other parts of the video must remain unchanged.", "scores": [3, 3, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The correct lamp was added, but it is static and does not cast shadows as instructed.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2"}
{"base": "0267_local_add_Overlay_an_animated", "edited_type": "local_add", "prompt": "Overlay an animated colorful sunshade onto the rear passenger window behind the child. The sunshade must be perfectly tracked to the window as the camera moves. It should flutter slightly with the car's motion, and its shadows inside the car should dynamically adapt to the changing light. All other parts of the video must remain unchanged.", "scores": [3, 3, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The correct object was added, but the requested animation and shadow effects are completely absent, and it appears pasted on.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2"}
{"base": "0271_local_add_Overlay_an_animated", "edited_type": "local_add", "prompt": "Overlay an animated red canoe floating on the water near the left side. The canoe should be tracked to the water surface as the camera moves, gently rocking with the water's motion. Its reflections and shadows should dynamically adapt to the changing light. All other parts of the video must remain unchanged.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The canoe is perfectly added with realistic reflections, shadows, and subtle motion that fits the scene.\nInstruction Compliance: 5\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5"}
{"base": "0256_local_add_Overlay_an_animated", "edited_type": "local_add", "prompt": "Overlay an animated wooden hiking stick held in the right hand of the person walking. The stick must be perfectly tracked to the hand's movements, moving naturally as the person walks. Its shadow on the grass should dynamically adapt to the changing light and the stick's motion. All other parts of the video must remain unchanged.", "scores": [2, 2, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The added stick is completely static and not held by the person, failing the motion and interaction instructions.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0265_local_add_Add_an_animated_smal", "edited_type": "local_add", "prompt": "Add an animated small frog sitting on the large leaf, tracked to the leaf's surface as it moves. The frog should have subtle breathing motions and occasional blinking. Shadows and lighting on the frog should adapt dynamically to the natural light changes in the video. All other parts of the video must remain unchanged.", "scores": [2, 2, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The frog is a static image, not animated. It is not tracked to the leaf's motion and disappears abruptly.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0280_local_add_Overlay_an_animated", "edited_type": "local_add", "prompt": "Overlay an animated leather-bound book onto the wooden table to the right of the pine branch and candles. The book must be perfectly tracked to the table's surface as the camera moves. It should remain stationary relative to the table, while its reflections and shadows dynamically adapt to the flickering candlelight. All other parts of the video must remain unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The editing instruction was not followed. No object was added to the video.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0262_local_add_Overlay_an_animated", "edited_type": "local_add", "prompt": "Overlay an animated quadcopter drone hovering above the off-road vehicle. The drone's rotors should spin realistically, and it should be tracked relative to the sky as the camera moves. Its shadow on the ground should move correspondingly with the drone's position and the sunlight angle. All other parts of the video must remain unchanged.", "scores": [2, 2, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The drone was added, but the required shadow is completely missing, which is a major physical error.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0273_local_add_Overlay_an_animated", "edited_type": "local_add", "prompt": "Overlay an animated seagull flying in the upper right quadrant of the sky. The bird should flap its wings naturally and move smoothly across the sky, with its shadow softly shifting on the clouds below. The seagull must be tracked relative to the sky as the camera moves. All other parts of the video must remain unchanged.", "scores": [3, 3, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The seagull was added, but it doesn't move across the sky or have a shadow as requested.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2"}
{"base": "0276_local_add_Overlay_an_animated", "edited_type": "local_add", "prompt": "Overlay an animated digital kitchen timer onto the marble countertop near the measuring spoons. The timer must be perfectly tracked to the countertop as the camera moves. The digital display should animate realistically, showing a countdown or blinking digits. All other parts of the video must remain unchanged.", "scores": [5, 3, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The added timer is correct, but it looks pasted on due to a lack of shadows and realistic lighting.\nInstruction Compliance: 5\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2"}
{"base": "0277_local_add_Overlay_an_animated", "edited_type": "local_add", "prompt": "Overlay an animated wristwatch on the wrist of the hand holding the pear. The watch must be tracked to the wrist, with the watch hands moving realistically over time and reflections dynamically changing with lighting. All other parts of the video must remain unchanged.", "scores": [3, 3, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The watch tracking is poor and lacks dynamic reflections. It appears pasted on with incorrect lighting and shadows.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2"}
{"base": "0270_local_add_Overlay_an_animated", "edited_type": "local_add", "prompt": "Overlay an animated colorful butterfly perched on a purple flower near the center-left of the scene. The butterfly should gently flutter its wings and remain tracked to the flower as it moves slightly with the breeze. The butterfly's shadows and reflections should dynamically adapt to the natural lighting changes. All other parts of the video must remain unchanged.", "scores": [2, 2, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The butterfly is not perched on a flower and clips through the dog's head, a severe occlusion error.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0264_local_add_Overlay_an_animated", "edited_type": "local_add", "prompt": "Overlay an animated small white sailboat on the calm water near the center-left of the video frame. The boat should be tracked to the water surface, moving slowly and smoothly as if sailing. Its sails should flutter gently, and reflections on the water should dynamically respond to the light and water movement. All other parts of the video must remain unchanged.", "scores": [3, 3, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The sailboat lacks animation and dynamic reflections. Its motion is physically incorrect, and the background color is changed.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2"}
{"base": "0282_local_add_Overlay_an_animated", "edited_type": "local_add", "prompt": "Overlay an animated small ceramic vase onto the wooden surface near the candle holder, slightly behind and to the left of the candle. The vase must be perfectly tracked to the surface as the camera subtly moves. It should remain stationary relative to the surface, while its reflections and shadows dynamically adapt to the flickering candlelight and ambient window light. All other parts of the video must remain unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: No object was added. The editing instruction was completely ignored.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0272_local_add_Overlay_an_animated", "edited_type": "local_add", "prompt": "Overlay an animated small dog walking alongside the couple on the bridge. The dog must be tracked to the bridge floor, moving naturally with the couple's pace. Its fur and shadow should dynamically respond to the lighting and motion. All other parts of the video must remain unchanged.", "scores": [3, 3, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: A dog was added, but it's behind the couple, not alongside, and is completely missing a shadow.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2"}
{"base": "0286_local_add_Overlay_an_animated", "edited_type": "local_add", "prompt": "Overlay an animated small black backpack on the man's right shoulder, tracking the shoulder's movement precisely. The backpack's texture and reflections should dynamically respond to the changing outdoor light. All other parts of the video must remain unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The instruction to add a backpack was not followed. No backpack was added to the video.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0284_local_add_Overlay_an_animated", "edited_type": "local_add", "prompt": "Overlay an animated metal kettle on the left edge of the fire pit, tracking it precisely as the camera moves. The kettle should remain fixed relative to the fire pit, with dynamic reflections of the flickering firelight on its surface. All other parts of the video must remain unchanged.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The metal kettle is added perfectly, with realistic dynamic reflections of the fire and seamless integration into the scene.\nInstruction Compliance: 5\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5"}
{"base": "0281_local_add_Overlay_an_animated", "edited_type": "local_add", "prompt": "Overlay an animated pair of reading glasses onto the open book near the bottom right corner of the right page. The glasses must be perfectly tracked to the book's surface as the camera subtly moves. The reflections on the lenses should dynamically adapt to the flickering candlelight. All other parts of the video must remain unchanged.", "scores": [2, 2, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The glasses are added but are completely static, not tracked to the book's movement, and lack reflections.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0279_local_add_Overlay_an_animated", "edited_type": "local_add", "prompt": "Overlay an animated small framed picture on the blue wall behind the woman in the video. The picture must be tracked to the wall as the camera moves. The glass surface of the frame should reflect subtle changes in light. All other parts of the video must remain unchanged.", "scores": [3, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: A static picture was added, but the instructions for animation and reflections were not followed.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3"}
{"base": "0283_local_add_Overlay_an_animated", "edited_type": "local_add", "prompt": "Overlay an animated colorful throw pillow on the sofa near the woman's left arm. The pillow must be perfectly tracked to the sofa as the camera moves. Its shadows and light reflections should dynamically adapt to the changing lighting. All other parts of the video must remain unchanged.", "scores": [5, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The sticker was added, but its lighting and color do not match the scene, making it look fake.\nInstruction Compliance: 5\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3"}
{"base": "0278_local_add_Overlay_an_animated", "edited_type": "local_add", "prompt": "Overlay an animated laptop onto the table surface in front of the man. The laptop must be tracked to the table as the camera moves, remaining stationary relative to the table. Its screen should reflect subtle changes in lighting dynamically. All other parts of the video must remain unchanged.", "scores": [3, 3, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The added laptop is floating in mid-air without a supporting surface or a cast shadow.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0285_local_add_Overlay_an_animated", "edited_type": "local_add", "prompt": "Overlay an animated honeybee near the butterfly on the purple flowers. The bee should be tracked to the flowers' surface, moving subtly as if collecting nectar, with its wings gently flapping. The bee's shadows and reflections should dynamically adapt to the changing light. All other parts of the video must remain unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: No edit was performed; the requested honeybee was not added to the video.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0275_local_add_Overlay_an_animated", "edited_type": "local_add", "prompt": "Overlay an animated small white motorboat on the water near the right side of the image. The boat should move smoothly from right to left, with its reflections and shadows dynamically adapting to the water's motion and changing light. The boat must be tracked relative to the water surface as the camera moves. All other parts of the video must remain unchanged.", "scores": [4, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The boat is added correctly, but it lacks a wake, and its reflections and lighting are not realistic.\nInstruction Compliance: 4\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3"}
{"base": "0287_local_add_Overlay_an_animated", "edited_type": "local_add", "prompt": "Overlay an animated street lamp post onto the grassy area near the sidewalk on the right side of the video. The lamp post must be perfectly tracked to the ground as the camera moves. It should remain stationary relative to the grass, while the glass lantern reflects the changing light dynamically. All other parts of the video must remain unchanged.", "scores": [3, 3, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The lamp post is added but is lit during the day and has no shadow, making it unrealistic.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2"}
{"base": "0274_local_add_Overlay_an_animated", "edited_type": "local_add", "prompt": "Overlay an animated colorful beach ball onto the sandy beach near the shoreline. The ball should have a slight rolling motion as if moved by a gentle breeze or small wave. It must be tracked to the sand surface as the camera moves. All other parts of the video must remain unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: No edit was performed on the video. The instruction to add a beach ball was completely ignored.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0289_local_add_Overlay_an_animated", "edited_type": "local_add", "prompt": "Overlay an animated flock of birds flying in a V formation across the sky above the city. The birds should flap their wings naturally and move smoothly from left to right. They must be tracked relative to the sky background as the camera moves, with lighting consistent with the scene. All other parts of the video must remain unchanged.", "scores": [4, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The birds are added, but their wing flapping is synchronized and unnatural, making the animation look artificial.\nInstruction Compliance: 4\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3"}
