{"base": "0020_action_edit_head_frame_right_1127ee45ec76", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person turn their head toward the right side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person's head is correctly turned to the right, and the edit is clean and consistent.\nInstruction Compliance: 5.\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5.\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5."}
{"base": "0000_action_edit_head_down_0cf30423295e", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person lower their head so they look downward throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit successfully lowers the person's head as requested. The result is high quality, stable, and preserves all other details.\nInstruction Compliance: 5.\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5.\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5."}
{"base": "0021_action_edit_head_frame_right_172bceee5b3a", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person turn their head toward the right side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The requested head turn is completely absent; the edited video is identical to the original.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0024_action_edit_head_up_0a6341570e0c", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person lift their head so they look upward throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The head is lifted upward as requested, with high visual quality and perfect preservation of details.\nInstruction Compliance: 5\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5"}
{"base": "0004_action_edit_head_down_1055ca9ccad3", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person lower their head so they look downward throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person's head is correctly lowered with excellent visual quality. Identity, background, and other details are perfectly preserved.\nInstruction Compliance: 5\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5"}
{"base": "0006_action_edit_head_up_1a96c9091406", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person lift their head so they look upward throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edited video is identical to the original; the requested action is completely absent.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0026_action_edit_head_up_0e0a77b5f133", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person lift their head so they look upward throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [3, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The head lifts progressively instead of maintaining a consistent upward pose as requested.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3"}
{"base": "0019_action_edit_head_frame_right_0f5b22373feb", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person turn their head toward the right side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [3, 2, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The head turn only occurs at the very start before snapping back to the original position.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3"}
{"base": "0016_action_edit_head_frame_right_0032e5e72cb1", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person turn their head toward the right side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit perfectly turns the person's head to the right with excellent visual quality and perfect background preservation.\nInstruction Compliance: 5.\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5.\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5."}
{"base": "0029_action_edit_head_up_1385ae7fac3f", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person lift their head so they look upward throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [5, 4, 4], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit correctly makes the person look upward, with good visual quality and high consistency in details.\nInstruction Compliance: 5\nVisual Quality & Stability: 4\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 4"}
{"base": "0005_action_edit_head_down_115cb198c043", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person lower their head so they look downward throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [3, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person only looks down briefly, not throughout the video as requested, and the motion has some artifacts.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3"}
{"base": "0027_action_edit_head_up_0eeee8dafdc6", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person lift their head so they look upward throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The requested head lift and upward gaze are executed perfectly, with excellent visual quality and detail preservation.\nInstruction Compliance: 5.\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5.\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5."}
{"base": "0011_action_edit_head_frame_left_0ad3743cfbaf", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person turn their head toward the left side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [5, 5, 4], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The head turn is executed perfectly. The result is visually flawless and stable. However, the person's subtle motion and necklace are not preserved.\nInstruction Compliance: 5\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 4"}
{"base": "0007_action_edit_head_down_1b1a4a971bb0", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person lower their head so they look downward throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [3, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The head is lowered as requested, but the original talking motion is completely removed, resulting in an unnaturally static pose.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3"}
{"base": "0010_action_edit_head_frame_left_0797be525a94", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person turn their head toward the left side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [4, 2, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The head turn is correct, but the face is distorted, and the original sunglasses are missing.\nInstruction Compliance: 4\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3"}
{"base": "0022_action_edit_head_frame_right_177ff5d873e9", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person turn their head toward the right side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person's head does not turn. Instead, the eyes are edited unnaturally.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0028_action_edit_head_up_1064dc19fff8", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person lift their head so they look upward throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [3, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit adds an unrequested open mouth and has severe facial distortion, artifacts, and identity change.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0017_action_edit_head_frame_right_093b6f365b5b", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person turn their head toward the right side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [3, 2, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit turns the head to the left, not the right. The video quality is very poor with artifacts.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2"}
{"base": "0009_action_edit_head_frame_left_04065f34d96f", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person turn their head toward the left side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [5, 4, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The requested head turn is executed precisely and smoothly, while perfectly preserving the background and subject's identity.\nInstruction Compliance: 5\nVisual Quality & Stability: 4\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5"}
