{"base": "0025_action_edit_head_up_0d33b390a1ae", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person lift their head so they look upward throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The requested edit is completely absent; the person's head remains down and is not lifted.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0022_action_edit_head_frame_right_177ff5d873e9", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person turn their head toward the right side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The head turn is executed precisely as requested, with excellent visual quality and perfect background/identity preservation.\nInstruction Compliance: 5\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5"}
{"base": "0004_action_edit_head_down_1055ca9ccad3", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person lower their head so they look downward throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The requested action is absent; the person's head is not lowered. Instead, their shirt has been changed.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0008_action_edit_head_frame_right_034111ac375d", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person turn their head toward the right side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The requested head turn is absent. A large, glitchy graphic artifact was added to the person's clothing.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0014_action_edit_head_frame_left_119847119822", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person turn their head toward the left side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The requested head turn is absent. The edit introduced major artifacts and changed the person's clothing and background.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0013_action_edit_head_frame_left_1084c8e86c1a", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person turn their head toward the left side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The requested action is absent. The background was changed, and a new person was added.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0009_action_edit_head_frame_left_04065f34d96f", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person turn their head toward the left side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The requested action is absent; the edited video is identical to the original video.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0024_action_edit_head_up_0a6341570e0c", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person lift their head so they look upward throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The requested action is absent, and the person's identity was changed significantly by removing their hair.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0011_action_edit_head_frame_left_0ad3743cfbaf", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person turn their head toward the left side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [4, 3, 4], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The head turn is correct, but the neck and jawline have some anatomical and temporal instability.\nInstruction Compliance: 4\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 4"}
{"base": "0032_action_edit_look_camera_0052970d786d", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person look straight toward the camera throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit failed. The person is still looking down at the book, not at the camera.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0001_action_edit_look_camera_0d16e8528f95", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person look straight toward the camera throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit is absent. The person's gaze remains unchanged from the original video and is not directed at the camera.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0005_action_edit_head_down_115cb198c043", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person lower their head so they look downward throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The requested action is completely absent. The person's shirt has been heavily changed and is full of artifacts.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0006_action_edit_head_up_1a96c9091406", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person lift their head so they look upward throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [4, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The head is lifted upward as requested, but the hands have noticeable red artifacts at the start.\nInstruction Compliance: 4\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3"}
{"base": "0029_action_edit_head_up_1385ae7fac3f", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person lift their head so they look upward throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [4, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The head is lifted as requested, but the person's face is smoothed and her colorful t-shirt is changed.\nInstruction Compliance: 4\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3"}
{"base": "0031_action_edit_head_up_18d2f13d0098", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person lift their head so they look upward throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person's head is lifted, but they are now wearing a shirt, which is a major inconsistency.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0019_action_edit_head_frame_right_0f5b22373feb", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person turn their head toward the right side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [2, 2, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit turned the head to the left, which is the opposite of the requested rightward turn.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2"}
{"base": "0027_action_edit_head_up_0eeee8dafdc6", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person lift their head so they look upward throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The requested head lift and upward gaze are executed perfectly, with excellent visual quality and detail preservation.\nInstruction Compliance: 5.\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5.\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5."}
{"base": "0012_action_edit_head_frame_right_0d594c4cfb35", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person turn their head toward the right side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The head turn is executed precisely and consistently, maintaining high visual quality and preserving all unrelated details.\nInstruction Compliance: 5.\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5.\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5."}
{"base": "0023_action_edit_head_frame_right_17877eab5a0a", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person turn their head toward the right side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The requested head turn to the right was executed precisely and realistically, with no noticeable artifacts or inconsistencies.\nInstruction Compliance: 5.\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5.\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5."}
{"base": "0020_action_edit_head_frame_right_1127ee45ec76", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person turn their head toward the right side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The head turn is executed perfectly with excellent visual quality and preservation of all other details.\nInstruction Compliance: 5\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5"}
{"base": "0018_action_edit_head_frame_right_0a2218e3f398", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person turn their head toward the right side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [3, 2, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The head turns in the correct direction but the motion is unnatural, distorted, and starts late.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3"}