{"base": "0288_local_add_Overlay_an_animated", "edited_type": "local_add", "prompt": "Overlay an animated bicycle parked near the tree trunk on the sidewalk. The bicycle must be perfectly tracked to the sidewalk and tree as the camera moves. It should remain stationary relative to the ground, with lighting and shadows dynamically adapting to the natural daylight changes. All other parts of the video must remain unchanged.", "scores": [2, 2, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: Two bicycles were added instead of one, and one incorrectly moves. The objects look like flat cutouts.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2"}
{"base": "0291_local_add_Overlay_an_animated", "edited_type": "local_add", "prompt": "Overlay an animated wooden bench onto the grassy area on the right side of the scene. The bench must be perfectly tracked to the ground as the camera moves. It should remain stationary relative to the grass, while its shadows and lighting dynamically adapt to the changing sunlight. All other parts of the video must remain unchanged.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The bench is added perfectly, with correct lighting, shadows, and flawless occlusion by the chicken running past.\nInstruction Compliance: 5.\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5.\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5."}
{"base": "0297_local_add_Overlay_an_animated", "edited_type": "local_add", "prompt": "Overlay an animated small wooden side table near the clothing rack, ensuring it is tracked to the floor as the camera moves. The table remains stationary relative to the floor, with lighting and shadows dynamically adapting to the scene. All other parts of the video must remain unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The requested wooden side table was not added to the video. No edit was performed.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0293_local_add_Overlay_an_animated", "edited_type": "local_add", "prompt": "Overlay an animated small glass vase with flowers onto the wooden table near the white plate. The vase and flowers should be perfectly tracked to the table's surface as the camera subtly moves. The flowers should have a gentle swaying motion, and the vase's reflections and shadows should dynamically adapt to the changing light. All other parts of the video must remain unchanged.", "scores": [2, 2, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The wrong object was added, and key instructions like animation, shadows, and reflections were completely ignored.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2"}
{"base": "0290_local_add_Overlay_an_animated", "edited_type": "local_add", "prompt": "Overlay an animated small dark green backpack onto the person's back, ensuring it is perfectly tracked to their movements. The backpack should sway subtly as the person walks, with lighting and shadows dynamically adapting to the forest environment. All other parts of the video must remain unchanged.", "scores": [4, 4, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The backpack is tracked well, but it lacks the instructed subtle sway and realistic contact shadows.\nInstruction Compliance: 4\nVisual Quality & Stability: 4\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3"}
{"base": "0292_local_add_Add_an_animated_wall", "edited_type": "local_add", "prompt": "Add an animated wall clock to the plain wall to the left of the person. The clock must be tracked to the wall. The clock's hands must move correctly over time, with the second hand visibly ticking. All other parts of the video must remain unchanged.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The animated clock is added correctly. It's well-integrated with realistic lighting, shadows, and correct animation of the hands.\nInstruction Compliance: 5.\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5.\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5."}
{"base": "0295_local_add_Overlay_an_animated", "edited_type": "local_add", "prompt": "Overlay an animated colorful kite in the sky above the vehicle, slightly to the right of center. The kite and its tail should flutter naturally in the wind and be tracked relative to the sky as the camera moves. All other parts of the video must remain unchanged.", "scores": [2, 2, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit replaced the existing flag on the vehicle instead of adding a kite in the sky.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2"}
{"base": "0294_local_add_Overlay_an_animated", "edited_type": "local_add", "prompt": "Overlay an animated seagull standing near the shoreline on the sand. The bird should be tracked to the sand surface as the camera moves. The seagull's head and feathers should have subtle natural movements, while shadows and lighting adapt to the changing environment. All other parts of the video must remain unchanged.", "scores": [3, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The added seagull is a static image, not animated with subtle movements as requested in the prompt.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3"}
{"base": "0298_local_add_Overlay_an_animated", "edited_type": "local_add", "prompt": "Overlay an animated black cat sitting on the floor near the girl. The cat should be perfectly tracked to the floor as the camera moves, with subtle blinking eye animations and slight fur movement. Shadows and reflections should dynamically adapt to the lighting changes. All other parts of the video must remain unchanged.", "scores": [3, 3, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The added cat is missing a shadow, which makes it look pasted on and not physically present.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0300_local_add_Overlay_an_animated", "edited_type": "local_add", "prompt": "Overlay an animated small stack of three hardcover books on the right side of the desk between the pencil holder and the laptop. The books should be tracked to the desk surface as the camera moves, with shadows dynamically adapting to the lighting. All other parts of the video must remain unchanged.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The requested books were added in the correct location with perfect tracking, lighting, and realistic shadows.\nInstruction Compliance: 5\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5"}
{"base": "0304_local_add_Overlay_an_animated", "edited_type": "local_add", "prompt": "Overlay an animated small red ladybug onto the green leaf in the lower right area of the video. The ladybug should be tracked to the leaf surface, moving slowly and naturally as if crawling. Its shell should reflect changing light and cast dynamic shadows consistent with the scene. All other parts of the video must remain unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit failed completely, replacing the butterfly's wings with a ladybug shell instead of adding a ladybug.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0296_local_add_Overlay_an_animated", "edited_type": "local_add", "prompt": "Overlay an animated black microphone stand to the right side of the person, tracking the stand's position relative to the person as the camera moves. The stand should remain fixed in place and its metallic surface should dynamically reflect changes in lighting. All other parts of the video must remain unchanged.", "scores": [3, 2, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The added microphone stand is not black, nor does it track the person's movement; it is completely static.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2"}
{"base": "0301_local_add_Overlay_an_animated", "edited_type": "local_add", "prompt": "Overlay an animated parked bicycle near the right side of the corridor close to the columns. The bicycle must be tracked to the floor as the camera moves. Its shadow should dynamically adapt to the changing sunlight and shadows from the columns. All other parts of the video must remain unchanged.", "scores": [2, 2, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: Two bicycles were added instead of one, and one was placed in the wrong location.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2"}
{"base": "0065_local_change_Replace_the_womans", "edited_type": "local_change", "prompt": "Replace the woman's pink jacket with a navy blue business blazer and white blouse, keeping the same pose and position within the video scene.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit perfectly replaces the clothing as requested, with seamless integration and no visible artifacts or inconsistencies.\nInstruction Compliance: 5\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5"}
{"base": "0299_local_add_Overlay_an_animated", "edited_type": "local_add", "prompt": "Overlay an animated small potted succulent plant on the desk surface to the left of the books. The plant's leaves should have a very subtle swaying motion. The object must remain fixed in place relative to the desk as the camera moves. All other parts of the video must remain unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit replaced the original action of placing a photo, instead of overlaying a plant on the desk.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0060_local_change_Replace_the_poster_w", "edited_type": "local_change", "prompt": "Replace the poster with a retro video game poster featuring pixel art characters, ensuring it maintains the same position and pose within the video scene.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The poster was correctly replaced with pixel art, matching the position and integrating seamlessly into the scene.\nInstruction Compliance: 5\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5"}
{"base": "0306_local_add_Overlay_an_animated", "edited_type": "local_add", "prompt": "Overlay an animated skateboard on the ground near the water bottle. The skateboard must be perfectly tracked to the asphalt surface as the camera moves. It should remain stationary relative to the ground, while its shadows dynamically adapt to the changing sunlight. All other parts of the video must remain unchanged.", "scores": [3, 3, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The skateboard is added, but its shadow is static, too dark, and unrealistic, failing a key instruction.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2"}
{"base": "0302_local_add_Overlay_an_animated", "edited_type": "local_add", "prompt": "Overlay an animated colorful kite flying in the upper right quadrant of the sky. The kite should move gently with the wind, swaying and fluttering its tail realistically. The kite must remain fixed relative to the sky as the camera moves. All other parts of the video must remain unchanged.", "scores": [3, 2, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The kite is the correct object but lacks realistic animation and is not properly tracked to the scene.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0305_local_add_Overlay_an_animated", "edited_type": "local_add", "prompt": "Overlay an animated colorful patterned scarf around the person's neck. The scarf should have subtle fabric movement as the person moves. It must be perfectly tracked to the neck area. All other parts of the video must remain unchanged.", "scores": [3, 2, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The scarf is static, not animated as requested. It looks pasted on, with no shadows or natural wrapping.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0063_local_change_Replace_the_current", "edited_type": "local_change", "prompt": "Replace the current desk with a rustic farmhouse style wooden desk, ensuring it maintains the desk's exact position and pose within the scene.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The desk was perfectly replaced with the requested style. The integration is seamless with no visual errors.\nInstruction Compliance: 5\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5"}
{"base": "0064_local_change_Replace_the_womans", "edited_type": "local_change", "prompt": "Replace the woman’s maroon sleeveless outfit with a white sleeveless blouse and denim shorts, ensuring she maintains the same pose and position within the scene.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit perfectly replaces the outfit as instructed, with excellent visual quality and seamless integration.\nInstruction Compliance: 5.\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5.\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5."}
{"base": "0061_local_change_Change_the_mans_hai", "edited_type": "local_change", "prompt": "Change the man's hair color to platinum blonde and adjust his beard accordingly, ensuring he maintains the same position and pose within the scene.", "scores": [3, 1, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The hair and beard color are correct, but the video is a short, jerky loop, completely failing to match the original motion.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1"}
{"base": "0059_local_change_Replace_the_white_co", "edited_type": "local_change", "prompt": "Replace the white compact car with a sleek, futuristic electric sports car in metallic blue, ensuring it maintains the same position and pose within the video scene.", "scores": [3, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: Two cars were replaced instead of the specified single white car.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3"}
{"base": "0066_local_change_Replace_the_red_Rena", "edited_type": "local_change", "prompt": "Replace the red Renault Duster car with a rugged off-road version featuring larger tires and roof-mounted spotlights, ensuring it maintains the car's exact position and pose within the scene.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit perfectly adds rugged features as requested, with seamless integration and realistic motion.\nInstruction Compliance: 5\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5"}
{"base": "0062_local_change_Replace_the_dog_in_t", "edited_type": "local_change", "prompt": "Replace the dog in the orange sweater with a dog wearing a cozy blue winter jacket and knitted hat, maintaining the same position and pose within the video scene.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The replacement is perfect, maintaining the dog's original motion. The new clothing is seamless and looks realistic.\nInstruction Compliance: 5\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5"}
{"base": "0067_local_change_Replace_the_man_with", "edited_type": "local_change", "prompt": "Replace the man with an elderly gentleman with silver hair and wrinkles, maintaining the same pose and position within the scene.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The replacement is flawless, perfectly matching the description, pose, and motion with seamless visual integration.\nInstruction Compliance: 5\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5"}
{"base": "0058_local_change_Replace_the_silver_s", "edited_type": "local_change", "prompt": "Replace the silver sedan car with a sleek, futuristic electric car with glowing blue accents, ensuring it maintains the same position and pose within the video scene.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit replaced the wrong vehicle, an auto-rickshaw, instead of the specified silver sedan.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1"}