{"base": "0023_action_edit_head_frame_right_17877eab5a0a", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person turn their head toward the right side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [3, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The head turn is correct, but the original talking motion is lost, and the new head is completely static.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3"}
{"base": "0012_action_edit_head_frame_right_0d594c4cfb35", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person turn their head toward the right side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The head is turned to the right as requested. The video is clean, stable, and preserves all details perfectly.\nInstruction Compliance: 5\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5"}
{"base": "0015_action_edit_head_frame_right_1a0448d8cd25", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person turn their head toward the right side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [5, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The head turn is executed correctly, but the fork in the man's hand is severely distorted.\nInstruction Compliance: 5\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3"}
{"base": "0013_action_edit_head_frame_left_1084c8e86c1a", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person turn their head toward the left side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [4, 2, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The requested action is correct, but the new head is very artificial, poorly rendered, and lacks realism.\nInstruction Compliance: 4\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2"}
{"base": "0002_action_edit_head_down_0d8707596b81", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person lower their head so they look downward throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [5, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person's head is correctly lowered, but the video has a noticeable loss of texture and detail.\nInstruction Compliance: 5\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3"}
{"base": "0014_action_edit_head_frame_left_119847119822", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person turn their head toward the left side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [3, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The head is turned left as requested but snaps back at the end, breaking the \"throughout\" instruction.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3"}
{"base": "0008_action_edit_head_frame_right_034111ac375d", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person turn their head toward the right side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [3, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit successfully turns the head but fails to preserve the original head motion, resulting in a static pose.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3"}
{"base": "0025_action_edit_head_up_0d33b390a1ae", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person lift their head so they look upward throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [5, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: Action is correct but visually unnatural. The original writing motion is lost, and lighting is slightly changed.\nInstruction Compliance: 5\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3"}
{"base": "0001_action_edit_look_camera_0d16e8528f95", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person look straight toward the camera throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [2, 2, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit fails to preserve the person's identity and adds glasses. The new face looks unnatural and distorted.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0032_action_edit_look_camera_0052970d786d", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person look straight toward the camera throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [4, 3, 4], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit correctly changes the gaze, but the head is unnaturally frozen and the face quality is degraded.\nInstruction Compliance: 4\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 4"}
{"base": "0018_action_edit_head_frame_right_0a2218e3f398", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person turn their head toward the right side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [3, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The head turns right but doesn't stay there, and there are minor visual artifacts.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3"}
{"base": "0031_action_edit_head_up_18d2f13d0098", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person lift their head so they look upward throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [3, 2, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The head lift is exaggerated to an extreme degree, causing significant, unnatural distortion to the person's face and neck.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2"}
{"base": "0003_action_edit_head_down_100d02e34f72", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person lower their head so they look downward throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [4, 4, 4], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person's head is lowered as requested, but the resulting pose looks somewhat static and unnatural.\nInstruction Compliance: 4\nVisual Quality & Stability: 4\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 4"}
{"base": "0034_action_edit_look_camera_0625ac18e1b6", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person look straight toward the camera throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit completely failed to change the person's gaze. The video quality is extremely poor and details are lost.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0033_action_edit_head_frame_left_034770a8e6fe", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person turn their head toward the left side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [4, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The head turn is executed correctly, but the side of the face has noticeable artifacts and blur.\nInstruction Compliance: 4\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3"}
{"base": "0040_action_edit_raise_arm_frame_left_0044903aabc0", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person raise the arm on the left side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The video is unchanged. The requested action of raising the arm is completely absent.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0041_action_edit_raise_arm_frame_left_04b2943d67a1", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person raise the arm on the left side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The requested edit to raise the person's left arm was not performed at all.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0036_action_edit_head_frame_left_0d158e01edf9", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person turn their head toward the left side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [4, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The head turn is correct, but the motion is static and unnatural. There are significant artifacts on the hands.\nInstruction Compliance: 4\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3"}
{"base": "0042_action_edit_raise_arm_frame_right_0db838f844c5", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person raise the arm on the right side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The requested action is absent. The video is identical to the original, with no attempt to raise the arm.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0051_action_edit_raise_arm_frame_right_07954cc366d9", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person raise the arm on the right side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The requested action is absent; the edited video is identical to the original, with no changes made.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0052_action_edit_raise_arm_frame_right_07b52ae1ffc4", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person raise the arm on the right side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The requested action is completely absent. The person's arm pose is unchanged from the original video.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0035_action_edit_head_frame_left_07de975f3007", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person turn their head toward the left side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [3, 2, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The head is turned left as requested, but the anatomy is severely distorted, especially the neck.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3"}