{"base": "0003_action_edit_head_down_100d02e34f72", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person lower their head so they look downward throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person's clothing was completely changed, which violates the instruction to preserve all details.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0007_action_edit_head_down_1b1a4a971bb0", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person lower their head so they look downward throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The requested action was not performed. Instead, the woman's clothing color was changed and a microphone was added.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0017_action_edit_head_frame_right_093b6f365b5b", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person turn their head toward the right side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [3, 2, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The head turn is present but looks unnatural and pasted on. The clothing, especially the red shirt collar, is significantly warped and distorted.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3"}
{"base": "0000_action_edit_head_down_0cf30423295e", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person lower their head so they look downward throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [4, 4, 4], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit correctly lowers the person's head, but the degree of the change is very subtle.\nInstruction Compliance: 4\nVisual Quality & Stability: 4\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 4"}
{"base": "0026_action_edit_head_up_0e0a77b5f133", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person lift their head so they look upward throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [5, 4, 4], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person correctly looks upward, but there are minor collar artifacts and an added watermark.\nInstruction Compliance: 5\nVisual Quality & Stability: 4\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 4"}
{"base": "0021_action_edit_head_frame_right_172bceee5b3a", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person turn their head toward the right side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [3, 2, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The head turn is correct, but the original hand gesture is removed, and the new hand is severely distorted.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2"}
{"base": "0015_action_edit_head_frame_right_1a0448d8cd25", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person turn their head toward the right side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The requested head turn is absent. The edit removes the original action and introduces severe artifacts and distortions.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0016_action_edit_head_frame_right_0032e5e72cb1", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person turn their head toward the right side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [2, 2, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The head turns to the left instead of the right, and the person's pants are changed.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2"}
{"base": "0002_action_edit_head_down_0d8707596b81", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person lower their head so they look downward throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [4, 3, 4], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit correctly lowers the person's head, but there are visible artifacts and flicker in the hair.\nInstruction Compliance: 4\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 4"}
{"base": "0028_action_edit_head_up_1064dc19fff8", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person lift their head so they look upward throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [2, 2, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: No more than 20 words.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2"}
{"base": "0036_action_edit_head_frame_left_0d158e01edf9", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person turn their head toward the left side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [2, 2, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The head turn is barely noticeable and the text on the shirt is completely destroyed.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0043_action_edit_raise_arm_frame_left_0f85ee9de48c", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person raise the arm on the left side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: A disembodied arm is added instead of making the person raise their own arm, completely failing the instruction.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0050_action_edit_wave_frame_left_071350aa51e4", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person wave with the hand on the left side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit adds a new, distorted person instead of making the original person wave. The result is heavily artifacted.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0046_action_edit_raise_arm_frame_left_1944a3a7470d", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person raise the arm on the left side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit adds a disembodied arm instead of making the subject raise their own arm.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0045_action_edit_raise_arm_frame_left_178d6162bd29", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person raise the arm on the left side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The requested action of raising the arm is completely absent from the edited video.\nInstruction Compliance: 1.\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1.\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1."}
{"base": "0039_action_edit_look_camera_191c12f933a4", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person look straight toward the camera throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The requested action is absent. The edit instead changes the background, which violates the instructions.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0034_action_edit_look_camera_0625ac18e1b6", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person look straight toward the camera throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit failed to change the person's gaze and introduced severe artifacts and a new person.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0037_action_edit_look_camera_114e468f001e", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person look straight toward the camera throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person's clothing is completely changed and distorted, and there are severe artifacts and anatomical breakage throughout the video.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0042_action_edit_raise_arm_frame_right_0db838f844c5", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person raise the arm on the right side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The requested arm raise was not performed. Instead, the man's clothing was changed, violating the instructions.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0049_action_edit_raise_arm_frame_left_067e5d236374", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person raise the arm on the left side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [5, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The requested action was performed, but a shoe changed color and artifacts appeared on the pants.\nInstruction Compliance: 5\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3"}
{"base": "0056_action_edit_wave_frame_left_00466d64ca3e", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person wave with the hand on the left side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: A new person was added to wave instead of editing the target person, a major unintended change.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0048_action_edit_raise_arm_frame_left_0497e2b4145a", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person raise the arm on the left side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [2, 2, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit moves the wrong arm and significantly changes the person's clothing, adding stripes to the sleeves.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2"}
{"base": "0041_action_edit_raise_arm_frame_left_04b2943d67a1", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person raise the arm on the left side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The requested action is absent. Instead of raising an arm, the edit adds tattoos to both arms.\nInstruction Compliance: 1.\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1.\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1."}