{"base": "0307_local_add_Overlay_an_animated", "edited_type": "local_add", "prompt": "Overlay an animated small brown dog on a leash near the person in the blue jacket. The dog should be tracked to the ground and move naturally with slight tail wagging and head turns. The leash should move subtly with the person's hand. Shadows and lighting on the dog should adapt dynamically to the changing sunset light. All other parts of the video must remain unchanged.", "scores": [3, 3, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The correct object was added, but it has major errors like a missing leash and glowing unnaturally.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2"}
{"base": "0068_local_change_Replace_the_car_with", "edited_type": "local_change", "prompt": "Replace the car with an armored military vehicle matte green in color with reinforced bumpers and heavy-duty tires, maintaining the same position and pose within the video scene.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The replacement is perfect, matching all attributes, and is seamlessly integrated with correct lighting, shadows, and motion.\nInstruction Compliance: 5\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5"}
{"base": "0069_local_change_Replace_the_tree_wit", "edited_type": "local_change", "prompt": "Replace the tree with a snow-covered winter tree with bare branches, ensuring it maintains the same position and pose within the video scene.", "scores": [3, 1, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit added snow to the ground, which was not requested. The added tree has inconsistent lighting and lacks shadows.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1"}
{"base": "0070_local_change_Replace_the_mans_ca", "edited_type": "local_change", "prompt": "Replace the man's casual green t-shirt with a sharp dark navy blue business suit, white shirt, and burgundy tie, maintaining the same position and pose within the scene.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit perfectly replaces the shirt with the specified suit, achieving a flawless and realistic result.\nInstruction Compliance: 5\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5"}
{"base": "0075_local_change_Replace_the_smooth_w", "edited_type": "local_change", "prompt": "Replace the smooth white table with a luxurious marble surface table, ensuring it maintains the same position and pose within the video scene.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The marble table replacement is perfect, with excellent integration and realistic reflections that match the scene.\nInstruction Compliance: 5.\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5.\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5."}
{"base": "0078_local_change_Add_stylish_black_ca", "edited_type": "local_change", "prompt": "Add stylish black cat-eye sunglasses to the woman, ensuring they fit her face and maintain her pose and position within the video scene.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit is perfect. The sunglasses are stylish, fit perfectly, and the lighting and stability are flawless.\nInstruction Compliance: 5\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5"}
{"base": "0072_local_change_Replace_the_middle_a", "edited_type": "local_change", "prompt": "Replace the middle-aged man with an elderly gentleman with silver hair and wrinkles, maintaining the same position and pose within the scene.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: Excellent replacement of the man. The edit is seamless, stable, and features flawless tracking and lighting integration.\nInstruction Compliance: 5.\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5.\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5."}
{"base": "0079_local_change_Replace_the_woman_wi", "edited_type": "local_change", "prompt": "Replace the woman with a mature woman in her 60s with silver hair, wearing the same coral outer garment and black inner shirt, ensuring the same pose and position within the scene.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit perfectly replaces the woman with the specified attributes, maintaining pose, clothing, and high visual quality.\nInstruction Compliance: 5\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5"}
{"base": "0071_local_change_Replace_the_pressure", "edited_type": "local_change", "prompt": "Replace the pressure cooker with a vibrant red pressure cooker with black handles, ensuring it maintains the same position and pose within the video scene.", "scores": [4, 4, 4], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The replacement is correct, but the woman's hand clips slightly into the new pressure cooker's lid handle.\nInstruction Compliance: 4\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 4\nVisual Quality & Stability: 4"}
{"base": "0076_local_change_Replace_the_womans", "edited_type": "local_change", "prompt": "Replace the woman's attire with a sleek navy blue business suit and light blue blouse, ensuring the new outfit fits her pose and position perfectly within the scene.", "scores": [3, 2, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The blouse color was not changed as instructed, and the original black blazer flickers through the edit.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2"}
{"base": "0074_local_change_Replace_the_wooden_d", "edited_type": "local_change", "prompt": "Replace the wooden dining table and chairs with a bohemian style rattan table and cushioned rattan chairs, maintaining the same position and pose within the scene.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The replacement is perfect, matching the requested style, and integrates seamlessly with realistic lighting and shadows.\nInstruction Compliance: 5.\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5.\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5."}
{"base": "0073_local_change_Replace_the_blue_spo", "edited_type": "local_change", "prompt": "Replace the blue sports car with an electric green eco-friendly car, ensuring it maintains the same position and pose within the video scene.", "scores": [4, 4, 4], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit is excellent, but the replacement is a coupe, not a convertible like the original car.\nInstruction Compliance: 4\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 4\nVisual Quality & Stability: 4"}
{"base": "0081_local_change_Replace_the_mans_bl", "edited_type": "local_change", "prompt": "Replace the man's black chef's jacket with a formal white double-breasted chef's jacket, maintaining the same position and pose within the scene.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit flawlessly replaces the jacket with the correct style, maintaining perfect consistency and visual quality throughout the clip.\nInstruction Compliance: 5.\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5.\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5."}
{"base": "0080_local_change_Replace_the_mans_li", "edited_type": "local_change", "prompt": "Replace the man's light gray suit jacket and white shirt with a sharp dark navy blue business suit jacket, white shirt, and red silk tie, ensuring the new attire fits his pose and position perfectly within the scene.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit flawlessly replaces the suit and adds the requested tie, with perfect tracking, lighting, and stability.\nInstruction Compliance: 5\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5"}
{"base": "0090_local_change_Replace_the_stool_wi", "edited_type": "local_change", "prompt": "Replace the stool with a rustic wooden stool with natural wood grain and a weathered finish, maintaining the same position and pose within the video scene.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The stool was correctly replaced with a rustic wooden one, and the integration is seamless and stable.\nInstruction Compliance: 5\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5"}
{"base": "0083_local_change_Replace_the_sofa_wit", "edited_type": "local_change", "prompt": "Replace the sofa with a classic brown leather sofa with visible stitching, ensuring it maintains the sofa's exact position and pose within the scene.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The sofa was replaced perfectly, matching all instructions. The edit is seamless, stable, and has realistic lighting.\nInstruction Compliance: 5\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5"}
{"base": "0085_local_change_Replace_the_mans_ca", "edited_type": "local_change", "prompt": "Replace the man's casual shirt with a dark navy blue business suit, white shirt, and black tie, maintaining the same pose and position within the scene.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit perfectly replaces the man's shirt with the requested suit. The tracking, lighting, and consistency are excellent.\nInstruction Compliance: 5\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5"}
{"base": "0084_local_change_Replace_the_stone_be", "edited_type": "local_change", "prompt": "Replace the stone bench with a rustic wooden bench made of weathered planks, ensuring it maintains the same position and pose within the video scene.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The stone bench was perfectly replaced with a wooden bench, maintaining correct position, lighting, and interaction.\nInstruction Compliance: 5\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5"}
{"base": "0089_local_change_Replace_the_woman_wi", "edited_type": "local_change", "prompt": "Replace the woman with an elegant senior woman with silver hair and subtle wrinkles, maintaining the same pose and position within the scene.", "scores": [2, 2, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit only changed the woman's hair color, not replacing her with a senior woman as instructed.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2"}
{"base": "0092_local_change_Replace_the_mans_da", "edited_type": "local_change", "prompt": "Replace the man's dark jacket and light shirt with a light blue short-sleeve polo shirt, maintaining the same position and pointing pose within the scene.", "scores": [2, 2, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit is only partial; the jacket sleeve on the pointing arm was not replaced, creating an obvious inconsistency.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2"}
{"base": "0087_local_change_Replace_the_womans", "edited_type": "local_change", "prompt": "Replace the woman's black turtleneck and gray pants with a light, sleeveless summer dress in pastel pink with floral patterns, ensuring the new attire fits her pose and position perfectly within the scene.", "scores": [4, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The dress is a static overlay that doesn't track the woman's subtle body movements or interact correctly with her hands.\nInstruction Compliance: 4\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3"}
{"base": "0095_local_change_Add_a_classic_brown", "edited_type": "local_change", "prompt": "Add a classic brown fedora hat to the boy's head, maintaining the same position and pose within the video scene.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit failed to follow instructions, adding the hat to the woman's head instead of the boy's.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1"}
{"base": "0077_local_change_Change_the_mans_hai", "edited_type": "local_change", "prompt": "Change the man’s hair color to platinum blonde, maintaining the same position and pose within the video scene.", "scores": [4, 4, 4], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The hair color was changed correctly, but the hairstyle was also slightly altered from a buzz cut.\nInstruction Compliance: 4\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 4\nVisual Quality & Stability: 4"}
{"base": "0094_local_change_Replace_the_young_gi", "edited_type": "local_change", "prompt": "Replace the young girl's winter sweater and skirt with a light, sleeveless pastel summer dress, maintaining her seated position and pose within the scene.", "scores": [3, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit replaces the clothing but leaves the original sweater's turtleneck collar, which looks unnatural and incomplete.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3"}
{"base": "0303_local_add_Overlay_an_animated", "edited_type": "local_add", "prompt": "Overlay an animated delicate silver chain necklace with a heart-shaped pendant around the person's neck. The necklace should move naturally with the person's subtle neck movements and have dynamic reflections consistent with lighting changes. All other parts of the video must remain unchanged.", "scores": [3, 2, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The added necklace is not delicate as requested, and it appears to float without casting any shadows.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0082_local_change_Replace_the_green_gr", "edited_type": "local_change", "prompt": "Replace the green grass with wildflower meadow grass containing colorful daisies, poppies, and bluebells, ensuring it maintains the same position and pose within the video scene.", "scores": [5, 1, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The new meadow's lighting is completely unrealistic for the sunset scene, and the colours are too saturated.\nInstruction Compliance: 5\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1"}
{"base": "0086_local_change_Replace_the_mans_ca", "edited_type": "local_change", "prompt": "Replace the man’s cap with a classic brown fedora hat, ensuring it maintains the same position and pose within the scene.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The fedora perfectly replaces the cap, with excellent tracking, lighting, and stability, creating a very realistic edit.\nInstruction Compliance: 5\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5"}
{"base": "0091_local_change_Replace_the_plant_wi", "edited_type": "local_change", "prompt": "Replace the plant with broad green leaves with a lush tropical palm plant, maintaining the same position and pose within the video scene.", "scores": [3, 1, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: Two plants were replaced instead of one, and they are static, not tracking with the camera's motion.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1"}
{"base": "0099_local_change_Add_a_pair_of_stylis", "edited_type": "local_change", "prompt": "Add a pair of stylish black sunglasses with reflective lenses to the girl’s face, maintaining the same position and pose within the video scene.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The sunglasses are added perfectly, tracking her face motion with great stability and realism.\nInstruction Compliance: 5\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5"}
{"base": "0088_local_change_Replace_the_mans_da", "edited_type": "local_change", "prompt": "Replace the man's dark chef coat with a light blue short-sleeve button-up shirt, keeping the same position and pose within the video scene.", "scores": [2, 2, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit is a partial replacement; the body of the coat remains, creating a vest over a shirt.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2"}