{"base": "0046_action_edit_raise_arm_frame_left_1944a3a7470d", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person raise the arm on the left side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The requested action is absent. The person's arm is not raised in the edited video.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0037_action_edit_look_camera_114e468f001e", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person look straight toward the camera throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [2, 2, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit weakly attempts the gaze change, but the person still doesn't look at the camera, and the face is distorted.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2"}
{"base": "0055_action_edit_raise_arm_frame_right_18d9db51c9f1", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person raise the arm on the right side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The requested action is absent. The man does not raise his arm in the edited video.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0059_action_edit_wave_frame_left_096f6159cd97", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person wave with the hand on the left side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edited video is identical to the original; the requested waving action is completely absent.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0045_action_edit_raise_arm_frame_left_178d6162bd29", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person raise the arm on the left side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [4, 3, 4], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The arm is raised as requested, but the hand has anatomical flaws and temporal instability.\nInstruction Compliance: 4\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 4"}
{"base": "0050_action_edit_wave_frame_left_071350aa51e4", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person wave with the hand on the left side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [3, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit adds a static hand gesture instead of the requested waving motion, which looks unnatural.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3"}
{"base": "0047_action_edit_raise_arm_frame_left_1a1177d9475d", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person raise the arm on the left side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [2, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The wrong arm was raised, and the edit is a static, distorted image with severe visual artifacts.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0039_action_edit_look_camera_191c12f933a4", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person look straight toward the camera throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [3, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person looks at the camera initially but then looks away, failing the 'throughout the video' instruction.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3"}
{"base": "0054_action_edit_raise_arm_frame_right_1010539f0a95", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person raise the arm on the right side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit adds a static third arm instead of raising the existing one, resulting in severe anatomical errors.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0053_action_edit_raise_arm_frame_right_0febc77e3a9d", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person raise the arm on the right side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [4, 3, 4], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The requested arm is raised, but the motion is slightly unnatural and creates minor visual artifacts.\nInstruction Compliance: 4\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 4"}
{"base": "0043_action_edit_raise_arm_frame_left_0f85ee9de48c", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person raise the arm on the left side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [4, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The requested action is executed, but the person's shirt is visibly distorted and warped where the arm was moved.\nInstruction Compliance: 4\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3"}
{"base": "0058_action_edit_wave_frame_left_068f0315ca58", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person wave with the hand on the left side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [3, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The wave is attempted but incomplete. The video has severe facial distortion, artifacts, and a completely changed background style.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0044_action_edit_raise_arm_frame_left_15886f124e22", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person raise the arm on the left side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [4, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The correct arm is raised, but the video has some facial distortion and minor consistency issues.\nInstruction Compliance: 4\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3"}
{"base": "0038_action_edit_head_frame_left_16d08abf3396", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person turn their head toward the left side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [5, 4, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The head turn is executed accurately and consistently. The result is visually clean with excellent background preservation.\nInstruction Compliance: 5\nVisual Quality & Stability: 4\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5"}
{"base": "0061_action_edit_wave_frame_left_0b0e436a0e95", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person wave with the hand on the left side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The requested waving action is absent. The video is completely unchanged from the original.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0049_action_edit_raise_arm_frame_left_067e5d236374", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person raise the arm on the left side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [3, 2, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The requested arm motion is subtle. The video quality is poor, with blurriness and distorted hands. Lighting is changed.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2"}
{"base": "0060_action_edit_wave_frame_left_0a638a0fa4c2", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person wave with the hand on the left side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [2, 2, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit targets the wrong hand and creates a static pose instead of a waving motion. The face color is also altered.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2"}
{"base": "0048_action_edit_raise_arm_frame_left_0497e2b4145a", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person raise the arm on the left side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit perfectly executes the instruction, raising the correct arm with excellent visual quality and consistency.\nInstruction Compliance: 5\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5"}
{"base": "0057_action_edit_wave_frame_left_06211f6c311e", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person wave with the hand on the left side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [2, 2, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: A disembodied hand was added instead of making the person wave with their own hand.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2"}