{"base": "0053_action_edit_raise_arm_frame_right_0febc77e3a9d", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person raise the arm on the right side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit adds a disembodied arm instead of making the subject raise his own arm.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0054_action_edit_raise_arm_frame_right_1010539f0a95", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person raise the arm on the right side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The requested action is absent; the person does not raise their arm. The shirt is changed instead.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0033_action_edit_head_frame_left_034770a8e6fe", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person turn their head toward the left side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [4, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: Head turn is correct, but the shirt is changed with flickering stripes and the face quality is reduced.\nInstruction Compliance: 4.\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3.\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3."}
{"base": "0059_action_edit_wave_frame_left_096f6159cd97", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person wave with the hand on the left side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [4, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The waving action is correct, but the motion is unnatural. The person's shirt collar is also incorrectly changed.\nInstruction Compliance: 4\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3"}
{"base": "0058_action_edit_wave_frame_left_068f0315ca58", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person wave with the hand on the left side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [2, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The wrong hand waves, and the person's identity is completely changed, with severe facial distortion and artifacts.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0038_action_edit_head_frame_left_16d08abf3396", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person turn their head toward the left side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [4, 4, 4], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The head is turned correctly to the left as requested. The result is clean, stable, and preserves all details.\nInstruction Compliance: 4\nVisual Quality & Stability: 4\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 4"}
{"base": "0061_action_edit_wave_frame_left_0b0e436a0e95", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person wave with the hand on the left side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person does not wave. Instead, an unrelated edit changes the person's clothing, violating the prompt.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0044_action_edit_raise_arm_frame_left_15886f124e22", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person raise the arm on the left side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [3, 2, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The requested arm raise is attempted, but the hand is anatomically broken and the motion is unnatural.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3"}
{"base": "0047_action_edit_raise_arm_frame_left_1a1177d9475d", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person raise the arm on the left side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [4, 2, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The arm is raised as requested, but the hand is distorted and the camera viewpoint is unstable.\nInstruction Compliance: 4\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3"}
{"base": "0052_action_edit_raise_arm_frame_right_07b52ae1ffc4", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person raise the arm on the right side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The arm is not raised as requested, and the person's clothing has been completely changed.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0035_action_edit_head_frame_left_07de975f3007", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person turn their head toward the left side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [3, 2, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: Head turn is recognizable, but the camera viewpoint changes, and there are severe hand artifacts and clothing changes.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2"}
{"base": "0051_action_edit_raise_arm_frame_right_07954cc366d9", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person raise the arm on the right side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit does the opposite of the instruction, keeping the specified arm down instead of raising it.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0057_action_edit_wave_frame_left_06211f6c311e", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person wave with the hand on the left side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [3, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person waves as requested, but the motion is unnatural. The person's shirt was changed from short-sleeved to long-sleeved.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3"}
{"base": "0060_action_edit_wave_frame_left_0a638a0fa4c2", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person wave with the hand on the left side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [4, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The waving motion is stiff and unnatural. A ring was also incorrectly added to the waving hand.\nInstruction Compliance: 4\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3"}
{"base": "0055_action_edit_raise_arm_frame_right_18d9db51c9f1", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person raise the arm on the right side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: No more than 20 words.\nThe requested action is absent. Instead, the person's shirt is changed and a flickering logo is added.\n\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0063_action_edit_wave_frame_left_18b32f44729e", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person wave with the hand on the left side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit replaced a statue with a person, which is a complete failure to preserve identity.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0040_action_edit_raise_arm_frame_left_0044903aabc0", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person raise the arm on the left side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit fails to raise the arm, creating a corrupted, flickering video with severe ghosting artifacts.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0062_action_edit_wave_frame_left_116e360eb43e", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person wave with the hand on the left side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The requested action is absent. An unrelated edit added a microphone to the person's shirt.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0010_action_edit_head_frame_left_0797be525a94", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person turn their head toward the left side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [3, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The head turn is correct, but the person's shirt color was changed from purple to white.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3"}
{"base": "0065_action_edit_wave_frame_right_05cf41a39bfc", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person wave with the hand on the right side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The requested waving action is completely absent. A new person was added to the scene instead.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0095_action_edit_raise_arm_frame_left_1b4128fbb37c", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person raise the arm on the left side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit fails by adding a new person instead of editing the pose of the person already present.\nInstruction Compliance: 1.\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1.\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1."}