{"base": "0093_local_change_Replace_the_metal_ta", "edited_type": "local_change", "prompt": "Replace the metal table with a rustic wooden table, ensuring it maintains the same position and pose within the video scene.", "scores": [5, 4, 4], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The metal table was perfectly replaced with a rustic wooden one, but there's a slight shimmer on the new table's surface.\nInstruction Compliance: 5.\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 4.\nVisual Quality & Stability: 4."}
{"base": "0101_local_change_Add_a_neatly_trimmed", "edited_type": "local_change", "prompt": "Add a neatly trimmed dark beard to the man, ensuring he maintains the same position and pose within the scene.", "scores": [4, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: A dark beard was added, but it does not move naturally with the man's facial expressions.\nInstruction Compliance: 4\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3"}
{"base": "0097_local_change_Replace_the_mans_or", "edited_type": "local_change", "prompt": "Replace the man's orange astronaut suit with a casual summer outfit of a light blue short-sleeve shirt and beige shorts, keeping the same seated pose and position in the video.", "scores": [2, 2, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The astronaut suit was only partially replaced, and the new outfit does not match the requested summer clothes.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2"}
{"base": "0098_local_change_Replace_the_womans", "edited_type": "local_change", "prompt": "Replace the woman's yellow dress with an elegant navy blue evening gown, maintaining the same pose and position within the video scene.", "scores": [4, 4, 4], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The dress was correctly replaced, but a slight yellow remnant is visible on the shoulders.\nInstruction Compliance: 4\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 4\nVisual Quality & Stability: 4"}
{"base": "0096_local_change_Replace_the_woman_in", "edited_type": "local_change", "prompt": "Replace the woman in the denim jacket with an elderly woman with silver hair and gentle wrinkles, ensuring she maintains the same position and pose within the scene.", "scores": [4, 4, 4], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The replacement is correct, but the new woman is static and doesn't match the original's hand gestures.\nInstruction Compliance: 4\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 4\nVisual Quality & Stability: 4"}
{"base": "0100_local_change_Replace_the_mans_li", "edited_type": "local_change", "prompt": "Replace the man's light gray hoodie with a sharp dark navy blue business suit, white shirt, and black tie, maintaining the same position and pose within the scene.", "scores": [2, 2, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The hoodie was not replaced but had a suit jacket added over it, and the requested tie is missing.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2"}
{"base": "0102_local_change_Replace_the_man_with", "edited_type": "local_change", "prompt": "Replace the man with an elderly gentleman with silver hair and gentle wrinkles, maintaining the same position and pose within the video scene.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The replacement is perfect, matching all attributes, motion, and details requested in the prompt seamlessly.\nInstruction Compliance: 5\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5"}
{"base": "0106_local_change_Replace_the_man_with", "edited_type": "local_change", "prompt": "Replace the man with a muscular elderly gentleman with silver hair and gentle wrinkles, ensuring the same position and pose within the scene.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The replacement is perfect, matching all attributes, and maintaining flawless consistency, detail, and visual quality throughout the edit.\nInstruction Compliance: 5\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5"}
{"base": "0108_local_change_Change_the_mans_hai", "edited_type": "local_change", "prompt": "Change the man’s hair color to platinum blonde, ensuring he maintains the same position and pose within the video scene.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The hair color was perfectly changed to platinum blonde. The edit is seamless, stable, and looks completely natural.\nInstruction Compliance: 5\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5"}
{"base": "0103_local_change_Replace_the_green_le", "edited_type": "local_change", "prompt": "Replace the green leafy tree with a cherry tree in full pink blossom, ensuring it maintains the same position and pose within the video scene.", "scores": [5, 2, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The tree was replaced correctly, but the new tree is cartoonish and lacks realistic lighting or shadows.\nInstruction Compliance: 5.\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2.\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2."}
{"base": "0107_local_change_Replace_the_red_Volk", "edited_type": "local_change", "prompt": "Replace the red Volkswagen car with a sleek, futuristic electric sports car in metallic blue, ensuring it maintains the same position and pose within the video scene.", "scores": [2, 2, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The car was replaced with another Volkswagen, not a futuristic sports car. The new car flickers noticeably throughout.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2"}
{"base": "0113_local_change_Add_a_classic_brown", "edited_type": "local_change", "prompt": "Add a classic brown fedora hat to the man, ensuring he maintains the same position and pose within the video scene.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The fedora was added to the table, not the man's head as instructed.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1"}
{"base": "0104_local_change_Replace_the_tree_wit", "edited_type": "local_change", "prompt": "Replace the tree with a golden-leaved tree that shimmers softly, ensuring it maintains the same position and pose within the video scene.", "scores": [4, 2, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The tree replacement is correct but lacks the requested shimmering. The lighting and colour do not match the scene.\nInstruction Compliance: 4\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2"}
{"base": "0105_local_change_Replace_the_mans_wh", "edited_type": "local_change", "prompt": "Replace the man's white dress shirt with a light blue short-sleeve polo shirt, maintaining the same position and pose within the video scene.", "scores": [4, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The shirt style is incorrect (button-down, not polo) and shows minor flicker and instability.\nInstruction Compliance: 4\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3"}
{"base": "0109_local_change_Replace_the_man_with", "edited_type": "local_change", "prompt": "Replace the man with an elderly gentleman with silver hair and wrinkles, keeping the same pose and position within the scene.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The man was perfectly replaced with an elderly gentleman, matching all instructions. The edit is seamless and stable.\nInstruction Compliance: 5\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5"}
{"base": "0110_local_change_Add_a_classic_black", "edited_type": "local_change", "prompt": "Add a classic black fedora hat to the woman's head, ensuring she maintains the same pose and position within the scene.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The fedora is added flawlessly, with perfect tracking and lighting that matches the original scene.\nInstruction Compliance: 5\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5"}
{"base": "0116_local_change_Replace_the_mans_ca", "edited_type": "local_change", "prompt": "Replace the man's casual green t-shirt with a sharp dark navy blue business suit, white shirt, and slim black tie, maintaining the same position and pose within the scene.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The suit replacement is perfect. It flawlessly tracks the man's motion, with consistent lighting and no visible artifacts.\nInstruction Compliance: 5.\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5.\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5."}
{"base": "0114_local_change_Replace_the_black_le", "edited_type": "local_change", "prompt": "Replace the black leather office chair with a modern minimalist office chair with a black mesh backrest and metal frame, ensuring it maintains the chair's exact position and pose within the scene.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The chair replacement is perfect and matches all instructions. Integration is seamless, stable, and visually flawless.\nInstruction Compliance: 5\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5"}
{"base": "0115_local_change_Replace_the_woman_wi", "edited_type": "local_change", "prompt": "Replace the woman with a graceful elderly woman with silver hair and gentle wrinkles, ensuring she maintains the same position and pose within the scene.", "scores": [3, 2, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The elderly woman replacement is good, but hand tracking is poor, with distorted gestures and flickering original hands.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2"}
{"base": "0117_local_change_Replace_the_wooden_t", "edited_type": "local_change", "prompt": "Replace the wooden table with a colorful mosaic table with intricate tile patterns, ensuring it maintains the same position and pose within the video scene.", "scores": [5, 4, 4], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The table was replaced correctly, but the lighting on the new table doesn't fully match the scene.\nInstruction Compliance: 5\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 4\nVisual Quality & Stability: 4"}
{"base": "0120_local_change_Replace_the_wicker_c", "edited_type": "local_change", "prompt": "Replace the wicker chair with a luxurious velvet armchair, ensuring it maintains the same position and pose within the video scene.", "scores": [2, 2, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The wrong chair was replaced. The instruction specified the wicker chair, but the grey chair was edited instead.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2"}
{"base": "0185_local_remove_Remove_the_woman_wit", "edited_type": "local_remove", "prompt": "Remove the woman with long, dark hair elegantly dressed in a vibrant red garment, applying makeup with a brush, from the entire video sequence. The background must be reconstructed with temporal consistency, and all other video content must remain unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The woman was not removed. The edit introduced severe ghosting and transparency artifacts, failing to follow the instruction completely.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0111_local_change_Replace_the_green_mu", "edited_type": "local_change", "prompt": "Replace the green muscle car with a sleek metallic red muscle car, ensuring it maintains the same position and pose within the video scene.", "scores": [3, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The car's color is correct, but the model is wrong (missing stripes, different wheels and hood).\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3"}
{"base": "0112_local_change_Replace_the_tree_wit", "edited_type": "local_change", "prompt": "Replace the tree with a golden autumn tree with vibrant yellow leaves, ensuring it maintains the same position and pose within the video scene.", "scores": [5, 2, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: Correct tree replacement, but the new tree looks fake. It lacks realistic shadows and doesn't match scene lighting.\nInstruction Compliance: 5\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2"}
{"base": "0187_local_remove_Remove_the_man_with", "edited_type": "local_remove", "prompt": "Remove the man with short, dark hair, wearing a light gray t-shirt with a subtle pattern, holding a small round glass in his right hand (left hand slightly raised), with a relaxed posture (shoulders leaning forward), closed eyes (expression of concentration and enjoyment, savoring the beverage), mouth open slightly (taking a sip), and visible facial features (nose, lips) from the entire video sequence. The background must be reconstructed with temporal consistency, and all other video content must remain unchanged.", "scores": [2, 2, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The man was removed, but the bowl he was holding was left floating mid-air.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2"}
{"base": "0118_local_change_Replace_the_billiard", "edited_type": "local_change", "prompt": "Replace the billiard table with a minimalist pool table with black felt surface and matte black metal frame, ensuring it maintains the same position and pose within the scene.", "scores": [4, 4, 4], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The table was correctly replaced, but the frame appears to be dark wood, not matte black metal.\nInstruction Compliance: 4\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 4\nVisual Quality & Stability: 4"}
{"base": "0121_local_change_Replace_the_white_mo", "edited_type": "local_change", "prompt": "Replace the white modern bathtub with a polished white marble bathtub with subtle gray veining, ensuring it maintains the same position and pose within the video scene.", "scores": [4, 4, 4], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit correctly replaced the bathtub with marble, but changed its shape, slightly deviating from the instruction.\nInstruction Compliance: 4\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 4\nVisual Quality & Stability: 4"}
{"base": "0182_local_remove_Remove_the_woman_wit", "edited_type": "local_remove", "prompt": "Remove the woman with long, wavy blonde hair, glasses, a sleeveless black dress cinched at the waist with a vibrant red belt and prominent buckle from the entire video sequence. The background must be reconstructed with temporal consistency to match the original context, and all other video content must remain unchanged.", "scores": [3, 2, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The woman is removed, but the background reconstruction is a blurry, unrealistic, and low-quality patch.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0184_local_remove_Remove_the_vibrant_y", "edited_type": "local_remove", "prompt": "Remove the vibrant yellow race car with MOTOROLA and BBS sponsor logos, glossy finish, spinning front wheel with black alloy rim, decals (cartoon character and number '63'), streamlined body, and competitive race scenario from the entire video. The background must be reconstructed with temporal consistency, and all other video content must remain unchanged.", "scores": [2, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The instruction to remove the car was not followed. Only the front wheel was partially and poorly removed.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0186_local_remove_Remove_the_tall_stu", "edited_type": "local_remove", "prompt": "Remove the tall, sturdy tree with a thick, textured trunk, green leaf canopy, and rustling leaves from the entire video sequence. The background must be reconstructed with temporal consistency, and all other video content must remain unchanged.", "scores": [3, 2, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The correct tree was removed, but the background reconstruction is very blurry, with major ghosting and instability.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2"}