{"base": "0062_action_edit_wave_frame_left_116e360eb43e", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person wave with the hand on the left side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [3, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The hand is static, not waving. There are noticeable artifacts on the arm and shirt.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3"}
{"base": "0056_action_edit_wave_frame_left_00466d64ca3e", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person wave with the hand on the left side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [4, 3, 4], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The requested waving action is present, but the hand looks unnatural and the motion is very stiff.\nInstruction Compliance: 4\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 4"}
{"base": "0065_action_edit_wave_frame_right_05cf41a39bfc", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person wave with the hand on the right side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [4, 3, 4], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The requested wave is present, but the motion is unnatural and the hand has some visual artifacts.\nInstruction Compliance: 4\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 4"}
{"base": "0064_action_edit_wave_frame_right_04d5cf13eace", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person wave with the hand on the right side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [3, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person raises the correct hand, but it is a static pose, not a wave. The background is also noticeably changed.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3"}
{"base": "0063_action_edit_wave_frame_left_18b32f44729e", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person wave with the hand on the left side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [3, 2, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit raises the statue's hand into a static pose but fails to create the waving motion.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3"}
{"base": "0068_action_edit_wave_frame_right_0d8e25092240", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person wave with the hand on the right side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The requested waving action is completely absent. The edit failed to implement the instruction at all.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0113_action_edit_raise_arm_frame_left_0774fa368ee9", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person raise the arm on the left side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The requested action is completely absent; the video is an identical copy of the original.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0069_action_edit_wave_frame_right_11761e832c8d", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person wave with the hand on the right side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The requested waving action is completely absent from the edited video. The camera viewpoint is also slightly altered.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0072_expression_edit_angry_0341da498a14", "edited_type": "expression_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person look angry throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The video is completely unchanged. The person's expression was not altered to look angry as instructed.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0066_action_edit_wave_frame_right_07050ea0388c", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person wave with the hand on the right side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [3, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The waving motion is recognizable but unnatural and inconsistent. The hand has minor visual artifacts and anatomical issues.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3"}
{"base": "0095_action_edit_raise_arm_frame_left_1b4128fbb37c", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person raise the arm on the left side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The requested action is completely absent; the person's arm is not raised in the edited video.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0067_action_edit_wave_frame_right_08393458eb1a", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person wave with the hand on the right side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [2, 2, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The waving action is very brief, not \"throughout the video\". The new hand is heavily distorted and the original hand is not removed.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2"}
{"base": "0070_action_edit_wave_frame_left_16331b90251c", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person wave with the hand on the left side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [3, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit creates a static raised hand instead of a waving motion, and the hand's movement is jittery.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3"}
{"base": "0073_expression_edit_angry_0658648b5b7e", "edited_type": "expression_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person look angry throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The angry expression is clear and stable. The edit is photorealistic and perfectly preserves identity, pose, and background.\nInstruction Compliance: 5\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5"}
{"base": "0075_expression_edit_angry_08e8a07d55d0", "edited_type": "expression_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person look angry throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [4, 2, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The angry expression is present, but the video has poor visual quality with facial distortion and artifacts.\nInstruction Compliance: 4\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3"}
{"base": "0078_expression_edit_angry_1636ec390eed", "edited_type": "expression_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person look angry throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [3, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The angry expression is only present for the first half of the video, reverting to the original expression.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3"}
{"base": "0086_expression_edit_cry_10f9e05201b6", "edited_type": "expression_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person cry, with tears on their face throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The instruction to make the person cry was not followed. The facial expression is unchanged from the original.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0074_expression_edit_angry_06d9f5ea0e7c", "edited_type": "expression_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person look angry throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [4, 2, 4], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The requested angry expression is present, but there is significant visual distortion around the mouth and teeth.\nInstruction Compliance: 4\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 4"}
{"base": "0085_expression_edit_cry_10c1fb67101b", "edited_type": "expression_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person cry, with tears on their face throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [5, 3, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The crying expression is convincing, but the tears look artificial and painted on. All other details are preserved.\nInstruction Compliance: 5.\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3.\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5."}