{"base": "0066_action_edit_wave_frame_right_07050ea0388c", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person wave with the hand on the right side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The waving instruction was not followed. Clothing was changed and severe artifacts, including a distorted face, were introduced.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0067_action_edit_wave_frame_right_08393458eb1a", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person wave with the hand on the right side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The requested waving action is absent. The logo on the person's shirt has also been changed.\nInstruction Compliance: 1.\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1.\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1."}
{"base": "0068_action_edit_wave_frame_right_0d8e25092240", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person wave with the hand on the right side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit adds a disembodied arm instead of making the subject wave and has severe visual artifacts.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0074_expression_edit_angry_06d9f5ea0e7c", "edited_type": "expression_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person look angry throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The angry expression is unmistakable and consistent. Visual quality is photographic, and all details are perfectly preserved.\nInstruction Compliance: 5.\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5.\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5."}
{"base": "0079_expression_edit_angry_185d9a51234b", "edited_type": "expression_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person look angry throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person's expression is unchanged and their clothing has been completely altered.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0070_action_edit_wave_frame_left_16331b90251c", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person wave with the hand on the left side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person does not wave as requested. The hand gesture is different, and the clothing is also changed.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0078_expression_edit_angry_1636ec390eed", "edited_type": "expression_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person look angry throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: No more than 20 words.\nThe edit completely fails to add the requested angry emotion, retaining the original sad/pensive expression.\n\nInstruction Compliance: 1.\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1.\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1."}
{"base": "0075_expression_edit_angry_08e8a07d55d0", "edited_type": "expression_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person look angry throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The expression is unchanged, and the person's shirt color and pattern are completely different.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0113_action_edit_raise_arm_frame_left_0774fa368ee9", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person raise the arm on the left side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The requested action is absent. The person's clothing has been completely and incorrectly changed from white to black.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0077_expression_edit_angry_0de19f734f7c", "edited_type": "expression_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person look angry throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [2, 2, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The requested emotion, anger, is not present. The man's expression is only very subtly altered to look slightly concerned.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2"}
{"base": "0069_action_edit_wave_frame_right_11761e832c8d", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person wave with the hand on the right side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [3, 2, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person's shirt is completely changed, and the waving hand is distorted and unnatural.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0072_expression_edit_angry_0341da498a14", "edited_type": "expression_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person look angry throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [5, 3, 4], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit successfully applies a convincing angry expression, but the face has a slightly artificial, smoothed-over quality.\nInstruction Compliance: 5\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 4"}
{"base": "0076_expression_edit_angry_0980a16f720f", "edited_type": "expression_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person look angry throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [4, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The angry expression is recognizable but subtle. The face has minor artifacts, and the overall video framing has changed.\nInstruction Compliance: 4\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3"}
{"base": "0109_action_edit_raise_arm_frame_left_19ec60f452ba", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person raise the arm on the left side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [2, 2, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The requested action is weakly attempted. The edit introduces significant visual distortion on the person's body and removes original shadows.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2"}
{"base": "0080_expression_edit_cry_0392ce0d40eb", "edited_type": "expression_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person cry, with tears on their face throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person is not crying, and the background has been completely and poorly changed, with heavy flickering artifacts.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0092_expression_edit_smile_0b18d450f6ca", "edited_type": "expression_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person smile gently throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit failed to add a smile, and the person's clothing has been changed significantly.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0083_expression_edit_cry_0845f5ef095b", "edited_type": "expression_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person cry, with tears on their face throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person is not crying, and both her identity and clothing have been changed.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0091_expression_edit_smile_09698bf43925", "edited_type": "expression_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person smile gently throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: No smile was added, and the edit changed the person's identity, face shape, and clothing completely.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0085_expression_edit_cry_10c1fb67101b", "edited_type": "expression_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person cry, with tears on their face throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [3, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The emotion reads as sadness, but the instruction for tears was not followed. There is some visual flicker.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3"}
{"base": "0081_expression_edit_cry_048a44bab317", "edited_type": "expression_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person cry, with tears on their face throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [2, 2, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: No tears are visible, the expression is unstable, the face is distorted, and the apron is removed.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2"}
{"base": "0088_expression_edit_frown_06f875df9575", "edited_type": "expression_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person frown throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: No frown was added, and the person's clothing was heavily changed and distorted throughout the video.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0090_expression_edit_frown_082663dcb429", "edited_type": "expression_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person frown throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit successfully adds a convincing, stable frown while perfectly preserving all other aspects of the video.\nInstruction Compliance: 5\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5"}