{"base": "0122_local_change_Replace_the_womans", "edited_type": "local_change", "prompt": "Replace the woman’s white plaid shirt with a sleek, elegant black evening dress with silver embroidery, ensuring she maintains the same position and pose within the scene.", "scores": [2, 2, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit added a vest over the shirt instead of replacing it with a dress.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2"}
{"base": "0189_local_remove_Remove_the_person_wi", "edited_type": "local_remove", "prompt": "Remove the person with long, wavy hair wearing a loose-fitting, light-colored shirt from the entire video sequence. The background must be reconstructed with temporal consistency, and all other video content must remain unchanged.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person was perfectly removed. The background reconstruction is seamless and temporally consistent with the slow camera pan.\nInstruction Compliance: 5\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5"}
{"base": "0183_local_remove_Remove_the_shirtless", "edited_type": "local_remove", "prompt": "Remove the shirtless man with a toned physique, dynamic pose (arms extended outward), glistening skin, dark cap, focused/determined expression (slight smile), watch on wrists, rhythmic arm movements, steady posture (body leaning forward) from the entire video sequence. The background must be reconstructed with temporal consistency, and all other video content must remain unchanged.", "scores": [3, 2, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The man is removed, but a prominent ghost of the jump rope remains visible in the sky.\nInstruction Compliance: 3.\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2.\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2."}
{"base": "0190_local_remove_Remove_the_woman_sta", "edited_type": "local_remove", "prompt": "Remove the woman standing gracefully with a relaxed yet attentive posture, dressed in a deep red coat, a long cream-colored scarf, neatly tied back hair, dark blue jeans, sturdy brown ankle boots, holding a small round object (possibly a phone or a small bag) in her right hand, with her left hand casually by her side, gazing slightly to her left, maintaining a steady stance with subtle movements suggesting engagement in a quiet conversation or waiting patiently from the entire video sequence. The background must be reconstructed with temporal consistency, and all other video content must remain unchanged.", "scores": [3, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The woman was removed, but the leash she was holding remains floating in the air.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3"}
{"base": "0119_local_change_Replace_the_mans_bl", "edited_type": "local_change", "prompt": "Replace the man's black long-sleeve shirt with a sharp dark grey business suit jacket, white dress shirt, and red tie, ensuring the new attire fits his pose and position within the scene.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The suit replacement is excellent, perfectly matching all instructions with seamless integration and consistent lighting.\nInstruction Compliance: 5.\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5.\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5."}
{"base": "0188_local_remove_Completely_remove_th", "edited_type": "local_remove", "prompt": "Completely remove the rectangular beige tile wall with a light blue top strip and a small off-center rectangular sign from the entire video. Ensure the background is inpainted with temporal consistency, maintaining all other unchanged video content.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The wall was perfectly removed and replaced with a high-quality, plausible, and temporally stable background.\nInstruction Compliance: 5\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5"}
{"base": "0191_local_remove_Remove_the_person_we", "edited_type": "local_remove", "prompt": "Remove the person wearing a light blue shirt and dark pants from the entire video sequence. The background must be reconstructed with temporal consistency, and all other video content must remain unchanged.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person is flawlessly removed from the entire video. The background reconstruction is perfect, seamless, and stable.\nInstruction Compliance: 5\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5"}
{"base": "0192_local_remove_Remove_the_person_wi", "edited_type": "local_remove", "prompt": "Remove the person with shoulder-length dark hair, wearing glasses and a light gray scarf, seated with a relaxed posture, dressed in a white t-shirt and light blue jeans, with a black crossbody bag on their lap, engaged in conversation (indicated by a slight smile and attentive expression), with hands gesturing subtly (suggesting explanation or listening intently), and a calm, composed demeanor with a slight lean forward from the entire video sequence. The background must be reconstructed with temporal consistency, and all other video content must remain unchanged.", "scores": [3, 2, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The correct person was removed, but her bag was left floating, and the background reconstruction is distorted and unstable.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2"}
{"base": "0193_local_remove_Remove_the_woven_wic", "edited_type": "local_remove", "prompt": "Remove the woven wicker basket with a sturdy, arched handle, delicate white lace trim, and a small decorative bow tied at the front from the entire video sequence. The background must be reconstructed with temporal consistency, and all other video content must remain unchanged.", "scores": [3, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The basket was removed, but an unrequested glass was added, and the reconstructed blanket is blurry.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3"}
{"base": "0195_local_remove_Remove_the_young_boy", "edited_type": "local_remove", "prompt": "Remove the young boy wearing a vibrant red beanie, a colorful jacket adorned with green and yellow circles, standing with a relaxed yet attentive posture, displaying curiosity through a slight head turn, with the hood resting against his back, steady gaze, slightly open mouth, neatly styled hair, and maintaining a consistent stance from the entire video sequence. The background must be reconstructed with temporal consistency, and all other video content must remain unchanged.", "scores": [2, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: Partial removal, leaving a distorted fragment of the backpack strap floating in the frame.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0197_local_remove_Remove_the_man_in_a", "edited_type": "local_remove", "prompt": "Remove the man in a vibrant red chef's jacket (neatly pressed with buttons and pockets), animated hands, shifting facial expressions, upright posture, and gesturing movements from the entire video. The background must be reconstructed with temporal consistency, and all other video content must remain unchanged.", "scores": [3, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The man is removed, but a new white box object is hallucinated on the counter.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0202_local_remove_Completely_remove_t", "edited_type": "local_remove", "prompt": "\"Completely remove the vibrant, neon green text DON'T PANIC!\"\" displayed on the tablet from the entire video, using temporally consistent background inpainting and ensuring all other video content remains unchanged.\"\"\"", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The text was perfectly removed, leaving a clean, blank screen, while flawlessly preserving the original screen reflection.\nInstruction Compliance: 5\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5"}
{"base": "0200_local_remove_Remove_the_metallic", "edited_type": "local_remove", "prompt": "Remove the metallic pipe with a smooth cylindrical form, evenly spaced rivets, muted gray weathered surface, consistent orientation (open end outward), gentle curvature, and solitary presence from the entire video sequence. The background must be reconstructed with temporal consistency, and all other video content must remain unchanged.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The object was removed perfectly. The simple, solid background was reconstructed flawlessly, resulting in a seamless edit.\nInstruction Compliance: 5\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5"}
{"base": "0199_local_remove_Remove_the_man_with", "edited_type": "local_remove", "prompt": "Remove the man with short, neatly combed hair, wearing a light gray sweater with a dark collar, whose hands are animated (initially close to his chest, then one gesturing outward and the other closer), facial expression focused with subtle changes, and upright posture from the entire video. The background must be reconstructed with temporal consistency, and all other video content must remain unchanged.", "scores": [3, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The man was removed, but the background reconstruction is extremely poor with severe artifacts and hallucinated objects.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0201_local_remove_Remove_the_wooden_ta", "edited_type": "local_remove", "prompt": "Remove the wooden table with a smooth, polished surface, subtly visible grain patterns, slight reflectivity catching ambient light, stationary, well-defined edges, robust construction, commanding yet understated presence, central role, timeless design, and versatile functionality from the entire video sequence. The background must be reconstructed with temporal consistency, and all other video content must remain unchanged.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The wooden table was removed flawlessly with a perfect and stable background reconstruction.\nInstruction Compliance: 5.\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5.\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5."}
{"base": "0196_local_remove_Completely_remove_th", "edited_type": "local_remove", "prompt": "Completely remove the sleek, modern car with a vibrant orange body, contrasting white roof, streamlined design, prominent front grille, angular headlights, large robust wheels, low profile, and fluid movement from the entire video. The background must be reconstructed with temporal consistency, and all other video content must remain unchanged.", "scores": [2, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: Wrong objects were removed. The edit introduced severe flickering, ghosting, and poor background reconstruction throughout the video.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0203_local_remove_Remove_the_delicate", "edited_type": "local_remove", "prompt": "Remove the delicate white flower with four broad, slightly ruffled petals, smooth and gently curved, symmetrical and balanced, stationary with a pale yellow central core from the entire video sequence. The background must be reconstructed with temporal consistency, and all other video content must remain unchanged.", "scores": [2, 2, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit is a partial removal, leaving two target flowers untouched. The background reconstruction is poor and jitters.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2"}
{"base": "0198_local_remove_Remove_the_woman_wit", "edited_type": "local_remove", "prompt": "Remove the woman with long, straight blonde hair, wearing a vibrant green sweater and a floral apron, engaged in a warm embrace, with her joyful and affectionate expression (eyes closed, slight smile), turning slightly to the side with relaxed and affectionate posture, gentle and fluid movements (shifting weight from one foot to the other), hands positioned near her chest (gesture of reassurance/affection), and consistent warm and friendly demeanor throughout the entire video sequence. The background must be reconstructed with temporal consistency, and all other video content must remain unchanged.", "scores": [3, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The target person was removed, but her apron and parts of her sweater were left floating unnaturally.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0206_local_remove_Remove_the_young_wom", "edited_type": "local_remove", "prompt": "Remove the young woman with long, dark hair, glasses, and a white long-sleeved top from the entire video sequence. The background must be reconstructed with temporal consistency, and all other video content must remain unchanged.", "scores": [3, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The woman is removed, but the background is heavily distorted, and severe warping artifacts are visible throughout.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0194_local_remove_Completely_remove_th", "edited_type": "local_remove", "prompt": "Completely remove the person dressed in a dark outfit with a light-colored hat, engaged in rhythmic, repetitive motion (walking forward with a steady, deliberate pace, hunched posture, bent elbows, synchronized lower body movement, and purposeful demeanor) from the entire video. The background must be reconstructed with temporal consistency, and all other video content must remain unchanged.", "scores": [3, 2, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person is removed, but replaced with a very obvious blurry and jittery patch.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2"}
{"base": "0209_local_remove_Remove_the_off_road", "edited_type": "local_remove", "prompt": "Remove the off-road vehicle (dune buggy) from the entire video. This includes its robust design, large rugged tires, dark matte body, protective roll bar, red taillights, driver's seat with protective cage, visible suspension system, and shock absorbers. The background must be reconstructed with temporal consistency, ensuring all other video content remains unchanged.", "scores": [2, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The vehicle was removed, but the people and parts of the seats were left floating with severe artifacts.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0211_local_remove_Remove_the_curved_c", "edited_type": "local_remove", "prompt": "Remove the curved, crescent-shaped piano keyboard with alternating black and white keys from the entire video. The background must be reconstructed with temporal consistency, and all other video content must remain unchanged.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The crescent keyboard was removed flawlessly, and the background was perfectly reconstructed with the existing striped pattern.\nInstruction Compliance: 5\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5"}
{"base": "0208_local_remove_Remove_the_seated_pe", "edited_type": "local_remove", "prompt": "Remove the seated person wearing a white jacket over a dark top with neatly tied-back hair from the entire video. The background must be reconstructed with temporal consistency, and all other video content must remain unchanged.", "scores": [4, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The correct person was removed, but the background reconstruction has noticeable blurriness and temporal instability.\nInstruction Compliance: 4\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3"}