{"base": "0080_expression_edit_cry_0392ce0d40eb", "edited_type": "expression_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person cry, with tears on their face throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [5, 4, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The crying expression is clear and stable, and identity and background are perfectly preserved.\nInstruction Compliance: 5\nVisual Quality & Stability: 4\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5"}
{"base": "0109_action_edit_raise_arm_frame_left_19ec60f452ba", "edited_type": "action_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person raise the arm on the left side of the frame throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [4, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The correct arm is raised, but its anatomy is distorted and the selfie stick has been removed.\nInstruction Compliance: 4\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3"}
{"base": "0090_expression_edit_frown_082663dcb429", "edited_type": "expression_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person frown throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [3, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The requested frown is extremely subtle and under-played. The face has a soft, wobbly quality with minor changes to the jawline.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3"}
{"base": "0084_expression_edit_cry_09290df9868e", "edited_type": "expression_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person cry, with tears on their face throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [5, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The crying expression is clear, but the face has visible artifacts and a slight identity shift.\nInstruction Compliance: 5\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3"}
{"base": "0079_expression_edit_angry_185d9a51234b", "edited_type": "expression_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person look angry throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [4, 3, 4], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The requested angry expression is subtle but present. The face has minor stability issues and a loss of detail.\nInstruction Compliance: 4\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 4"}
{"base": "0091_expression_edit_smile_09698bf43925", "edited_type": "expression_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person smile gently throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The gentle smile is perfect, and all other details are preserved with excellent visual quality.\nInstruction Compliance: 5\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5"}
{"base": "0081_expression_edit_cry_048a44bab317", "edited_type": "expression_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person cry, with tears on their face throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [3, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: No more than 20 words.\nThe crying expression is present, but the requested tears are missing. The face looks slightly unnatural.\n\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3"}
{"base": "0092_expression_edit_smile_0b18d450f6ca", "edited_type": "expression_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person smile gently throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The facial expression is completely unchanged from the original video; the instruction was not followed.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0083_expression_edit_cry_0845f5ef095b", "edited_type": "expression_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person cry, with tears on their face throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: No more than 20 words.\nThe instruction was not followed. The person is not crying, and the entire video is heavily distorted and unstable.\n\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0096_expression_edit_sad_0545aa72d39a", "edited_type": "expression_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person look sad throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit failed completely; the person's expression was not changed to sad as requested.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0077_expression_edit_angry_0de19f734f7c", "edited_type": "expression_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person look angry throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [3, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The requested emotion is barely recognizable and under-played, visible only as a slight brow furrow.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3"}
{"base": "0076_expression_edit_angry_0980a16f720f", "edited_type": "expression_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person look angry throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [3, 2, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The angry expression is only visible for a moment at the start, not throughout the video as requested.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3"}
{"base": "0087_expression_edit_cry_1325e9f9c93c", "edited_type": "expression_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person cry, with tears on their face throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [2, 2, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: No more than 20 words.\nTears are added, but the underlying expression does not change to crying. The tears are visually artificial.\n\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2"}
{"base": "0098_expression_edit_smile_0a060fe12b72", "edited_type": "expression_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person smile gently throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The video is completely unchanged; the requested gentle smile has not been added.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0094_expression_edit_frown_18dd340dd757", "edited_type": "expression_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person frown throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [5, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The requested frown is clear and consistent, but the face has some minor artifacts and shape changes.\nInstruction Compliance: 5\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3"}
{"base": "0100_expression_edit_smile_0eb25abbd0d5", "edited_type": "expression_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person smile gently throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The gentle smile is natural and stable. All other details are perfectly preserved with photographic quality.\nInstruction Compliance: 5\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5"}
{"base": "0101_expression_edit_sad_10571acea60a", "edited_type": "expression_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person look sad throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The sad expression is convincing and stable, with all other details perfectly preserved.\nInstruction Compliance: 5\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5"}
{"base": "0103_expression_edit_sad_1935d6e653f6", "edited_type": "expression_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person look sad throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit successfully and convincingly applies a sad expression while perfectly preserving all other aspects of the video.\nInstruction Compliance: 5.\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5.\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5."}
{"base": "0107_expression_edit_smile_166cc3790337", "edited_type": "expression_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person smile gently throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The video is completely unchanged. The instruction to make the person smile was not followed at all.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0102_expression_edit_sad_14482e8286dd", "edited_type": "expression_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person look sad throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [4, 3, 4], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The sad expression is recognizable but looks slightly soft and has minor frame-to-frame instability.\nInstruction Compliance: 4\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 4"}