{"base": "0064_action_edit_wave_frame_right_04d5cf13eace", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person wave with the hand on the right side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [2, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person holds a static pose instead of waving. Clothing and background are completely changed.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0086_expression_edit_cry_10f9e05201b6", "edited_type": "expression_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person cry, with tears on their face throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: No change in expression. The video quality is very poor with heavy flickering and the clothing is completely changed.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0094_expression_edit_frown_18dd340dd757", "edited_type": "expression_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person frown throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person's clothing is completely changed, and the requested frown expression is not present.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0087_expression_edit_cry_1325e9f9c93c", "edited_type": "expression_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person cry, with tears on their face throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit failed to make the person cry. The video is heavily distorted, and the person's clothing is changed.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0089_expression_edit_smile_0749608a5f9a", "edited_type": "expression_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person smile gently throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [3, 2, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The smile is present but looks unnatural and forced, not gentle. There is noticeable facial distortion and warping.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3"}
{"base": "0082_expression_edit_cry_04c71bc29175", "edited_type": "expression_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person cry, with tears on their face throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: No more than 20 words.\nThe edit shows smiling instead of crying and completely changes the logo on the person's T-shirt.\n\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0084_expression_edit_cry_09290df9868e", "edited_type": "expression_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person cry, with tears on their face throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit fails to show crying, distorts the face, and incorrectly adds a pattern to the pants.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0073_expression_edit_angry_0658648b5b7e", "edited_type": "expression_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person look angry throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit failed to preserve clothing, hair, camera motion, and head pose.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0096_expression_edit_sad_0545aa72d39a", "edited_type": "expression_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person look sad throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit perfectly changes the expression to sad while keeping high visual quality and preserving all details.\nInstruction Compliance: 5\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5"}
{"base": "0103_expression_edit_sad_1935d6e653f6", "edited_type": "expression_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person look sad throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [4, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The requested sad expression is present, but the logo on the man's shirt has been unintentionally changed.\nInstruction Compliance: 4\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3"}
{"base": "0099_expression_edit_sad_0b711d0d9659", "edited_type": "expression_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person look sad throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit failed to create a sad expression and added a large, distracting artifact on the arm.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0100_expression_edit_smile_0eb25abbd0d5", "edited_type": "expression_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person smile gently throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The gentle smile is perfectly applied and held steadily. The visual quality and overall consistency are flawless.\nInstruction Compliance: 5\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5"}
{"base": "0098_expression_edit_smile_0a060fe12b72", "edited_type": "expression_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person smile gently throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The gentle smile is stable, coherent, and looks natural. The edit perfectly preserves identity and background details.\nInstruction Compliance: 5\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5"}
{"base": "0108_expression_edit_frown_182645bb1556", "edited_type": "expression_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person frown throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit failed. The person's expression was not changed to a frown as requested.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0104_expression_edit_frown_03abb719c987", "edited_type": "expression_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person frown throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit successfully adds a stable frown while perfectly preserving the person's identity and all other details.\nInstruction Compliance: 5\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5"}
{"base": "0107_expression_edit_smile_166cc3790337", "edited_type": "expression_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person smile gently throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person's expression is completely unchanged, and their clothing has been altered, violating the instructions.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0101_expression_edit_sad_10571acea60a", "edited_type": "expression_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person look sad throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit perfectly adds a stable, convincing sad expression while preserving identity, background, and all other details.\nInstruction Compliance: 5\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5"}
{"base": "0116_expression_edit_surprised_0ad079f2555d", "edited_type": "expression_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person look surprised throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The video is completely unchanged. The person's expression was not edited to look surprised as requested.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0102_expression_edit_sad_14482e8286dd", "edited_type": "expression_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person look sad throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The sad expression is unmistakable and stable. The edit is clean, with no artifacts or unwanted changes.\nInstruction Compliance: 5\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5"}
{"base": "0114_expression_edit_surprised_091c984af220", "edited_type": "expression_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person look surprised throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [4, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The surprised expression is recognizable, but there are artifacts and unintended changes to hair and shirt color.\nInstruction Compliance: 4\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3"}
{"base": "0097_expression_edit_sad_057ba6a74164", "edited_type": "expression_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person look sad throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [3, 3, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: No more than 20 words.\nThe expression reads as neutral, not sad, and a child has been digitally removed from the background.\n\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2"}
{"base": "0119_expression_edit_surprised_107cb478b3e5", "edited_type": "expression_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person look surprised throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: No more than 20 words.\nThe edit completely failed. The person's expression is unchanged from the original video; she does not look surprised.\n\nInstruction Compliance: 1.\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1.\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1."}