{"base": "0215_local_remove_Completely_remove_th", "edited_type": "local_remove", "prompt": "Completely remove the man with short, neatly combed hair and glasses from the entire video sequence. The background must be reconstructed with temporal consistency, and all other video content must remain unchanged.", "scores": [2, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The man was only partially removed. His body remains, but his head is missing, leaving a void.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0207_local_remove_Remove_the_person_wi", "edited_type": "local_remove", "prompt": "Remove the person with long, flowing red hair wearing a light brown, textured coat with a wide collar and tied waist belt from the entire video sequence. The background must be reconstructed with temporal consistency, and all other video content must remain unchanged.", "scores": [3, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person is removed, but significant ghosting appears on the boy's shoulder and hair.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3"}
{"base": "0205_local_remove_Remove_the_man_weari", "edited_type": "local_remove", "prompt": "Remove the man wearing a vibrant red t-shirt with bold black text and a black cap engaged in dynamic conversation, with expressive gestures including pointing and open-handed movements, right hand occasionally gesturing outward, left hand possibly holding an object or gesturing towards it, subtle facial expression shifts indicating engagement, relaxed yet animated posture with slight shoulder and head movements conveying confidence and authority, and overall friendly and approachable demeanor from the entire video sequence. The background must be reconstructed with temporal consistency, and all other video content must remain unchanged.", "scores": [3, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: Correct person removed, but with major ghosting and severe color bleeding that completely distorts the background car.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0204_local_remove_Remove_the_person_st", "edited_type": "local_remove", "prompt": "Remove the person standing with a relaxed posture, wearing a patterned shirt (mix of dark and light tones) and loose-fitting blue jeans, holding an object in their right hand (slightly raised), head turned left, steady stance, and calm demeanor. The background must be reconstructed with temporal consistency, and all other video content must remain unchanged.", "scores": [2, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The wrong person was removed, leaving behind a floating cup and creating severe ghosting and distortion.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0212_local_remove_Remove_the_small_bir", "edited_type": "local_remove", "prompt": "Remove the small bird with glossy black plumage, yellow beak, and fluid movements from the entire video. The background must be reconstructed with temporal consistency, and all other video content must remain unchanged.", "scores": [3, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The bird is removed, but replaced with a static, blurry patch that is visually jarring and inconsistent.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0213_local_remove_Remove_the_young_man", "edited_type": "local_remove", "prompt": "Remove the young man with short, dark hair and glasses from the entire video sequence. He is wearing a black shirt under a plaid shirt with red, white, and blue patterns. His sequence of movements includes speaking/presenting with a slightly open mouth and focused eyes, shifting to a smile with teeth and a friendly demeanor, closing his eyes momentarily, and raising his right hand to make a thumbs-up gesture. The background must be reconstructed with temporal consistency, and all other video content must remain unchanged.", "scores": [3, 2, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The man is removed, but the background is poorly inpainted with obvious smudges and artifacts.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0216_local_remove_Remove_the_woman_wit", "edited_type": "local_remove", "prompt": "Remove the woman with short, neatly styled blonde hair wearing a deep blue blazer over a textured, light blue sweater, with her concerned expression (closed eyes, pursed lips), subtle head movements (tilted to upright), and upright posture (slight lean) from the entire video sequence. The background must be reconstructed with temporal consistency, and all other video content must remain unchanged.", "scores": [2, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The wrong object was also removed, and the background reconstruction is extremely poor and distorted.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0210_local_remove_Remove_the_person_in", "edited_type": "local_remove", "prompt": "Remove the person in a maroon sweater and glasses engaged in focused activity from the entire video sequence. The background must be reconstructed with temporal consistency, and all other video content must remain unchanged.", "scores": [4, 4, 4], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person was removed, but minor artifacts and edge blurring are visible on the remaining person's shoulder.\nInstruction Compliance: 4\nVisual Quality & Stability: 4\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 4"}
{"base": "0217_local_remove_Remove_the_majestic", "edited_type": "local_remove", "prompt": "Remove the majestic white horse adorned with a harness, moving gracefully along a cobblestone path, from the entire video sequence. The background must be reconstructed with temporal consistency, and all other video content must remain unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit was not performed; the horse and carriage are still present in the video.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0221_local_remove_Completely_remove_th", "edited_type": "local_remove", "prompt": "Completely remove the person with long, flowing brown hair tied back in a ponytail from the entire video sequence. The background must be reconstructed with temporal consistency, and all other video content must remain unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The requested person was not removed. The edited video is identical to the original video provided.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0219_local_remove_Completely_remove_a", "edited_type": "local_remove", "prompt": "Completely remove a light blue cowboy hat with a wide, slightly curved brim and a smooth, rounded crown from the entire video, using temporally consistent background inpainting and ensuring all other video content remains unchanged.", "scores": [2, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The hat was only partially removed, remaining in the mirror. The hair reconstruction is severely distorted and static.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0214_local_remove_Remove_the_young_wom", "edited_type": "local_remove", "prompt": "Remove the young woman with long, wavy brown hair and a serene expression from the entire video sequence. She is wearing a textured, off-white knit sweater with wide, ruffled sleeves, gazing upwards with her lips slightly parted and eyes softly closed, her head tilting slightly to the side while maintaining a relaxed posture with shoulders subtly leaning back. The background must be reconstructed with temporal consistency, and all other video content must remain unchanged.", "scores": [3, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The correct person is removed, but a strand of her hair remains floating, and the other person's hand glitches.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3"}
{"base": "0223_local_remove_Remove_the_elegant_o", "edited_type": "local_remove", "prompt": "Remove the elegant orchid with slender stem, delicate pink blossoms (clustered, ruffled petals), vibrant green leaves, and upright position from the entire video sequence. The background must be reconstructed with temporal consistency, and all other video content must remain unchanged.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The orchid was perfectly removed. The background reconstruction is seamless and stable with no visible artifacts or flaws.\nInstruction Compliance: 5\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5"}
{"base": "0218_local_remove_Completely_remove_a", "edited_type": "local_remove", "prompt": "Completely remove a white peaked cap, adorned with a glossy black visor and a gold emblem on the front, from the entire video, using temporally consistent background inpainting and ensuring all other video content remains unchanged.", "scores": [3, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The cap is removed, but the hair and background reconstruction is very poor with severe temporal artifacts.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0222_local_remove_Remove_the_person_we", "edited_type": "local_remove", "prompt": "Remove the person wearing a blue and black striped sports jersey, black shorts, with a well-groomed beard, short hair, and intricate tattoos on both arms from the entire video. The background must be reconstructed with temporal consistency, and all other video content must remain unchanged.", "scores": [4, 4, 4], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: Correct object removed, but very minor flickering artifacts are present in the reconstructed background area.\nInstruction Compliance: 4\nVisual Quality & Stability: 4\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 4"}
{"base": "0220_local_remove_Completely_remove_th", "edited_type": "local_remove", "prompt": "Completely remove the vibrant skateboard with a blue and green wave design, sturdy green wheels, and metallic trucks from the entire video sequence. Ensure the background is reconstructed with temporal consistency, maintaining all other video content unchanged.", "scores": [3, 3, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The skateboard is gone, but the background reconstruction is blurry, discolored, and jitters noticeably throughout the video.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2"}
{"base": "0224_local_remove_Completely_remove_th", "edited_type": "local_remove", "prompt": "Completely remove the woman with long, dark hair seated in a dark blazer over a light shirt, holding a piece of paper and examining it with gentle, deliberate hand movements. The background must be reconstructed with temporal consistency, and all other video content must remain unchanged.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The removal is flawless. The background reconstruction is seamless, and the remaining subjects are perfectly preserved without distortion.\nInstruction Compliance: 5.\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5.\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5."}
{"base": "0228_local_remove_Remove_the_woman_wit", "edited_type": "local_remove", "prompt": "Remove the woman with shoulder-length blonde hair wearing a black blazer over a black top from the entire video sequence. Ensure temporal consistent background inpainting, and leave all other video content unchanged.", "scores": [3, 2, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: Correct object removed, but obvious ghosting artifact is visible where the woman was.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2"}
{"base": "0225_local_remove_Remove_the_lush_gre", "edited_type": "local_remove", "prompt": "Remove the lush, green potted plant with dense foliage, vibrant and healthy broad glossy leaves, and robust, full form from the entire video sequence. The background must be reconstructed with temporal consistency, and all other video content must remain unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: Wrong edit. The video sequence is altered, an extra object is removed, and the plant's reflection remains.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0230_local_remove_Remove_the_young_gir", "edited_type": "local_remove", "prompt": "Remove the young girl with light brown hair styled in a neat bun, wearing a light blue t-shirt adorned with white animal prints, holding a black pen in her right hand while examining it with curiosity, occasionally glancing upwards, left hand slightly raised, seated posture, and subtle movements involving the pen from the entire video sequence. The background must be reconstructed with temporal consistency, and all other video content must remain unchanged.", "scores": [3, 2, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: Correct girl removed, but her pen is left floating and the reconstructed background is static and mismatched.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0227_local_remove_Remove_the_compact_y", "edited_type": "local_remove", "prompt": "Remove the compact yellow taxi with a boxy shape, roof rack, 'FOR HIRE' green lettering, tinted windows, visible interior with a driver, rounded front, elevated rear, stationary (wheels straight), and well-maintained (no dents/scratches) from the entire video. The background must be reconstructed with temporal consistency, and all other video content must remain unchanged.", "scores": [3, 1, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The correct object was removed, but the scooter passing by is severely distorted and partially erased.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2"}
{"base": "0226_local_remove_Remove_the_sleek_da", "edited_type": "local_remove", "prompt": "Remove the sleek, dark gray car with compact, aerodynamic design from the entire video sequence. The background must be reconstructed with temporal consistency, and all other video content must remain unchanged.", "scores": [2, 2, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit incorrectly removed the red car in addition to the specified dark gray car.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2"}
{"base": "0231_local_remove_Remove_the_sleek_wh", "edited_type": "local_remove", "prompt": "Remove the sleek, white electric car (featuring a smooth aerodynamic design, glossy ambient light-reflecting surface, modern contours, streamlined shape, large dark alloy wheels visible in its side profile, tinted windows, subtly integrated door handles, a stationary parked position, and embodying elegance and efficiency of contemporary automotive design) from the entire video sequence. The background must be reconstructed with temporal consistency, and all other video content must remain unchanged.", "scores": [4, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: Correct object removed, but with very faint ghosting. The reconstructed background shimmers slightly.\nInstruction Compliance: 4\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3"}
{"base": "0232_local_remove_Remove_the_man_with", "edited_type": "local_remove", "prompt": "Remove the man with short, neatly styled hair, purple sunglasses, dark-colored sweater over collared shirt, cheerful expression, smiling broadly, occasional mouth opening, subtle gestures (head tilt, right arm raise), and relaxed demeanor from the entire video. The background must be reconstructed with temporal consistency, and all other video content must remain unchanged.", "scores": [5, 4, 4], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The man is perfectly removed. The background reconstruction is very stable, but the inpainted rocks lack the detail of the original.\nInstruction Compliance: 5\nVisual Quality & Stability: 4\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 4"}