{"base": "0110_expression_edit_smile_1a9d1eaa59fc", "edited_type": "expression_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person smile gently throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person's expression is completely unchanged. No smile was added to the face.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0088_expression_edit_frown_06f875df9575", "edited_type": "expression_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person frown throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [2, 2, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The requested frown is only present for the first moment before reverting to the original positive expression.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2"}
{"base": "0104_expression_edit_frown_03abb719c987", "edited_type": "expression_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person frown throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [5, 3, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit successfully adds a clear and consistent frown, but the visual quality is slightly soft and unnatural.\nInstruction Compliance: 5\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5"}
{"base": "0099_expression_edit_sad_0b711d0d9659", "edited_type": "expression_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person look sad throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [3, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The sad expression is present at the start but is not held for the entire clip.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3"}
{"base": "0097_expression_edit_sad_057ba6a74164", "edited_type": "expression_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person look sad throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The requested sad emotion is not present; the facial expression is almost entirely unchanged from the original video.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0082_expression_edit_cry_04c71bc29175", "edited_type": "expression_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person cry, with tears on their face throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [3, 2, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The crying emotion is inconsistent and unstable, with very artificial-looking tears that disappear during the clip.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3"}
{"base": "0089_expression_edit_smile_0749608a5f9a", "edited_type": "expression_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person smile gently throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [2, 2, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit removes the person's heavy makeup, a major failure to preserve their original identity and look.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2"}
{"base": "0114_expression_edit_surprised_091c984af220", "edited_type": "expression_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person look surprised throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit perfectly applies a surprised expression, maintaining high visual quality and preserving all original details.\nInstruction Compliance: 5\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5"}
{"base": "0115_expression_edit_surprised_0a4500173cbf", "edited_type": "expression_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person look surprised throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [3, 2, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The surprised expression is attempted, but looks unnatural and unstable, especially around the distorted mouth.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3"}
{"base": "0108_expression_edit_frown_182645bb1556", "edited_type": "expression_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person frown throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: No more than 20 words.\nThe instruction to make the person frown was not followed; the original expression is almost entirely unchanged.\n\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0118_expression_edit_surprised_0cde96657c66", "edited_type": "expression_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person look surprised throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The surprised expression is clear and stable. The edit is photorealistic and preserves all other details perfectly.\nInstruction Compliance: 5\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5"}
{"base": "0122_motion_edit_crouch_026ea1cf56ad", "edited_type": "motion_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person crouch down throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit failed. The person does not crouch down; the video is unchanged from the original.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0112_expression_edit_surprised_0534d6ca6b11", "edited_type": "expression_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person look surprised throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [3, 2, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The expression is a weak, under-played surprise. The face is distorted, unstable, and looks unnatural and pasted on.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3"}
{"base": "0105_expression_edit_frown_046318652f39", "edited_type": "expression_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person frown throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [3, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The requested frown is present at the start but disappears halfway, reverting to the original smile.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3"}
{"base": "0116_expression_edit_surprised_0ad079f2555d", "edited_type": "expression_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person look surprised throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [5, 4, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The surprised expression is perfect and stable. All other details of the original video are preserved.\nInstruction Compliance: 5\nVisual Quality & Stability: 4\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5"}
{"base": "0119_expression_edit_surprised_107cb478b3e5", "edited_type": "expression_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person look surprised throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The surprised expression is perfectly executed and stable. All other details like identity, background, and motion are preserved flawlessly.\nInstruction Compliance: 5\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5"}
{"base": "0124_motion_edit_crouch_06bc29ad02f7", "edited_type": "motion_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person crouch down throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: No edit was performed. The person does not crouch and the original video is returned unchanged.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0123_motion_edit_crouch_0656c3080549", "edited_type": "motion_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person crouch down throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [3, 2, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person crouches, but the movement is exaggerated and causes the body to melt and distort severely.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3"}
{"base": "0120_motion_edit_crouch_004bd93cc1d5", "edited_type": "motion_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person crouch down throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [2, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: No more than 20 words.\nAn attempt is made to crouch, but the video is unusable due to severe duplication and melting artifacts.\n\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0125_motion_edit_crouch_0ab167eb6e77", "edited_type": "motion_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person crouch down throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [5, 5, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person successfully crouches throughout the video while maintaining perfect consistency with the original scene and quality.\nInstruction Compliance: 5\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5"}