{"base": "0121_motion_edit_crouch_02116ab5c9b9", "edited_type": "motion_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person crouch down throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person does not crouch. Their clothing and possibly identity have been changed instead of the requested movement.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0110_expression_edit_smile_1a9d1eaa59fc", "edited_type": "expression_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person smile gently throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: No smile was added. The person's expression is either unchanged or slightly distorted, but not smiling gently.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0122_motion_edit_crouch_026ea1cf56ad", "edited_type": "motion_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person crouch down throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person does not crouch at all, and their clothing has been completely changed.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0115_expression_edit_surprised_0a4500173cbf", "edited_type": "expression_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person look surprised throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [4, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The surprise expression is present but mild. A pocket square has been added to the jacket.\nInstruction Compliance: 4\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3"}
{"base": "0117_expression_edit_surprised_0c80274522bd", "edited_type": "expression_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person look surprised throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: No more than 20 words.\nThe expression is unchanged, and the person's clothing has been completely altered.\n\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0118_expression_edit_surprised_0cde96657c66", "edited_type": "expression_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person look surprised throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit fails to change the expression and completely changes the person's clothing.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0127_motion_edit_crouch_130b665db298", "edited_type": "motion_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person crouch down throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person does not crouch down as requested and remains standing throughout the video.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0124_motion_edit_crouch_06bc29ad02f7", "edited_type": "motion_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person crouch down throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person does not crouch. Her identity and clothing are completely changed, and her body melts during movement.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0105_expression_edit_frown_046318652f39", "edited_type": "expression_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person frown throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [2, 2, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The requested frown is not present; instead, the face is distorted into an unstable, pained grimace.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2"}
{"base": "0126_motion_edit_crouch_129742cb593d", "edited_type": "motion_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person crouch down throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The video is unchanged. The person does not crouch down or perform any other movement.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0120_motion_edit_crouch_004bd93cc1d5", "edited_type": "motion_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person crouch down throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person does not crouch. Instead, their clothing is completely changed.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0125_motion_edit_crouch_0ab167eb6e77", "edited_type": "motion_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person crouch down throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person does not crouch at all, and their clothing is completely changed. The video also jitters.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0123_motion_edit_crouch_0656c3080549", "edited_type": "motion_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person crouch down throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person does not crouch. Identity and clothing are also changed, completely failing the instruction.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0131_motion_edit_jump_0bdd41c5399c", "edited_type": "motion_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person jump up off the ground throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person does not jump at all. The instruction was completely ignored and no movement was added.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0129_motion_edit_jump_0af84eb2cc47", "edited_type": "motion_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person jump up off the ground throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person does not jump, but rather bobs slightly with heavy distortion and jitter throughout the clip.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0128_motion_edit_jump_0acb3427c057", "edited_type": "motion_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person jump up off the ground throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person does not jump at all. The edit removes the original motion and changes the person's clothing.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0130_motion_edit_jump_0b659566f37c", "edited_type": "motion_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person jump up off the ground throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [5, 3, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The jump is good, but her face and the background distort and warp significantly with the movement.\nInstruction Compliance: 5\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2"}
{"base": "0134_motion_edit_jump_19e081372347", "edited_type": "motion_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person jump up off the ground throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person does not jump. The background and clothing are completely changed and visually corrupted.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0136_motion_edit_sit_down_0409027ceeb8", "edited_type": "motion_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person sit down throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person does not sit down. His head is distorted and his identity is not well-preserved.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0139_motion_edit_sit_down_0ad7d0a16136", "edited_type": "motion_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person sit down throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person does not sit down. The instruction was completely ignored and the person remains standing.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0133_motion_edit_jump_0d3c0d999587", "edited_type": "motion_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person jump up off the ground throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person does not jump. The person and background are completely replaced, failing to preserve identity and scene.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0144_motion_edit_stand_up_0321840edcc6", "edited_type": "motion_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person stand up throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person does not stand up; they remain seated throughout the video, failing the instruction.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0137_motion_edit_sit_down_04668227b2cc", "edited_type": "motion_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person sit down throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person does not sit down as requested; the edit failed to execute the instruction.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0146_motion_edit_stand_up_07c1271ef2a7", "edited_type": "motion_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person stand up throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The instruction to make the person stand up was not followed at all.