{"base": "0229_local_remove_Remove_the_man_with", "edited_type": "local_remove", "prompt": "Remove the man with short, neatly styled hair, dark sunglasses, and a heather gray t-shirt from the entire video sequence. The background must be reconstructed with temporal consistency, and all other video content must remain unchanged.", "scores": [3, 2, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The man is removed, but the woman's shoulder and the background behind the man are severely distorted and blurry.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0233_local_remove_Remove_the_man_with", "edited_type": "local_remove", "prompt": "Remove the man with a beard and glasses wearing a checkered shirt, dark apron, actively cooking with a stand mixer, fluid movements, gesturing, shifting expressions from focused to smiling, holding the mixer firmly, steady posture with slight stance adjustments from the entire video sequence. The background must be reconstructed with temporal consistency, and all other video content must remain unchanged.", "scores": [3, 2, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The man is removed, but the background reconstruction is completely static and an incorrect attachment is added to the mixer.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0385_subtitle_edit_Remove_the_subtitles", "edited_type": "subtitle_edit", "prompt": "Remove the subtitles at the bottom of the video.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The subtitles were successfully removed without any visual artifacts or unintended changes.\nInstruction Compliance: 5.\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5.\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5."}
{"base": "0237_local_remove_Remove_the_white_van", "edited_type": "local_remove", "prompt": "Remove the white van with its compact utilitarian design, roof rack, sleek aerodynamic shape, distinct front grille, tinted windows, steady motion, partially visible wheels, and overall reliable purposeful posture from the entire video sequence. The background must be reconstructed with temporal consistency, and all other video content must remain unchanged.", "scores": [4, 4, 4], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The correct van was removed, but the smoke passing over the reconstructed area appears slightly soft and unnatural.\nInstruction Compliance: 4\nVisual Quality & Stability: 4\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 4"}
{"base": "0381_subtitle_edit_Remove_the_subtitles", "edited_type": "subtitle_edit", "prompt": "Remove the subtitles at the top of the video.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The top subtitles were removed perfectly, with no visual artifacts or unintended changes.\nInstruction Compliance: 5.\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5.\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5."}
{"base": "0240_local_remove_Remove_the_lush_gree", "edited_type": "local_remove", "prompt": "Remove the lush greenery floral display with slender, elongated stems, small, delicate pale green buds tightly clustered at the tips, gracefully arching stems, and subtle swaying movement throughout the sequence from the entire video. The background must be reconstructed with temporal consistency, and all other video content must remain unchanged.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The floral display is removed perfectly. The background is flawlessly reconstructed with excellent detail and temporal stability.\nInstruction Compliance: 5\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5"}
{"base": "0235_local_remove_Remove_the_man_with", "edited_type": "local_remove", "prompt": "Remove the man with short, neatly styled hair, a beard, wearing a black t-shirt with a prominent logo on the front, standing behind a desk with his right arm resting on the surface gesturing slightly as he speaks, left hand placed on the desk with fingers slightly curled, an attentive expression with eyes focused forward, occasionally pointing with his index finger, smooth and deliberate movements, and a calm and confident presence from the entire video sequence. The background must be reconstructed with temporal consistency, and all other video content must remain unchanged.", "scores": [3, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: Man is removed, but the background reconstruction is very poor and flickers. His reflection remains on the case.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0238_local_remove_Remove_the_man_with", "edited_type": "local_remove", "prompt": "Remove the man with short, neatly combed hair, friendly expression, wearing a crisp blue button-up shirt, standing confidently with hands positioned in front of him, mouth open, eyes wide, relaxed yet assertive posture with a slight lean forward, and subtle changing facial expressions and hand gestures from the entire video sequence. The background must be reconstructed with temporal consistency, and all other video content must remain unchanged.", "scores": [3, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The man is removed, but the entire video is extremely blurry, including the text that should have been preserved.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0387_subtitle_edit_Add_But_the_truth_s", "edited_type": "subtitle_edit", "prompt": "\"Add But the truth she’s about to share? It’ll blow your mind.\"\" subtitles at the top of the video with white text without border style.\"\"\"", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The subtitle content is completely wrong and unreadable, failing the core instruction.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0389_subtitle_edit_Replace_the_subtitl", "edited_type": "subtitle_edit", "prompt": "\"Replace the subtitles But wait—those faces are about to come alive. What happens next?\"\" with \"\"Pastel grid of healthcare heroes—smiles, scrubs, and masks: a heartfelt tribute begins.\"\" at the bottom of the video with black text with white border style.\"\"\"", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: No edit was made. The original subtitles were not replaced as instructed.\nInstruction Compliance: 1.\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1.\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1."}
{"base": "0236_local_remove_Remove_the_person_wi", "edited_type": "local_remove", "prompt": "Remove the person with short, curly hair in a dynamic pose (right arm extended upwards with a clenched fist, left arm bent at the elbow on the hip) wearing a dark long-sleeved shirt, from the entire video sequence. The background must be reconstructed with temporal consistency, and all other video content must remain unchanged.", "scores": [2, 2, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The target person was only partially removed and reappears in the middle of the video.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2"}
{"base": "0388_subtitle_edit_Remove_the_subtitles", "edited_type": "subtitle_edit", "prompt": "Remove the subtitles at the bottom of the video.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The subtitles were removed perfectly with seamless inpainting of the area underneath.\nInstruction Compliance: 5.\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5.\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5."}
{"base": "0391_subtitle_edit_Remove_the_subtitles", "edited_type": "subtitle_edit", "prompt": "Remove the subtitles at the bottom of the video.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The subtitles were removed flawlessly with perfect background inpainting and no unintended changes to the video.\nInstruction Compliance: 5.\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5.\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5."}
{"base": "0383_subtitle_edit_Remove_the_subtitles", "edited_type": "subtitle_edit", "prompt": "Remove the subtitles at the bottom of the video.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The subtitles were removed flawlessly with excellent inpainting, leaving no trace of the original text.\nInstruction Compliance: 5.\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5.\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5."}
{"base": "0239_local_remove_Remove_the_small_bir", "edited_type": "local_remove", "prompt": "Remove the small bird with a vibrant orange crown, soft muted gray body, green and blue feather mix with brown hints, short pointed beak, tilting head, alert expressive eyes, slender delicate legs with sharp claws, and poised balanced stance (occasionally shifting weight) from the entire video sequence. The background must be reconstructed with temporal consistency, and all other video content must remain unchanged.", "scores": [3, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The bird is removed, but the banana peel reconstruction is blurry and lacks detail, creating a noticeable patch.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3"}
{"base": "0382_subtitle_edit_Add_This_crisp_gree", "edited_type": "subtitle_edit", "prompt": "\"Add This crisp green could be the star of your next meal—what’s it hiding?\"\" subtitles at the bottom of the video with black text with white border style.\"\"\"", "scores": [2, 2, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The added subtitle text is completely incorrect and does not match the instruction.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2"}
{"base": "0393_subtitle_edit_Replace_the_subtitl", "edited_type": "subtitle_edit", "prompt": "\"Replace the subtitles Live debate floor: Sanders and opponent clash in prime time.\"\" with \"\"What’s he about to say that could shift the debate’s course?\"\" at the top of the video with white text with black border style.\"\"\"", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit failed completely. The original subtitles were not replaced, and another part of the video was corrupted.\nInstruction Compliance: 1.\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1.\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1."}
{"base": "0234_local_remove_Remove_the_person_in", "edited_type": "local_remove", "prompt": "Remove the person in a cream-colored long-sleeved top, light brown pants, with a multicolored scarf around their neck, long dark hair, holding a small object in their right hand, and with a relaxed yet attentive posture (head slightly tilted upwards) from the entire video sequence. The background must be reconstructed with temporal consistency, and all other video content must remain unchanged.", "scores": [4, 4, 4], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The correct person is removed, but minor blurriness is visible on the shoulder of the remaining person.\nInstruction Compliance: 4\nVisual Quality & Stability: 4\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 4"}
{"base": "0390_subtitle_edit_Replace_the_subtitl", "edited_type": "subtitle_edit", "prompt": "\"Replace the subtitles But what he’s about to share could change everything.\"\" with \"\"A warm smile in a quiet clinic—what’s making him light up?\"\" at the center of the video with white text without border style.\"\"\"", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: No edit was performed. The original subtitle remains unchanged, failing to follow any part of the instruction.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0386_subtitle_edit_Replace_the_subtitl", "edited_type": "subtitle_edit", "prompt": "\"Replace the subtitles What secrets lie beyond those emerald cliffs? Keep watching.\"\" with \"\"Dive into a paradise where jagged cliffs meet liquid sapphire.\"\" at the bottom of the video with white text with black border style.\"\"\"", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: No edit was made. The original subtitles remain with visual artifacts.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0392_subtitle_edit_Add_What_secrets_is", "edited_type": "subtitle_edit", "prompt": "\"Add What secrets is this old computer unlocking for him?\"\" subtitles at the bottom of the video with black text with white border style.\"\"\"", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The added subtitle text is completely garbled, unreadable, and incorrect.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0397_subtitle_edit_Replace_the_subtitl", "edited_type": "subtitle_edit", "prompt": "\"Replace the subtitles Eggs mid-fall, green glow framing their splashy entrance\"\" with \"\"What happens when these eggs hit the water—you won’t believe the splash\"\" at the center of the video with white text without border style.\"\"\"", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The subtitle was not replaced as requested; the video remains completely unchanged.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0395_subtitle_edit_Remove_the_subtitles", "edited_type": "subtitle_edit", "prompt": "Remove the subtitles at the bottom of the video.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The subtitles were removed flawlessly, and the background was reconstructed perfectly.\nInstruction Compliance: 5.\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5.\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5."}
{"base": "0396_subtitle_edit_Remove_the_subtitles", "edited_type": "subtitle_edit", "prompt": "Remove the subtitles at the top of the video.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit perfectly removed the subtitles from the top of the video with no visual artifacts.\nInstruction Compliance: 5.\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5.\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5."}
{"base": "0398_subtitle_edit_Remove_the_subtitles", "edited_type": "subtitle_edit", "prompt": "Remove the subtitles at the center of the video.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit perfectly removed the subtitles and restored the background without any visual issues or artifacts.\nInstruction Compliance: 5.\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5.\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5."}
{"base": "0394_subtitle_edit_Remove_the_subtitles", "edited_type": "subtitle_edit", "prompt": "Remove the subtitles at the bottom of the video.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The subtitles were removed flawlessly with no visual degradation or unintended changes.\nInstruction Compliance: 5.\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5.\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5."}
{"base": "0384_subtitle_edit_Add_Tony_Hale_at_th", "edited_type": "subtitle_edit", "prompt": "\"Add Tony Hale at the 'Toy Story 4' premiere—festive tent, movie poster, and a story to share.\"\" subtitles at the center of the video with white text with black border style.\"\"\"", "scores": [2, 2, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: Wrong placement and style. The instruction was to add a subtitle, not replace the existing one with a modified version.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2"}