{"base": "0128_motion_edit_jump_0acb3427c057", "edited_type": "motion_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person jump up off the ground throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person does not jump at all; the instruction was completely ignored.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0117_expression_edit_surprised_0c80274522bd", "edited_type": "expression_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person look surprised throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [3, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The requested surprised expression is very subtle and under-played. There are also noticeable wobble artifacts on the face.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3"}
{"base": "0130_motion_edit_jump_0b659566f37c", "edited_type": "motion_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person jump up off the ground throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [3, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person levitates statically instead of performing a jump. Her feet are very distorted and her robe is unnaturally cropped.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3"}
{"base": "0121_motion_edit_crouch_02116ab5c9b9", "edited_type": "motion_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person crouch down throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [5, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person is correctly shown in a crouched pose, but the pose has some distortion and object interaction has changed.\nInstruction Compliance: 5\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3"}
{"base": "0135_motion_edit_jump_1a1fa799b982", "edited_type": "motion_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person jump up off the ground throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person does not move. The edit failed to make the person jump as requested.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0129_motion_edit_jump_0af84eb2cc47", "edited_type": "motion_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person jump up off the ground throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [2, 2, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person just bobs vertically instead of jumping. The edit is very jittery with heavy distortion on the head.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2"}
{"base": "0131_motion_edit_jump_0bdd41c5399c", "edited_type": "motion_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person jump up off the ground throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The video is completely unchanged. The person does not jump, so the instruction was not followed at all.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0132_motion_edit_jump_0cd2036c6956", "edited_type": "motion_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person jump up off the ground throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person does not jump or perform any movement; she remains stationary.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0126_motion_edit_crouch_129742cb593d", "edited_type": "motion_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person crouch down throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [2, 2, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person is crouching, but their lower body and the background are completely and poorly reconstructed.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0134_motion_edit_jump_19e081372347", "edited_type": "motion_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person jump up off the ground throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [4, 3, 4], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The girl jumps as requested, but her legs and feet are very distorted and rubbery during the motion.\nInstruction Compliance: 4\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 4"}
{"base": "0133_motion_edit_jump_0d3c0d999587", "edited_type": "motion_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person jump up off the ground throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [2, 2, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The jump is a momentary, glitchy leg lift at the start, not a plausible jump throughout the video.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2"}
{"base": "0138_motion_edit_sit_down_06e1469563ba", "edited_type": "motion_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person sit down throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [5, 4, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person is plausibly sitting down, and the scene is perfectly preserved with only minor visual artifacts.\nInstruction Compliance: 5\nVisual Quality & Stability: 4\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5"}
{"base": "0147_motion_edit_stand_up_0833d24d6719", "edited_type": "motion_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person stand up throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person does not stand up. The edit is completely unchanged from the original video.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0145_motion_edit_stand_up_04981ae10dcf", "edited_type": "motion_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person stand up throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person does not stand up; his shorts are changed to pants instead of the requested movement.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0143_motion_edit_sit_down_148adb1880ea", "edited_type": "motion_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person sit down throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [3, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person is made to sit, but the movement is not shown, and the seated pose is distorted.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3"}
{"base": "0150_motion_edit_stand_up_15c084acac26", "edited_type": "motion_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person stand up throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [1, 1, 1], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person does not stand up; he remains seated. The camera framing is also cropped.\nInstruction Compliance: 1\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 1"}
{"base": "0127_motion_edit_crouch_130b665db298", "edited_type": "motion_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person crouch down throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [2, 1, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person is put in a crouch, not shown crouching. The video is extremely distorted and jittery.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2"}
{"base": "0139_motion_edit_sit_down_0ad7d0a16136", "edited_type": "motion_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person sit down throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [2, 2, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person is changed to a static seated pose, not performing the movement of sitting down. Background objects change.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2"}
{"base": "0137_motion_edit_sit_down_04668227b2cc", "edited_type": "motion_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person sit down throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [3, 3, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person is seated as requested, but is completely static, and her identity is not preserved.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2"}
{"base": "0142_motion_edit_sit_down_13618f106e92", "edited_type": "motion_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person sit down throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [4, 2, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person sits as requested, but her legs are distorted and the background and dog have been altered.\nInstruction Compliance: 4\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3"}