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0138_motion_edit_sit_down_06e1469563ba", "edited_type": "motion_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person sit down throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person does not sit down. Her clothing and the background have also been changed.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0112_expression_edit_surprised_0534d6ca6b11", "edited_type": "expression_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person look surprised throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person's shirt has been completely changed, which violates the instruction to preserve clothing and identity.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0140_motion_edit_sit_down_0b3680008411", "edited_type": "motion_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person sit down throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person does not sit down as requested; they remain standing throughout the video.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0143_motion_edit_sit_down_148adb1880ea", "edited_type": "motion_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person sit down throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person does not sit down and their clothes are completely changed, with significant visual artifacts.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0132_motion_edit_jump_0cd2036c6956", "edited_type": "motion_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person jump up off the ground throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person does not jump. Instead, her skirt is incorrectly changed to jeans, failing the instruction completely.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0147_motion_edit_stand_up_0833d24d6719", "edited_type": "motion_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person stand up throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person does not stand up; they remain in the same crouching position. Their shirt also changes color.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0148_motion_edit_stand_up_1379cde8e7fd", "edited_type": "motion_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person stand up throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person does not stand up; she remains seated, and her clothing is changed from jeans to shorts.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0145_motion_edit_stand_up_04981ae10dcf", "edited_type": "motion_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person stand up throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person does not move; he remains seated in the car. The instruction was not followed.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0135_motion_edit_jump_1a1fa799b982", "edited_type": "motion_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person jump up off the ground throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person does not jump as requested. Their clothing is also completely changed in the edited video.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0154_motion_edit_turn_away_086bce5203ef", "edited_type": "motion_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person turn around to face away from the camera throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The instruction was completely ignored. The person does not move, let alone turn around.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0151_motion_edit_stand_up_15cf20219a72", "edited_type": "motion_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person stand up throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person does not stand up. Their hat is also removed and their shirt is changed.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0153_motion_edit_turn_away_03711900432c", "edited_type": "motion_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person turn around to face away from the camera throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: No movement was performed at all; the instruction to turn around was completely ignored.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0142_motion_edit_sit_down_13618f106e92", "edited_type": "motion_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person sit down throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person does not sit down, her clothing changes, and her lower body is a distorted mess.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0149_motion_edit_stand_up_13d3e4c001a5", "edited_type": "motion_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person stand up throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person was replaced with someone else and did not stand up, failing the instruction completely.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0155_motion_edit_turn_away_0c03f4e28fd0", "edited_type": "motion_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person turn around to face away from the camera throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person does not move at all, completely failing to follow the instruction to turn around.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0152_motion_edit_turn_away_020c1e67ecb9", "edited_type": "motion_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person turn around to face away from the camera throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person does not turn around as requested. The video remains almost identical to the original.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0157_motion_edit_turn_away_1110a56d3512", "edited_type": "motion_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person turn around to face away from the camera throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person does not turn around. The instruction was not followed at all.\nInstruction Compliance: 1.\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1.\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1."}
{"base": "0150_motion_edit_stand_up_15c084acac26", "edited_type": "motion_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person stand up throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person does not stand up. The clothing, identity and microphone have been noticeably altered.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0156_motion_edit_turn_away_100c052b1c51", "edited_type": "motion_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person turn around to face away from the camera throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person does not turn around. The shirt has also been changed completely.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0158_motion_edit_turn_away_136240ee4acd", "edited_type": "motion_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person turn around to face away from the camera throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person does not turn around at all; the instruction was completely ignored.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0162_motion_edit_turn_to_camera_1634d6bf0bab", "edited_type": "motion_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person turn around to face the camera throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person does not turn around. Instead, their clothing is changed, violating the instruction to preserve it.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0141_motion_edit_sit_down_109e73249c2d", "edited_type": "motion_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person sit down throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person is already sitting, not performing the action. The body is severely distorted with impossible leg proportions.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0159_motion_edit_turn_away_1a0bd5760e84", "edited_type": "motion_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person turn around to face away from the camera throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person does not turn around. The instruction was not followed at all.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0161_motion_edit_turn_to_camera_14863dbcb200", "edited_type": "motion_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person turn around to face the camera throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [3, 2, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_lucy_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person turns, but their identity and clothing are completely changed, and their face is distorted.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}