{"base": "0401_subtitle_edit_Replace_the_subtitl", "edited_type": "subtitle_edit", "prompt": "\"Replace the subtitles What’s locked in these frames could rewrite her story.\"\" with \"\"Her fingers trace fragile film—soft light, a life unspooling.\"\" at the bottom of the video with white text without border style.\"\"\"", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The subtitles were not replaced as instructed. The video is completely unchanged.\nInstruction Compliance: 1.\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1.\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1."}
{"base": "0400_subtitle_edit_Remove_the_subtitles", "edited_type": "subtitle_edit", "prompt": "Remove the subtitles at the top of the video.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The subtitles were completely removed with no visual artifacts, perfectly following the instruction.\nInstruction Compliance: 5.\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5.\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5."}
{"base": "0404_subtitle_edit_Remove_the_subtitles", "edited_type": "subtitle_edit", "prompt": "Remove the subtitles at the center of the video.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The central subtitles were perfectly removed, and the background was flawlessly restored with no artifacts.\nInstruction Compliance: 5.\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5.\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5."}
{"base": "0399_subtitle_edit_Remove_the_subtitles", "edited_type": "subtitle_edit", "prompt": "Remove the subtitles at the center of the video.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The subtitles were removed perfectly, and the background was reconstructed without any visual flaws or artifacts.\nInstruction Compliance: 5.\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5.\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5."}
{"base": "0405_subtitle_edit_Remove_the_subtitles", "edited_type": "subtitle_edit", "prompt": "Remove the subtitles at the top of the video.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The subtitles were removed flawlessly without affecting the video quality.\nInstruction Compliance: 5.\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5.\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5."}
{"base": "0403_subtitle_edit_Remove_the_subtitles", "edited_type": "subtitle_edit", "prompt": "Remove the subtitles at the center of the video.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The subtitles were removed perfectly with no visual artifacts or unintended changes.\nInstruction Compliance: 5.\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5.\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5."}
{"base": "0402_subtitle_edit_Add_That_blue_truck", "edited_type": "subtitle_edit", "prompt": "\"Add That blue truck’s next move? It’s about to rewrite the day’s rhythm\"\" subtitles at the center of the video with white text with black border style.\"\"\"", "scores": [3, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The subtitle text content was incorrectly changed to all capital letters.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3"}
{"base": "0406_subtitle_edit_Replace_the_subtitl", "edited_type": "subtitle_edit", "prompt": "\"Replace the subtitles Industrial chaos meets precision: a crane lifts a truck as workers watch.\"\" with \"\"But will this crane maneuver keep the truck from tipping? You won’t look away.\"\" at the top of the video with white text without border style.\"\"\"", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit failed. The original subtitles were not replaced with the new text as instructed.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0408_subtitle_edit_Replace_the_subtitl", "edited_type": "subtitle_edit", "prompt": "\"Replace the subtitles By the ocean, calm meets strength—this yoga handstand split is pure discipline.\"\" with \"\"What happens when she shifts her weight? This handstand’s about to get intense.\"\" at the center of the video with black text with white border style.\"\"\"", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The model added incorrect text and failed to remove the original subtitles, resulting in overlapping, nonsensical text.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0411_subtitle_edit_Remove_the_subtitles", "edited_type": "subtitle_edit", "prompt": "Remove the subtitles at the top of the video.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The subtitle at the top was completely removed, and the background was perfectly restored with no artifacts.\nInstruction Compliance: 5.\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5.\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5."}
{"base": "0407_subtitle_edit_Remove_the_subtitles", "edited_type": "subtitle_edit", "prompt": "Remove the subtitles at the center of the video.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The subtitles were successfully removed without any visual artifacts or unintended changes to the video.\nInstruction Compliance: 5.\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5.\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5."}
{"base": "0410_subtitle_edit_Remove_the_subtitles", "edited_type": "subtitle_edit", "prompt": "Remove the subtitles at the center of the video.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The subtitles were removed flawlessly, with perfect reconstruction of the background and no unintended video changes.\nInstruction Compliance: 5.\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5.\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5."}
{"base": "0409_subtitle_edit_Add_Two_friends_nav", "edited_type": "subtitle_edit", "prompt": "\"Add Two friends navigate Tokyo’s ramen ritual—one’s first taste of the machine.\"\" subtitles at the center of the video with white text with black border style.\"\"\"", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The requested subtitle was not added to the video. The edit was completely ignored.\nInstruction Compliance: 1.\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1.\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1."}
{"base": "0416_subtitle_edit_Remove_the_subtitles", "edited_type": "subtitle_edit", "prompt": "Remove the subtitles at the bottom of the video.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The subtitles were removed perfectly with no visual artifacts or unintended changes to the video.\nInstruction Compliance: 5.\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5.\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5."}
{"base": "0414_subtitle_edit_Remove_the_subtitles", "edited_type": "subtitle_edit", "prompt": "Remove the subtitles at the bottom of the video.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The subtitles were completely removed with no visual artifacts or other changes to the video.\nInstruction Compliance: 5.\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5.\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5."}
{"base": "0418_subtitle_edit_Remove_the_subtitles", "edited_type": "subtitle_edit", "prompt": "Remove the subtitles at the top of the video.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The subtitles at the top of the video were successfully removed with no visual issues.\nInstruction Compliance: 5.\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5.\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5."}
{"base": "0415_subtitle_edit_Replace_the_subtitl", "edited_type": "subtitle_edit", "prompt": "\"Replace the subtitles These vibrant beaded hoops? You won’t believe why they’re a must-have.\"\" with \"\"Sunlit kitchen, colorful earrings—this is going to be your new favorite accessory story.\"\" at the bottom of the video with white text without border style.\"\"\"", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The subtitles were not replaced as instructed; the original subtitles remain untouched in the edited video.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0413_subtitle_edit_Add_Beneath_a_starl", "edited_type": "subtitle_edit", "prompt": "\"Add Beneath a starless sky, city lights hum a quiet lullaby.\"\" subtitles at the bottom of the video with white text with black border style.\"\"\"", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The subtitle text is completely wrong and unreadable. The sky was also significantly and unintentionally altered.\nInstruction Compliance: 1.\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1.\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1."}
{"base": "0412_subtitle_edit_Remove_the_subtitles", "edited_type": "subtitle_edit", "prompt": "Remove the subtitles at the center of the video.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The subtitles were completely removed with perfect restoration of the background video.\nInstruction Compliance: 5.\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5.\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5."}
{"base": "0422_subtitle_edit_Remove_the_subtitles", "edited_type": "subtitle_edit", "prompt": "Remove the subtitles at the center of the video.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The subtitles were removed perfectly with no visual artifacts or damage to the underlying video.\nInstruction Compliance: 5.\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5.\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5."}
{"base": "0421_subtitle_edit_Add_Whats_he_hidin", "edited_type": "subtitle_edit", "prompt": "\"Add What’s he hiding on that phone? This chopstick challenge just got interesting.\"\" subtitles at the bottom of the video with white text with black border style.\"\"\"", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The added subtitles are completely incorrect and unreadable gibberish, not the requested text.\nInstruction Compliance: 1.\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1.\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1."}
{"base": "0423_subtitle_edit_Add_Hands_glide_ove", "edited_type": "subtitle_edit", "prompt": "\"Add Hands glide over the most precise edge you’ve ever seen—this knife’s about to change how you cut.\"\" subtitles at the bottom of the video with white text without border style.\"\"\"", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The required subtitles are missing from the edited video.\nInstruction Compliance: 1.\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1.\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1."}
{"base": "0429_subtitle_edit_Remove_the_subtitles", "edited_type": "subtitle_edit", "prompt": "Remove the subtitles at the bottom of the video.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The subtitles were removed perfectly, with a seamless reconstruction of the snowy background and no visual artifacts.\nInstruction Compliance: 5.\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5.\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5."}
{"base": "0420_subtitle_edit_Replace_the_subtitl", "edited_type": "subtitle_edit", "prompt": "\"Replace the subtitles Golden light paints a mountain valley alive with yurts and a thousand stories\"\" with \"\"What’s about to unfold under that red flag could change how we see this mountain gathering\"\" at the bottom of the video with black text with white border style.\"\"\"", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edited subtitle text is completely garbled and unreadable, failing the instruction to add the new text.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0419_subtitle_edit_Replace_the_subtitl", "edited_type": "subtitle_edit", "prompt": "\"Replace the subtitles Morning prep starts here—this duffel’s about to hold everything I need.\"\" with \"\"This bag’s about to hold more than just clothes—what’s next?\"\" at the bottom of the video with white text without border style.\"\"\"", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: No edit was performed. The subtitles in the edited video are identical to the original.\nInstruction Compliance: 1.\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1.\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1."}
{"base": "0426_subtitle_edit_Remove_the_subtitles", "edited_type": "subtitle_edit", "prompt": "Remove the subtitles at the bottom of the video.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The subtitles were removed perfectly, with seamless inpainting on the complex reflective surface of the wheel.\nInstruction Compliance: 5.\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5.\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5."}
{"base": "0424_subtitle_edit_Replace_the_subtitl", "edited_type": "subtitle_edit", "prompt": "\"Replace the subtitles Rustic room, pool cues, and a guitarist—tonight’s soundtrack just got interesting.\"\" with \"\"What’s the story behind that guitar’s portrait? You won’t believe it.\"\" at the center of the video with white text without border style.\"\"\"", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The original subtitles were not replaced, and unreadable, corrupted text was added to the video instead.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0428_subtitle_edit_Remove_the_subtitles", "edited_type": "subtitle_edit", "prompt": "Remove the subtitles at the center of the video.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The subtitle was perfectly removed, and the background was seamlessly restored with no visual artifacts or unintended changes.\nInstruction Compliance: 5.\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5.\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5."}
{"base": "0425_subtitle_edit_Add_But_the_truth_h", "edited_type": "subtitle_edit", "prompt": "\"Add But the truth he’s about to share could change everything.\"\" subtitles at the top of the video with white text without border style.\"\"\"", "scores": [2, 2, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The subtitle text is completely incorrect and garbled. Existing on-screen text was also unintentionally altered.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2"}
{"base": "0427_subtitle_edit_Add_Whats_around_t", "edited_type": "subtitle_edit", "prompt": "\"Add What’s around the bend for this steady trek? The path hides more than just the load.\"\" subtitles at the center of the video with white text with black border style.\"\"\"", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The required subtitles were not added to the video. The edit failed completely.\nInstruction Compliance: 1.\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1.\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1."}
{"base": "0417_subtitle_edit_Remove_the_subtitles", "edited_type": "subtitle_edit", "prompt": "Remove the subtitles at the center of the video.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The subtitles were completely removed with no visual artifacts or unintended changes.\nInstruction Compliance: 5.\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5.\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5."}
{"base": "0430_subtitle_edit_Remove_the_subtitles", "edited_type": "subtitle_edit", "prompt": "Remove the subtitles at the center of the video.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_r4_rcfg2_s100", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The subtitles were removed perfectly, and the underlying video was restored flawlessly.\nInstruction Compliance: 5.\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5.\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5."}