{"base": "0144_motion_edit_stand_up_0321840edcc6", "edited_type": "motion_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person stand up throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [3, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person is now standing, but the action of standing up is missing. The chair is distorted.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3"}
{"base": "0152_motion_edit_turn_away_020c1e67ecb9", "edited_type": "motion_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person turn around to face away from the camera throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [3, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person is turned away but the edit does not show the movement of turning, just a static pose change.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3"}
{"base": "0153_motion_edit_turn_away_03711900432c", "edited_type": "motion_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person turn around to face away from the camera throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [3, 2, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person faces away as requested, but then turns back towards the camera, breaking the instruction. Her identity changes.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2"}
{"base": "0149_motion_edit_stand_up_13d3e4c001a5", "edited_type": "motion_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person stand up throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [5, 5, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person is now plausibly standing, but their pants have changed from dark grey to blue jeans.\nInstruction Compliance: 5\nVisual Quality & Stability: 5\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3"}
{"base": "0151_motion_edit_stand_up_15cf20219a72", "edited_type": "motion_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person stand up throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [2, 1, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person does not stand up. He sits more upright, but his entire lower body is replaced.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 1\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2"}
{"base": "0156_motion_edit_turn_away_100c052b1c51", "edited_type": "motion_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person turn around to face away from the camera throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [2, 2, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person turns towards the camera, not away. Identity changes noticeably during the jittery turn.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2"}
{"base": "0141_motion_edit_sit_down_109e73249c2d", "edited_type": "motion_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person sit down throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [4, 4, 4], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person crouches instead of sitting, which is a minor error. The edit is visually stable with good consistency.\nInstruction Compliance: 4\nVisual Quality & Stability: 4\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 4"}
{"base": "0157_motion_edit_turn_away_1110a56d3512", "edited_type": "motion_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person turn around to face away from the camera throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [3, 2, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person turns towards the camera, not away, and doesn't remain facing away. The turn itself is very distorted.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3"}
{"base": "0154_motion_edit_turn_away_086bce5203ef", "edited_type": "motion_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person turn around to face away from the camera throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [3, 3, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person is turned away, but the motion is incorrect, and the person's identity changes when they turn.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2"}
{"base": "0148_motion_edit_stand_up_1379cde8e7fd", "edited_type": "motion_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person stand up throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [3, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person is changed to a standing pose, but the action of standing up is not performed.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3"}
{"base": "0161_motion_edit_turn_to_camera_14863dbcb200", "edited_type": "motion_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person turn around to face the camera throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [3, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person only turns their head momentarily, and the reflection in the mirror does not change.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3"}
{"base": "0136_motion_edit_sit_down_0409027ceeb8", "edited_type": "motion_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person sit down throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [4, 4, 4], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person is sitting on an invisible chair, but the edit is clean and preserves the background perfectly.\nInstruction Compliance: 4\nVisual Quality & Stability: 4\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 4"}
{"base": "0155_motion_edit_turn_away_0c03f4e28fd0", "edited_type": "motion_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person turn around to face away from the camera throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [3, 2, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person turns towards the camera instead of away, and their shirt changes type mid-edit.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3"}
{"base": "0158_motion_edit_turn_away_136240ee4acd", "edited_type": "motion_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person turn around to face away from the camera throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [3, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person turns back towards the camera, failing to face away throughout the video as instructed.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3"}
{"base": "0140_motion_edit_sit_down_0b3680008411", "edited_type": "motion_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person sit down throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [2, 2, 2], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person is sitting, but it's a static image, not a movement. Clothing and facial features are changed.\nInstruction Compliance: 2\nVisual Quality & Stability: 2\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 2"}
{"base": "0162_motion_edit_turn_to_camera_1634d6bf0bab", "edited_type": "motion_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person turn around to face the camera throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [3, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person's head turns to face the camera, but the body's turn is incomplete and unnatural.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3"}
{"base": "0159_motion_edit_turn_away_1a0bd5760e84", "edited_type": "motion_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person turn around to face away from the camera throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [3, 3, 3], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The edit shows the person facing away, but omits the action of turning, making the instruction incomplete.\nInstruction Compliance: 3\nVisual Quality & Stability: 3\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 3"}
{"base": "0146_motion_edit_stand_up_07c1271ef2a7", "edited_type": "motion_edit", "prompt": "Make the visible person stand up throughout the video while preserving identity, clothing, background, lighting, motion, camera viewpoint, and temporal consistency. Keep the camera unchanged.", "scores": [5, 4, 5], "protocol": "gemini_video", "rubric": "i2v-transfer", "model": "gemini-2.5-pro", "repo": "sanaka87/openve_pp_joyai_video_edit", "raw": "Brief reasoning: The person is now standing for the whole video as requested. The edit is clean and preserves all details.\nInstruction Compliance: 5\nVisual Quality & Stability: 4\nConsistency & Detail Fidelity: 5"}